Jane McCarthy (@JaneMcC149) profile picture

This is my personal account, all opinions my own. #XDissenter Sociologist, activist, hopefully Woke

South East England
Joined May 2018
Photo by Jane McCarthy (@JaneMcC149)Photo by Jane McCarthy (@JaneMcC149)
A man who died 23 years ago may explain Palestine better than anyone on television today. A new documentary has brought Edward Said back to life. And if you want to understand Palestine, the Western media, and why an entire people have spent generations fighting for the right to tell their own story, put this film on your must-watch list. Edward Said: Between Worlds (2026), directed by Maiken Baird, is a 107-minute documentary unlike the usual parade of historians and experts telling us what to think. For the first time, filmmakers were given full access to the Said family archives. Decades of previously unseen home movies, private recordings, rare television interviews, public confrontations and lectures have been assembled into a film in which Said largely tells his own story. It premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival, has travelled to festivals around the world and won a Special Jury Prize in São Paulo. But who was Edward Said? Born in Jerusalem in 1935, he became one of the twentieth century's most influential intellectuals, teaching at Columbia University and writing Orientalism, the 1978 book that exposed how the West had spent centuries inventing its own versions of Eastern peoples, describing them, classifying them and claiming intellectual authority over them. A Palestinian telling the West that perhaps the people it had colonised understood their own existence better than their colonisers did. And doing so with such intellectual brilliance that ignoring him became increasingly difficult. One particularly devastating moment in the documentary takes us back to 1992. Said returns to the Jerusalem house where he played as a little boy, captured in the family home movies his father had filmed. The house is still there. His childhood isn't. And the building now houses an office of a Christian Zionist organisation. He cannot bring himself to knock. That single scene says more about exile than a hundred political speeches. Said died in 2003. He never lived to see what happened to Gaza after October 7, 2023. But he spent decades explaining how Palestinians were dispossessed not only of their land, but of the authority to describe what had happened to them. And why their suffering so often had to be translated into language acceptable to Western audiences before it was considered worthy of attention. That is what makes this documentary so urgently relevant. In a world overflowing with people explaining Palestinians to everybody else, here is a Palestinian explaining himself. No one can accuse Edward Said of having nothing to say. The question is whether we are finally prepared to listen. Edward Said: Between Worlds (2026). Remember the title. Watch it when you get the opportunity.
65
1,263
59
2,246
39,342
Jane McCarthy retweeted
it is not a failure of journalism, it is a systemic failure in liberal democracy that allows the billionaire class to capture our politicians, by allowing them to buy up all our media. MediaFreedomAct.org/take-act…
1
1
1
8
Jane McCarthy retweeted
'21% of people hospitalized with COVID-19 and 11% of those who were not hospitalized for COVID-19 developed high blood pressure'. newsroom.heart.org/news/covi… We have known this for well over three years.
5
185
6
474
7,532
THIS is the biggest scandal of our times. If you aren’t understanding that this is a cover-up & Covid is harming population health on a grand scale I don’t know what to tell you 🫠
Covid in England NHS England due to end the publication of Covid hospital admissions data...
8
144
3
448
4,558
Why can’t you say this 👇 @UKHSA? Do you enjoy NHS trusts having to declare critical incidents, nationwide? Seriously though, what is wrong with you?
1
40
1
125
1,095
Jane McCarthy retweeted
At last, some good news on data centres. Spain is requiring its rapidly growing number of them to slash energy and water use and prove that they are getting 80% of their energy from renewable sources. Yet again the country is setting an energy example. euronews.com/2026/11/20/spai…
10
208
10
438
5,408
He Survived the Nazis as a Jewish Child. At 87, British Police Questioned Him After He Carried Flowers for Gaza. In December 1944, seven-year-old Stephen Kapos sat down for Christmas dinner with German soldiers in Nazi-occupied Budapest. A huge swastika flag hung above the table. The soldiers had no idea that the children they were feeding were Jewish. Stephen was hiding under a false identity. Discovery could have meant death. Fifteen members of his family were murdered at Auschwitz. His father was deported to Bergen-Belsen and later Theresienstadt. Miraculously, he survived. Stephen remembered the devastated streets of Budapest: burned-out vehicles, shattered buildings, rubble, dead bodies. Eighty years later, he saw photographs of Gaza. The destruction brought those childhood memories back. He also recognized something else: the persecution of a population on a massive scale. Kapos did not claim that Gaza and the Holocaust were identical. He acknowledged important differences. But he believed Israel was committing genocide against Palestinians. And he decided to do something about it. In April 2024, he addressed an enormous pro-Palestinian demonstration in London's Hyde Park. He told the crowd about Adolf Eichmann, the deportation of Hungarian Jews and the fifteen relatives he had lost. He condemned Israel's use of Holocaust memory to justify its treatment of Palestinians. Then, on January 18, 2025, he joined another demonstration. Kapos was 87 years old. Alongside other protesters, including Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell, he participated in a delegation carrying flowers to commemorate Palestinians killed in Gaza. Police had restricted the demonstration to Whitehall. The delegation moved toward Trafalgar Square. The Metropolitan Police considered this a possible violation of the Public Order Act. Weeks later, Kapos received a summons for questioning. On March 21, 2025, the Holocaust survivor entered Charing Cross Police Station. He was questioned under caution. Outside, approximately 100 supporters gathered, including other Holocaust survivors and their descendants. Forty survivors and descendants had signed an open letter condemning his treatment. To be clear, the police investigation concerned alleged violations of protest restrictions, not Kapos's opinions about Israel. But the circumstances were extraordinary. A man who had survived the systematic persecution of Jews under Nazi rule was being questioned by British police after participating in a peaceful demonstration commemorating Palestinian victims. Kapos was not accused of violence. And he had no intention of abandoning his activism. After the interview, he said he would continue protesting. He was proud that his son and grandchildren joined him. In an article published by Al Jazeera four days later, he described the terrible memories Gaza had awakened. He also rejected attempts to portray pro-Palestinian demonstrations as inherently antisemitic. Thousands of Jews had participated in them, he pointed out. Including himself. There is something deeply wrong with invoking the Holocaust to silence people who survived it. Stephen Kapos lost fifteen relatives at Auschwitz. He spent his childhood hiding from Nazis. Eight decades later, he recognized suffering that he believed demanded his opposition. He carried flowers for Palestinians killed in Gaza. And Britain summoned him for police questioning. At 87, he was still refusing to look away.
45
1,077
46
2,079
36,600
Jane McCarthy retweeted
UK Govt looks set to accept Milburn’s call for 41% cuts to young people’s disability benefits. Looks like another version of Starmer's defeated plan. Will create destitution and hardship for many. Who will be picked on next? Organize to force a rethink. disabilitynewsservice.com/go…
94
728
41
1,208
16,018
Jane McCarthy retweeted
The smartest species ever to walk the Earth and also the most arrogant and stupid
33
510
25
1,086
8,582
Jane McCarthy retweeted
Permafrost contains almost twice as much carbon as there now is in the atmosphere, posing an immense potential threat to the climate. Now scientists have found that expected long hot summers could enable hitherto frozen microbes to release it. futura-sciences.com/en/scien…
9
92
5
158
5,968
Jane McCarthy retweeted
"Stop giving power to people who don't believe in science or worse than that, pretend they don't believe in climate change for their own self-interest." Harrison Ford There is no time to wait. #ActOnClimate #climate #energy #biodiversity #panelsnotpipelines #cdnpoli
82
374
11
671
7,918
The dramatic impacts of the climate crisis can be felt everywhere. I have just witnessed it again here at the rice terraces in Banaue, Philippines. The only effective response is urgent #ClimateAction: ending our addiction to fossil fuels, transitioning to renewables & protecting the most vulnerable. #COP31
505
427
47
1,187
50,215
Jane McCarthy retweeted
I’m struggling to find the words for the sadness, heartbreak and disbelief I feel watching what is unfolding at #COP31. How is this possible? Only recently, in Santa Marta, Colombia, governments, social movements, scientists, Indigenous peoples and frontline communities came together to confront the main driver of the climate emergency and ask how we move beyond fossil fuels. For a moment, it felt as though the political courage might finally match the urgency of the science. And now, here we are. Panama is right to draw a line. If the final text contains no commitment to phase out fossil fuel production, no meaningful climate finance and no guarantee that electrification will be powered by renewables, Panama should formally object. I stand with Panama in taking that position, and I urge other governments to stand with them. Nepal is being pushed to the point of walking out as powerful countries ignore the devastation its people have recently experienced. Fossil fuels have disappeared from the latest draft. Imagine Alcoholics Anonymous spending 30 years negotiating and producing a statement that never mentions alcohol. Now imagine the alcohol industry turning up as the largest delegation and helping shape the outcome. Every year we delay phasing out coal, oil and gas locks in more harm for people already living through this crisis and leaves future generations with a more dangerous world. We are on course to exceed 1.5°C of long-term warming. Every fraction of a degree matters. How can governments claim to defend that goal while refusing to confront the continued production of the fuels pushing us beyond it? The proposed commitment on adaptation finance has also disappeared. And we are still expected to call this progress. What are we to call a system in which those who have contributed least to the crisis suffer its worst consequences, while those with the greatest responsibility protect fossil fuel profits? Is this climate apartheid? What breaks my heart is that we know what is at stake. People are losing their homes, their livelihoods and their lives. Communities are struggling to hold on to places that have sustained their cultures for generations. Entire countries are fighting for their survival. And after Santa Marta, we are still negotiating away the very words we need to name the problem. What does electrification achieve if we leave open the question of how it will be powered? How are countries supposed to deliver on their climate commitments without the finance to do so? How can we call it a just transition if we refuse to confront the continued production of the fuels driving the injustice? History will judge these talks by whose lives were protected, whose interests were defended and whose future was sacrificed. We still have time to change the outcome. I’m asking the governments that came to Santa Marta, and every government that has promised to stand with frontline communities, to speak up now and insist that the COP31 outcome commits to a fast, fair and funded phase-out of fossil fuels. And to our allies here at COP31, come in early, raise your voices and stand with the countries holding the line. We owe this fight to the people already living through the crisis, to the young people whose futures are being decided in these rooms, and to those who will inherit the consequences of what we do here. There is still time to choose courage. Let’s use every hour we have. @AFP @Reuters @AP @nytimes @FinancialTimes @guardian @washingtonpost @TheEconomist @Bloomberg @BBCWorld @CNN @AJEnglish @politico @lemondefr @FRANCE24 @radiofrance_XIX @el_pais @POLITICOEurope @derspiegel @euronews @CarbonBrief @ClimateHome @insideclimate
112
357
41
861
47,169
Jane McCarthy retweeted
Give the ‘celebrity’ sexual predators in the news, this Tracy Ullman sketch from 2018 couldn’t be more apposite:
“Have you recently been outed as a s*x pest?” I obviously can't say for sure who was the inspiration behind this sketch from series three of Tracey Ullman’s Show (2016 - 2018), but I can certainly shadow a guess! She really is bloody good, don’t you think? By the way, did you know that The Simpsons began life as a series of animated shorts that were broadcast between sketches on The Tracey Ullman Show, way back in 1987.
12
189
1
770
46,186
The International Court of Justice has ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya people, killing at least 10,000 people. It marks the first time the United Nations’ highest court has held a state responsible for genocide. “Never again” means little unless the world comes together to defend human dignity, hold perpetrators accountable and protect the persecuted. We thank people and government of The Gambia for refusing to let the world look away. More than 1 million refugees remain displaced. They will not be forgotten. The Rohingya people deserve justice.
1,025
5,674
140
38,628
675,206
Jane McCarthy retweeted
Today Daniel Thomas pleaded guilty to a crime that he recorded himself committing. He has a previous conviction for attempting a kidnapping while armed with a knife, in a dispute over £10,000 of drugs. He was already on bail for charges including using threatening or abusive words or behaviour and using racially abusive words or behaviour. The accounts on here presenting him as a "political prisoner" know all of these things and are hoping you don't. Call them out.
69
863
42
3,771
75,896
Jane McCarthy retweeted
Yesterday, my aunt was in the little kitchen inside her tent when a bullet came through. One of those bullets soldiers fire for amusement along the border. It landed just inches away from her. A little while ago, my uncle was shot in the foot by a stray bullet while he was inside his tent. The bullet tore through the tissue in his foot, and tonight he is in the hospital. I keep thinking about how they used to live. They each had a big home. My uncle's house was four stories high, with eight apartments and a little garden in front. A whole family had a place to call home. Now he lives under a piece of fabric that cannot protect him from the cold, the summer heat, insects, or even a bullet. Yesterday, my aunt could have been killed while preparing food. Today, my uncle was wounded without even leaving his tent. The tent is our nightmare.
36
423
20
695
9,093
Jane McCarthy retweeted
Israel armed the Myanmar army while it committed genocide against the Rohingya people. The least surprising news ever.
Aside from implications on future #GazaGenocide rulings, it is important to remember that the Zionist regime actively contributed to the #RohingyaGenocide with arms sales that continued at least until 2022
173
2,820
65
5,908
67,173
I don’t think there is anyone in any position of power in British media who understands this or looks beneath the surface of climate change headlines. It’s the biggest and most dangerous failure in the history of journalism with huge consequences.
HANSEN TEAM: 2026 WILL SURGE TO RECORD WARMING October all-time monthly increase, put at 1.78°C by NASA GISS Copernicus was a bit lower at 1.75°C. That's El Niño boost on record warming mailchi.mp/caa/horse-race-up… #climatechange. #globalwarming
2
15
37
1,146