Jan Heitmann retweeted
I am a member of the Norwegian Nobel Committee.
There are five of us. Five people, appointed by a parliament most of the planet could not find on a map, who decide, once a year, which human being the world has agreed to call good.
I know. I know. I think about it on the tram.
We meet in a building on Henrik Ibsens gate, a street named after a man who wrote almost exclusively about people discovering they are frauds, which nobody on the committee finds funny except me. There is a room with a long table and the portraits of the dead laureates looking down, Mandela, the Dalai Lama, a great many earnest men in spectacles, and one portrait we do not discuss, which is Kissinger, 1973, awarded while the bombs were still falling, after which two of our predecessors resigned and the satirist Tom Lehrer said political satire was now obsolete. We keep him on the wall. A reminder. Every family has the uncle.
It is October in Oslo, which means the sun gives up around four in the afternoon like a civil servant, and it rains the particular Norwegian rain that isnât quite falling, just hanging there, judging you. I arrive with wet shoes. I always arrive with wet shoes. There is coffee, because this is Norway and there is always coffee, we drink more of it per person than almost anyone alive, and someoneâs wife has sent kanelboller, the cinnamon buns, and we sit, five Norwegians, damp, caffeinated, sugared, and we decide the moral standing of the entire species.
Let me tell you how it actually works, because the world imagines a cathedral and it is, I promise you, a book club with a mandate.
287 nominations this year. 208 people, 79 organizations. Anyone can nominate, thatâs the secret nobody understands: a professor, a parliamentarian, a former laureate, so the ânomineeâ list is meaningless, itâs a suggestion box, and every autumn some congressman nominates his own golden retriever and the press writes âSHORTLISTED.â Nobody is shortlisted. There is no short list the public ever sees. There is us, and the coffee, and the rain, and the portraits, and a Norwegian stubbornness that is older than the prize itself.
We read reports. The instituteâs advisers write them, thick dull documents, and we argue. Our chairman told the BBC once that in the final meeting âthere is a high temperature.â High temperature, for a Norwegian, means someone slightly raised an eyebrow and then apologized for it. We donât do high temperature. We do a long silence, and then Kristin says âwell,â and everyone knows exactly what âwellâ meant, and itâs settled. Thatâs our shouting. âWell.â Youâd have to be raised here to hear the violence in it.
Now. This year. I will not say the name, because we never say the name, but you know the name.
A certain head of state wanted this prize the way a child wants a thing in a shop window, which is to say loudly, and in public, and with the full belief that wanting it was itself the argument. He said he deserved it. He said heâd ended eight wars, a number that grew most times he said it, like a fish. He had other heads of state phone us. Israelâs prime minister posted it on the internet, âGive him the Nobel.â The leaders of Cambodia and Pakistan announced theyâd nominated him, as though announcing it were part of it, as though we tally mentions. A man flew around the globe collecting endorsements for a Norwegian committee the way youâd collect signatures for a petition to the council about a noisy dog.
And here, uff da, is the detail I treasure, the one that makes me smile into my coffee. The nomination deadline is the 31st of January. He took office on the 20th. So for all the phone calls, all the posts, all the gilded lobbying, the only nominations that could possibly count for this yearâs prize were filed in the first eleven days of his term, before he had, by his own arithmetic, ended a single one of the eight wars. He campaigned all year for a prize whose window had shut while he was still hanging up his coat. We didnât have to reject him. The calendar did. We just watched. Norwegians are very good at watching. We have long winters.
People think we sit there weighing his deeds. We donât. Thatâs the thing I canât make the world understand. Weâre not grading his homework. We donât owe anyone the prize for a ceasefire, however real, however loud the announcement. âHe made peaceâ is not a sentence that ends in a medal, the way he believes it does, the way he believes every good thing ends in his name on it. The will of a dead Swede says the prize goes to whoever did the most for fraternity between nations. A dead Swede, I should add, who made his entire fortune inventing dynamite and selling arms, and spent his last years horrified at his own obituary, which called him a merchant of death, and so bought his way to immortality as a man of peace. The whole prize is one guilty arms dealerâs attempt to launder his name. We are, all of us, administering a dead manâs public relations. I find this clarifying. It keeps me humble. It should keep everyone humble, and it keeps, by my count, no one humble at all.
So who did we give it to?
An eighty-five-year-old woman. A judge. Born in Durban, under apartheid, granddaughter of a Tamil man who came to South Africa as indentured labor, a bus driverâs daughter from the poor Indian quarter, who became the first non-white woman to run a law practice in her province, who defended Mandelaâs people when defending them was dangerous, who sat on the Rwanda tribunal and the court at the Hague, and who, at eighty-five, is right now a judge weighing whether a genocide is a genocide. When we told the world, our chairman said the rule of law âunderpins the system we have set up to ensure peace,â and that âpeace requires justice.â She wasnât even in Oslo. She was in Nuremberg. In courtroom 600. The actual room where they tried the Nazis. You cannot stage that. God staged that, and God, it turns out, is a better satirist than any of us.
She did not phone us. She did not post. No prime minister demanded it for her on the internet. She had, as far as our deliberations are concerned, the one qualification the loud man could never manufacture, which is that she wanted the work and not the medal. The medal finds those people. It flees the ones who chase it. This is not a rule we wrote. Itâs just the only pattern the hundred-odd years of our mistakes has ever shown.
The reaction from across the ocean was immediate. His spokesman posted that we âplace politics over peace.â Ja. Perhaps. Weâre five damp pensioners in a rainy city; of course itâs political, it was always political, it was political when we gave it to a sitting American president nine months into his first term for the promise of things he had not yet done, and we have been quietly embarrassed about that one for fifteen years, so believe me, we had a particular reason this year to prefer a woman with fifty years of verdicts behind her over a man with eight wars in front of him and a deadline already behind him.
Here is what he will never understand, the thing Iâd tell him on the tram if he ever took one. We are the one prize he cannot buy, cannot post his way to, cannot have a friendly dictator phone in for him. Not because weâre incorruptible, nei, weâre as vain and wrong and human as the portraits on our wall. But because the entire point of the thing, the only power a small cold countryâs book club has ever held, is that it goes to the person not performing the wanting. The moment you demand it, youâve proven you donât understand what itâs for, and proving that is itself the disqualification. He ran the most expensive campaign in the history of the prize and the campaign was the reason. He was never losing to Navi Pillay. He was losing to the concept.
Itâs dark now. Four oâclock dark. The buns are gone. Kristin said âwellâ an hour ago and we all went home. Iâm on the tram with my wet shoes, and somewhere across the water a very powerful man is explaining to a camera that the prize is rigged, that weâre corrupt, that heâll win it next year, and he genuinely might, weâre only five idiots and weâve been wrong before, Kissinger is still on the wall.
But not this year. This year an old woman in Nuremberg, in the room where the law once stared down the exact kind of man who thinks wanting a thing loudly enough should make it his, got a phone call she didnât ask for.
Thatâs the job. We donât reward the man who ends the war and announces it.
We reward the woman who spent fifty years deciding what a war was.
Heâll never see the difference. Thatâs rather the whole point of him.
Takk for i dag. I have to change trams.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
The problem here is 'legalism', not scientism. Forget whether the player's hair touched the ball or not. Here's what the offside rule was originally created for: a striker breaks through the defense early or purposely stays behind, finds himself with ten yards of open grass between him and the last defender and only the goalkeeper in front. The rule is one of the oldest in the game because the people who first played it saw something clearly unfair about it, i.e., an advantage that doesn't require skill to create, which, if allowed, would have made the game unwatchable. The problem is that over time people began to conflate the advantage aspect with the mechanics of detecting it, especially since TV programs in the 70s began showing slow-motion replays of gray-area calls over and over in post-match analysis to keep football fans endlessly arguing and their ratings high. This is how you get, for instance, cases in which a forward who times his run perfectly, catching the defender off guard (often running in the opposite direction) and then scoring, is still called "unfair" by other fans because his shoulder or nose or whatever was ahead when the pass occurred, despite the fact that if it would have been behind, if anything, it'd have given him even *more* time to score. It's the same thing that often happens in court. A law is written to stop a particular harm, then lawyers spend decades arguing over the exact wording until the very harm it was meant to stop gets almost forgotten and the letter becomes the law. Nobody watching Croatia's disallowed goal possibly believes that the Croatian playerâs touch (even if it happened) created an advantage for his teammate. The ball clearly reaches the latter thanks to the (non-deliberate, thus irrelevant) deflection off the Portugal player. But nobody is thinking about the purpose of the rule anymore, only the technicality of its wording. Hence scientism, which is downstream of legalism in this context and eventually convinced the entire sport that it needed sensors inside the football to detect a hair touch because... why not?
Croatia's disallowed goal highlights scientism's core ideology that "data" is truth: but it is simply not. It is obvious to the naked eye that the ball direction is not altered by the player's head. That is truth. The blip on the sensor could simply be put there later, it could correspond to an earlier or later touch. If it is isolated from the other previous or subsequent touches it could simply be an added graphic. Data is how to fool people that lies are truth, because it is the easiest thing to manipulate. Trust your own judgment always: you don't see a touch? There is no touch.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
1/
Everyone who's read Scott Alexander's "Meditations on Moloch" walks away with the same sinking feeling:
"We're trapped. Individual rationality leads to collective doom. There's no way out."
I believed this for years.
I was wrong.
2/
First, let's make sure we're talking about the same demon.
Moloch is the god of coordination failure.
He's the reason we destroy the things we love through the act of competing for them.
3/
Moloch is:
The arms race no one wanted but everyone joined
The ocean fished to collapse by rational fishermen
The inbox that devours evenings because "everyone else is online"
The hiring process bloated with signals no one believes but everyone requires
4/
The pattern is always the same:
Each person makes a locally rational choice. Those choices aggregate into collective catastrophe. Everyone sees it happening. No one can stop.
It feels like gravity. Inevitable. Structural.
5/
Here's what changed my mind:
A simple question I'd never thought to ask.
"If Moloch is inevitable, why isn't everything already Moloch'd?"
6/
Think about it.
Humans have been optimizing for thousands of years.
If coordination failure was truly inescapable, we should be living in a hellscape of pure defection.
We're not.
Something is holding Moloch back.
7/
That something has a structure.
And once you see the structure, you realize:
Moloch doesn't win by default.
He wins when four specific conditions are met.
Remove any one of them, and he weakens.
Remove enough, and he loses.
8/
Moloch's Four Requirements:
Coordination is impossible (no communication, no trust)
Defection is invisible (you can cheat without being seen)
Defection is unpunishable (even if caught, no consequences)
Cooperation isn't rewarded (nice guys finish last)
9/
Read that list again.
Those aren't laws of physics.
They're design parameters.
Parameters that humans have successfully altered before.
10/
Existence Proof #1: Rule of Law
Before: "Might makes right" â constant low-level violence â no investment in future â everyone worse off
This was Moloch winning.
11/
Then something happened.
Humans invented legal systems.
Suddenly:
Defection (violence, theft) became visible (witnesses, evidence)
Defection became punishable (courts, enforcement)
Cooperation became rewarded (contracts became enforceable)
12/
The result?
Violence dropped. Trade increased. Investment became possible.
Not utopia. But measurably, dramatically better.
Moloch didn't disappear.
He was pushed back.
13/
Existence Proof #2: Property Rights
The tragedy of the commons is Moloch's favorite game.
Everyone overgrazes. The commons dies. Everyone loses.
"Inevitable," we're told.
14/
Except... it's not.
When communities developed property normsâwhether private ownership or collective management with rulesâthe dynamic shifted.
Defection became visible. Consequences became real. Stewardship became rational.
15/
Existence Proof #3: Democratic Succession
For most of history, power transferred through violence.
King dies â succession war â thousands dead â winner takes throne â repeat.
Pure Moloch.
16/
Then humans invented something weird:
Elections.
Peaceful power transfer. Losers accept results. Winners don't execute opponents.
Sounds impossible. Yet here we are.
17/
I'm not saying these systems are perfect.
I'm saying they exist.
They prove that coordination failures can be engineered away.
Moloch-escape isn't a fantasy. It's been done.
Repeatedly.
18/
So what's the actual formula?
Invert Moloch's four requirements:
â Build coordination infrastructure (communication + trust)
â Make defection visible (transparency architecture)
â Make defection costly (credible commitment mechanisms)
â Make cooperation pay (positive-sum structure)
19/
This is engineering, not prayer.
You don't beat Moloch by being virtuous.
You beat him by changing the game so that selfish actors accidentally cooperate.
20/
This is the secret hidden in plain sight:
Every institution that works is a Moloch-trap.
Markets. Courts. Democracies. Professional norms. Reputation systems.
All are mechanisms that convert individual selfishness into collective benefit.
21/
"But wait," you say. "These systems are failing. Moloch is winning."
Fair.
Let me reframe:
These systems are eroding.
Moloch doesn't conquerâhe corrodes.
22/
Here's the brutal truth:
Alignment isn't a state. It's a process.
Every Moloch-trap requires active maintenance.
Stop maintaining, and Moloch seeps back in.
23/
This is actually good news.
It means the question isn't "Can we escape Moloch?"
It's "Are we willing to maintain our escapes?"
24/
The generation that built rule of law, property rights, democratic normsâthey did impossible things.
Not because they were smarter.
Because they understood something we've forgotten:
Coordination problems are solvable.
25/
New Moloch-traps are needed now.
For AI development. For social media dynamics. For climate coordination. For attention economics.
The old traps don't fit the new games.
26/
But the method still works:
Identify where individual rationality â collective harm
Find ways to make defection visible
Build mechanisms that make defection costly
Design structures where cooperation pays
27/
This won't happen automatically.
Moloch is the default.
Escape requires deliberate construction.
But "requires effort" â "impossible."
28/
I used to read "Meditations on Moloch" and feel despair.
Now I read it as a diagnostic manual.
Moloch isn't a god.
He's a bug.
A well-understood bug with known patches.
29/
The question isn't whether Moloch can be beaten.
History already answered that.
The question is whether we'll build the next generation of traps before the current ones finish eroding.
30/
Moloch is not inevitable.
He's just patient.
And he's betting we've forgotten how to fight.
Let's prove him wrong.
/end
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Every year, it gets more difficult to predict the Super Bowl result based on the quarterback interviews in the week leading to it. They get so much media training, so most responses are prepared. Sometimes a kid asks a question that triggers a real response, but most journalists just butter them up.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
CHRISTOPHER WALKEN reads the lyrics to Lady Gaga's Pokerface in true Walken style.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Pre-pandemic our president, Erin Lydon did a @TEDTalks on #EqualPay. It began with a clip of the #WorldCup-winning US team chanting for equal pay & ended with solutions to address the problem. But if Erin gave that same TEDx today, she would only offer one solution: Play Poker âŁïž
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Everyone is gambling, all the time.
The "risk takers" have the courage to attempt something and gamble with the possibility of failure.
The "risk averse" avoid failure, but gamble with the opportunity cost of what they could have achievedâhad they found the courage to try.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
When we get better at poker, we get better at life. Poker teaches us to be more realistic, more strategic, more patient. When we carry these qualities from the table into life, life gets easier. And then, poker gets easier. Hereâs to getting better. At everything.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Really good thread, scroll up!
Replying to @RageSheen
âŠnot only can you avoid doing any public health work at all, but people will actually celebrate that absence as freedom. Millions die, and people do nothing, because conformity has been used to weaponise helplessness. 17/17
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Navigating the Tug-of-War Between Love and Obsessive Drive
I've been:
- self-employed w/ big dreams for 15yrs
- married for 7.5
- father for 4
- learning from plenty of mistakes!
If you've said, "Sorry, honey. This week is crazy" in the last 2 months, this thread is for you đ§”
Jan Heitmann retweeted
GlĂŒckwunsch Max Kruse.....
tinyurl.com/mtcbtswb
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Er hat es wirklich geschafft. Max Kruse hat sich den Traum eines jeden Pokerspielers erfĂŒllt und ein WSOP Bracelet gewonnen. Details bald bei sport1.de/poker
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Endlich kann auch Max Kruse ĂŒber ein Bracelet jubeln. Der FuĂball Profi setzte sich beim ⏠1.500 + 150 NLH 6-max Event # 7 der WSOPE im King's Resort Rozvadov durch und sicherte sich so ⏠124.152, das âŹ10k WSOPE Ticket und sein erstes Bracelet. buff.ly/3TsiRT4
Absolut empfehlenswerte Doku!! Schaut es euch an. @CrownUpGuy erzĂ€hlt seine Geschichte und lĂ€sst Poker dabei gut aussehen. Sich auch. đ
Die Doku-Serie "Money Maker" erzĂ€hlt die Geschichte des deutschen #Poker-Weltmeisters Fedor Holz â um 22:50 Uhr im Ersten und jetzt in der #ARDMediathek: 1.ard.de/money-maker-fedor-h⊠@CrownUpGuy
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Jenny Just of @joinpokerpower explains how playing poker can build confidence for women in business to @JBoorstin at CNBC's #Disruptor50 Summit.
Jan Heitmann retweeted
Das hat mir der Liebe @Gaggo79 gestern nach meinem Bust aus dem Road to PSPC Mainevent geschickt. Hab es schon vor 4 Jahren gepostet. Manchmal ist es notwendig, dass dich jemand anderes an deine eigenen Worte erinnert. â at Thermi, Greece
























