D (@HopeForTo) header
D (@HopeForTo) profile picture

Respect what others value, it goes both ways. The world needs to stop shouting & start listening. No one is above another

Joined December 2012
Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)Photo by D (@HopeForTo)
Forced therapy for a young person is a violation of human rights. The language coming out of Milburn is a violation of actual law. Courts are going to experience log jam like never before.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
16
225
3
1,095
8,851
Extremely worrying to see how out of touch Milburn is, especially about mental illness and neurodevelopmental disorders. Someone needs to school him.
Milburn classes autism as mental illness rather than a lifelong neurodevelopmental condition. Shocking ignorance.
19
105
8
372
5,236
Keeping PIP The Ignored Side - @DailyMail @TheSun @GMB @BBCPolitics @itvnews @UKLabour @andyburnham @labourlewis @UNHumanRights @thetimes @FinancialTimes @Conservatives @Telegraph Keeping PIP & UC will cost DWP £3.4 billion a year. However, once you count wider GDP growth, job retention, and avoided NHS and homelessness bills, keeping the safety net while funding support delivers a net positive return to the UK economy. Keeping PIP means disabled young people can actually afford the specialized transport, sensory aids, or support needed to stay in those new jobs—protecting the +£1bn to +£2.4bn in new tax and economic output rather than seeing them drop back out of work. GDP Multiplier (+£2bn to +£5bn+): Retaining £3.6 billion in PIP and UC payments keeps that money circulating immediately in local supermarkets, utilities, and high streets. Even using the OBR’s conservative 0.6 multiplier, keeping that money in claimants' pockets preserves ~£2.16 billion a year in GDP (and up to £5.4 billion using higher low-income multipliers). Avoided Crisis Costs (+£1bn to £3bn+): Keeping the financial safety net prevents the cost-shunting of eviction, temporary council housing (£15k–£30k per person), food bank reliance, and acute NHS mental health admissions. (For comparison, TUC economic modelling of a targeted youth jobs guarantee without benefit cuts estimated a return of £2.69 for every £1 spent in combined tax, productivity, and public service savings). Keeping PIP and the UC health element intact while funding targeted employment support produces a net positive return to the UK economy of roughly +£3.5 billion to +£7.5 billion per year compared to cutting those benefits. Even if you strip out gross wages so you aren't double-counting GDP and look strictly at public-sector and local demand value, the net gain is still +£3.5 billion to +£7.0 billion a year.
19
Replying to @Telegraph
@Telegraph @UKLabour @conservatives @LibDems @BBCNews @GMB @DailyMirror @JohnHealey_MP @andyburnham PIP 16-24 year olds shunting the costs onto Councils, NHS, making disabled people destitute while not actually saving money because it increases spend required for local councils & NHS.
Replying to @UKLabour
@UKLabour @andyburnham @UNHumanRights @alanmilburn1958 @TheSun @DailyMail Article 14 (Prohibition of Discrimination) read with Article 1 of Protocol 1 (Protection of Property)Article 3 (Prohibition of Inhuman or Degrading Treatment): Stripping a vulnerable young person of all subsistence funds (via a 100% Youth Allowance sanction) when their non-engagement is caused by autism-related executive dysfunction, sensory overload, or communication barriers could trigger Article 3 or Equality Act 2010 challenges if adequate safeguards aren't followed. In short this government want our Autistic children to become destitute with no access to any funds, to starve & ultimately die. Sensory overload does not go away. YOS are poorly equipped to judge when pushing an autistic young person into an environment will cause genuine psychological or physical harm. a YOS adviser is measured on targets to reduce NEET numbers and move young people into work or training. Putting the same non-medical person in charge of both certifying illness (fit notes) and policing benefit sanctions creates a direct conflict of interest. There is strong historical evidence showing that combining benefit sanctions with non-clinical assessments for vulnerable people carries a documented risk of severe psychological distress, destitution, and suicide.
8
Replying to @TheSun
@TheSun @GMB @BBCNews @DailyMail @Daily_Express @guardian @GBNEWS @TalkTV @LBC @Independent @Channel4News @andyburnham @UKLabour And this is the man that Burnham has given the role as Chair of the new Youth Opportunities Unit.
After reflecting on his report, I've decided to post a recording of my attempt to interview #AlanMilburn at #Labour conference in Sept about his failure to address the safeguarding risks of his #NEETs approach. It contains adult language. He starts to get angry about 50 secs in:
17
Replying to @DailyMail
@DailyMail @TheSun @GMB @BBCPolitics @itvnews @UKLabour @andyburnham @labourlewis @UNHumanRights @thetimes @FinancialTimes @Conservatives Keeping PIP & UC will cost DWP £3.4 billion a year. However, once you count wider GDP growth, job retention, and avoided NHS and homelessness bills, keeping the safety net while funding support delivers a net positive return to the UK economy. Keeping PIP means disabled young people can actually afford the specialized transport, sensory aids, or support needed to stay in those new jobs—protecting the +£1bn to +£2.4bn in new tax and economic output rather than seeing them drop back out of work. GDP Multiplier (+£2bn to +£5bn+): Retaining £3.6 billion in PIP and UC payments keeps that money circulating immediately in local supermarkets, utilities, and high streets. Even using the OBR’s conservative 0.6 multiplier, keeping that money in claimants' pockets preserves ~£2.16 billion a year in GDP (and up to £5.4 billion using higher low-income multipliers). Avoided Crisis Costs (+£1bn to £3bn+): Keeping the financial safety net prevents the cost-shunting of eviction, temporary council housing (£15k–£30k per person), food bank reliance, and acute NHS mental health admissions. (For comparison, TUC economic modelling of a targeted youth jobs guarantee without benefit cuts estimated a return of £2.69 for every £1 spent in combined tax, productivity, and public service savings). Keeping PIP and the UC health element intact while funding targeted employment support produces a net positive return to the UK economy of roughly +£3.5 billion to +£7.5 billion per year compared to cutting those benefits. Even if you strip out gross wages so you aren't double-counting GDP and look strictly at public-sector and local demand value, the net gain is still +£3.5 billion to +£7.0 billion a year.
19
The False Economy of "Shunting" Costs ​Economists call this cost-shunting: saving £1 in the DWP’s welfare budget by creating £2 or £3 of emergency spending in the NHS and local councils. ​Housing vs. Sanctions: If an autistic young person loses their £338/month Youth Allowance via a sanction and falls into rent arrears, saving the DWP roughly £4,000 a year can easily trigger an eviction that costs the local council £15,000 to £30,000+ a year to house them in emergency temporary accommodation. ​Lost Local Spending: Every pound taken out of a low-income disabled person's pocket is a pound immediately removed from local supermarkets, utility companies, and high streets—shrinking local tax receipts.
21
Milburn’s Report Claims It Puts Back - Net return to the Treasury: £200 million a year by 2036/37 (roughly 0.015% of UK public spending)—and that assumes his employment schemes succeed at a scale no previous UK government has achieved. What the Treasury’s Ledger Ignores: The Cost of Destitution which it says it wants to solve but simultaneously pushing Autistic. ADHD & Mental Health into costs this country Consequence of Removing Support Direct Cost to UK Public Services & Economy Hunger & Malnutrition Hunger and material hardship cost the UK economy £75+ billion a year (projected to hit £79.1 billion by 2026/27). Malnutrition alone costs the NHS roughly £22.6 billion a year in hospital admissions and slower recovery. Homelessness & Eviction Pushing vulnerable young people into rent arrears drives £3 billion a year in statutory local council homelessness spending (temporary accommodation, B&Bs) plus £67 million on rough sleeping. Acute NHS & Mental Health Crises Deprivation and destitution add £6.3 billion a year in extra healthcare spending. People in the most deprived groups are nearly twice as likely to attend A&E, and critical care hospital beds cost over £2,000 per day. Lost Productivity & Crime Hunger and severe hardship cost £38.2 billion a year in reduced employment and productivity (resulting in £18.4 billion in lost tax revenue), alongside billions in policing, courts, and social care intervention.
1
28
Replying to @UKLabour
@UKLabour @andyburnham @UNHumanRights @alanmilburn1958 @TheSun @DailyMail Article 14 (Prohibition of Discrimination) read with Article 1 of Protocol 1 (Protection of Property)Article 3 (Prohibition of Inhuman or Degrading Treatment): Stripping a vulnerable young person of all subsistence funds (via a 100% Youth Allowance sanction) when their non-engagement is caused by autism-related executive dysfunction, sensory overload, or communication barriers could trigger Article 3 or Equality Act 2010 challenges if adequate safeguards aren't followed. In short this government want our Autistic children to become destitute with no access to any funds, to starve & ultimately die. Sensory overload does not go away. YOS are poorly equipped to judge when pushing an autistic young person into an environment will cause genuine psychological or physical harm. a YOS adviser is measured on targets to reduce NEET numbers and move young people into work or training. Putting the same non-medical person in charge of both certifying illness (fit notes) and policing benefit sanctions creates a direct conflict of interest. There is strong historical evidence showing that combining benefit sanctions with non-clinical assessments for vulnerable people carries a documented risk of severe psychological distress, destitution, and suicide.
omg just realized that Milburn de facto advocates for MANDATORY talking therapy or sensory management courses for autistic people, or else they will be sanctioned. This is extremely unethical.
1
1
1
2
104
Quick Google suggests disability law is being tested ECHR must have something to say #SEND
3
14
28
517
When you are pushing thousands of young disabled people 16-24, with mental health issues, ADHD & Autisim (lifelong neurodevelopmental differences rather than illnesses to be "cured" or "treated) into poverty & suicidal thoughts & suicide, you now say 100k anually - EU citizens can come & take those same jobs you want them to apply for. So in effect you as per the Milburn report will expect them to live on £338 Per Month & because of this, & the report which says if they can't engage or find employment you will reduce this amount. The transfer of this age group was EU to UK 130K to 180k annually UK TO EU roughly 85k. Why do you hate our disabled youth & non disabled youth so much. This will not help our unemployed & disabled community at all, as it has never been more able to move to the EU than come here. @andyburnham @UKLabour
16
Dear John Lewis, This is how you do a Christmas advert. You’re welcome 😭
228
1,464
103
8,237
293,521
Replying to @UKLabour
@UKLabour @andyburnham Who'd of thought!!! Statistics/recommendations moulded to the report not the other way around. @DailyMirror @DailyMirror @DailyMail @TheSun
After FullFact’s revelation yesterday that the Milburn report was wrong about GP sick notes, I thought every claim in the report required careful fact checking. This thread will contain fact checking as far as I can muster.
16
These are not "difficult" choices, you are choosing to sponsor sucide and state suicide.
13
Replying to @anneliese_midge
What happens after 6 months? They get put back right where they started. The saving is upto £200 million by year 10. £20 million per year. Did they also tell you, they also want to use positive discrimination against all the other people unemployed. Pitting each section of society against another. Instead of solving the mess they have made, with the business world in the last two years.
22
Replying to @anneliese_midge
Leaving out the point that a neurodiverse person will be expected to survive on £338 per month? Just over 4k per year. How that will pay for food, bills & accommodation? How by if they cannot engage because of their learning difficulties, speech & comprehension difficulties that the £338 will be stripped as a further punishment. So our son who is Autistic, with severe learning delays, and language disorder, who has toileting accidents everyday because he doesn't realise the urge to wee or poo. Who has to have help wash, dress, be prompted to eat/drink & further help will be left destitute, starving when we are no longer here all because Labour hate the disabled & dont get that PIP is not because you dont work, it helps with your everyday care needs. Instead the funding for extra help, they are giving it to councils who multiple times let disabled adults & children down, up & down the country.
1
32
So that is okay by you judging by your statement. A disabled person, particularly neurodiverse as collateral damage. It doesn't matter that they can't afford to live or eat on £338 per month and yet employment is also not possible. So what the result is loss of life? That's not just as you put it "being cruel to be kind", that is society failing and endorsing state suicide/death. Autism with its co diagnosis's is not a health condition. You don't recover from it.
10
Paragraph 109 "Paragraph 109: States that young people with conditions such as anxiety, depression, ADHD, and autism—who currently make up the majority of new Personal Independence Payment (PIP) claimants—should be particular beneficiaries of the new, participation-focused approach rather than being placed onto long-term out-of-work disability benefits." Shows this government understands zero of either. When our son reaches 16 & has to go cap in hand to the LA for the additional help & envitabley doesnt get it because it's the same LA who broke several statutes of SEND & parts of the Children's & Family Act 2014 all because of Maladministration. The same authority who have failed many children in this area & is repeated multiple times across the country. Why should he when he's old enough & others have to beg to live. Employment doesn't cover the extra costs of being disabled or help required & these additional proposed funds are not expected to cover them.
1
22