Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
It’s almost poetic that the tagline of this article decries movements for “ethics in games journalism” before the article itself proceeds to spit in the face of the principles outlined in the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics:
-"Provide context. Take special care not to misrepresent or oversimplify in promoting, previewing or summarising a story": By omitting all mention of Thomas Lockley’s questionable status as an accurate historical source, as well as Ubisoft’s blatant use of plagiarism and mistranslations in the game and its promotional material, the article removes crucial information that contextualises the underlying criticism that people have been levelling against the game this whole time - that Ubisoft doesn’t actually care about Japanese culture, history or people, and is only claiming to by disingenuously venerating Yasuke as a ‘historical’ figure.
-"Be vigilant and courageous about holding those with power accountable. Give voice to the voiceless": The article is written with the underlying premise that Ubisoft is synonymous with (or at least aligned with) voiceless ‘minorities’ who have now been silenced once again by the powers of the “reactionary right wing movement.” This is ass-backwards. Ubisoft is a billion-dollar company that is currently meat-puppeting the culture and history of a (non-English speaking) nation for the purposes of marketing an upcoming game under the guise of inclusivity & cultural sensitivity. If anyone can be said to be ‘voiceless’ in this situation, it is by definition the Japanese whose opinions are, by default, excluded from Western media by virtue of the fact that they simply don’t speak English.
-"Support the open and civil exchange of views, even views they find repugnant": The fact that the article grossly oversimplifies & mischaracterises all criticisms levelled against the game as blanket “racism,” before condemning those levelling these criticisms wholesale, is needlessly polarising and blatantly sensationalist. It is no wonder the majority of people both within and without the gaming sphere dismiss contemporary journalism as nothing more than propaganda and tabloids.
-"Provide access to source material when it is relevant and appropriate": This ties in with a principle outlined in the American Press Association’s Statement of Principles which states that journalism has a duty to “make the significant interesting and relevant.” The article references “countless studies and stories proving that the radicalization of male youth has been…perpetuated by the internet.” However, instead of summarising those findings for the ease of readers, the article then shirks this responsibility by saying “go read them, as they’ll convince you far more effectively than I can.” Not only that - but the linked sources aren’t referencing any kind of scientific study, just more articles written by other journalists. I’ve yet to see a piece of gaming journalism properly summarise and reference source material for a ‘study’ or ‘story’ that isn’t this self-referencial, auto-fellatory, ouroboric loop of taking the reader to another article written by another games journalist.
-"Expose unethical conduct in journalism, including within their organisations": The article had a chance to do this when it referenced an IGN article that claimed to report on the ‘sexist’ work environment behind the scenes of “Black Myth: Wukong’s” development. The article in question was panned across the Internet for brazenly mischaracterizing statements made by one of the co-founders of the development studio (Gamescience), and using mistranslations of said statements as the basis for the story. Kotaku seems to have a penchant for excusing disingenuous mistranslation and misrepresentation, especially when it comes to non-English speaking cultures and languages - so to see this, while disappointing, is not surprising.
Game journalism is on life support and this is why.
Unhinged and objectively racist rant article by @Alyssa_merc throws in buzzwords like "Trump," "Right wing," "Hate" and even throwing in "BLM" and "MeToo" while completely misrepresenting the issues, facts and TRUE cultural appropriation by Ubisoft.
Alyssa Mercante is going after Japanese people for being upset about Assassin's Creed Shadows.
While she carefully never mentions the Japanese, we know that the entire country, celebrities,historians and politicians are the ones most upset about Ubisoft's crass handling of their culture and history. It is THEIR petition that is now at nealry 95,000 signatures.
She fails to cover any of that, or the many copyright violations, Chinese cultural mixups, stealing One-Piece's sword, or the fact that the historians Ubisoft promoted, like Lockley, were caught passing fan-fiction as fact, and even editing Wikipedia articles under an alt to promote these false depictions of Japanese culture.
You have an entire nation to answer to, Alyssa, and calling them all racist right-wingers is profoundly disturbing.
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
Replying to @Kotaku
Did the article reference stolen artwork?
Did the article reference copyright infringement in claiming the one piece Zoro Cosplay sword was called a "replica"?
Did the article mention the problem wasn't Yasuke himself, but ubisoft's presentation of him with their words?
Did the article talk about the sexual harassment claims and poor monetization practices of ubisoft? Or it being owned by a chinese company, Tencent?
In the year of 2024, with the money and resources that ubisoft has, it is absolutely appalling to think they would hire a "consultant" obsessed with "transgenerational attraction" (monks SB'ing little boys) who couldn't tell them "hey...the seasonal depiction is wrong...so are the buildings...and the use of the gates......"
Anyway, when is kotaku going to ask why the target audience didn't show up for Concord or flintlock or Zau? When is kotaku going to stop blaming everyone else for their problems?
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
Do not fall for this clickbait ass shit. Wait for your youtubers to respond to this. Giving kotaku clicks for this is exactly what this dying brand wants from you. They are desperate. They are trying to get another big win like they got with the SBI article.
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
It's the same crap they were saying 10 years ago: begging "for the games industry to stand up to it" when 99% of "it" is the BS that comes from these stupid op-eds.
The anti-woke campaigning that kicked off a few months ago is still rolling on - the language may have changed a little since Gamergate but the intention behind it has not. Forgive my simmering rage, but I've seen this way too many times before: theguardian.com/games/articl…
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
It’s not about “giving gamer gate men” fuel.
This die hard need of people to remain loyal to sides is wild. The only “sides” that there are in all of this:
Anti-censorship vs pro-censorship
Truth vs lies
Love vs intimidation
If you are for genuine creative expression for all, you are beautiful.
If you do your best to wade through the murky waters to find the truth of things, you are beautiful.
If you encourage people to tell stories, respect that there are different cultures in this world even if they challenge your own views, and use words to express yourself instead of resorting to fear and intimidation, you are beautiful.
What you want is what I want. It’s what many people want.
I believe most people are inherently beautiful. So this idea that things need to be watered down for an imaginary problem that doesn’t exist is baffling. But this shift in character design is a reflection of the people making these choices……and it’s concerning.
Both should exist but in America and Canada why does only one ever make it to market lately? It creates a pattern, a behavioral trend, and it shows nothing is genuine in AAA right now.
Check boxes stifle creativity. You should be able to create whatever character you want without being told no, you can’t represent that type of person like that. The free market should decide what will sell certainly but no one should be forced to avoid or adhere to things.
This is why I don’t like using the words gamergate or woke…why I try to only use left/right as a demographic qualifier. There are more specific problems and everything else is a distraction.
unavailable
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
Let's entertain this.
If we've got the "representation", and women were buying games in this split this whole time, why do existing franchises need to change? They were clearly inclusive towards women regardless of the game type, genre, character cast, etc.
Games were already appealing to both men and women this whole time- otherwise, if women were offended or didn't like the existing content, they wouldn't be buying and playing games, correct? We'd see the trend reverse where there were less women in games but that is not the case.
Existing franchises since 2006 were clearly split very nicely between men and women, why aren't new franchises being made? Why are existing ones problematic? According to this information right here, women have always been around in gaming and got more into gaming, liking the way the market was.
Why did journos say 'it's a man's space! there is no women!'?? This graph very elegantly debunks that claim long before they came around in 2016.
According to this, there were women and they were content because they didn't leave. In fact, the market only expanded.
So why not let existing franchises be and instead create new ones to capture even more audiences? Clearly, everything was indeed fine, according to this person and their graphs.
the point:
You can't have it both ways. You cant claim a market needs to change to include women while also stating women were included the whole time.
unavailable
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
Are you referring to the guy that Alyssa Mercante claimed was threatening her to @SmashJT via DM's and so SmashJT apologized and deleted the QT? That one? To claim he is "in cahoots" has been disproven with receipts. Sorry. Your narrative was disproven before you even hit enter.
This quoted post is unavailable.
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
I've said it before, I'll say it again, of all the back and forth @SmashJT and Alyssa have had, he absolutely did not threaten her nor did I see him elevate a death threat towards her.
"Bringing someone's family into it is not the same as bringing someone's family into it."
(note: @SmashJT did no such thing)
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
are you out of your rabbit ass mind? You involve anyone in my family and Im coming to see about you period. Dox my address im coming to see you period. Anyone defending either one needs their ass whooped
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
1: Don't doxx people. Period.
2: I am completely unsurprised that SOMEONE did this after she tracked down and went after a YouTuber's WIFE like the goddamned psycho that she is.
Looks like Alyssa Mercante may have gotten Doxxed, or someone close to her did. It goes without saying, I obviously don't support whoever did this. It's wrong. It's dangerous. In some places it's illegal.
All that being said...Are you really surprised? Was it worth it? All this because some Brazillian rando made a steam page about video games made by a company you don't even work for or had a hand in? Was it worth trying to ruin Kabrutus or Mark Kern simply for your own benefit?
It's called a Culture War dear. Emphasis on the WAR part. Back in 2014, when the original Gamergate happened your side held all the cards. Your side doxxed. Your side Swatted. Your side called peoples jobs and got them fired, taking bread from their children's mouths.
It's been a decade, and things have only gotten worse. For what? For you to LARP as activists pretending you cared about video games and women's rights? Marginalized people? Social deviants who seek only to make their predatory taboos culturally normalized under the guise of being victims?
You took away the comforts and escapism of real people going through real strife in real world, all while pretending (poorly might I add), that you were doing this for some greater good.
Now it seems like things have gone horribly wrong for you because of a position you put yourself in when you didn't need to. You could have written about anything. Top 10 Legend of Zelda Games. How to Unlock the BFG In Doom Eternal. Underrated Indie Games that Deserve a Steam Purchase. But no. No, instead you decided to sew division amongst the avid fans, consumers, and paying customers of the largest entertainment industry in the world.
So while it's wrong you may have gotten doxxed, I have to say, from an outsider looking in, who has been watching all of this come to a head over the last 10 years...Your decisions lead to this.
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
I am a rape survivor from two men. I was gang-raped. Evidence: surveillance video, DNA test and bruises. This tweet is horrible.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
The Game Spot editor is now defending Kotaku's Alyssa Mercante for harassing @SmashJT's family based on someone else's tweets, which don't even say what she says they say.
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
Verge Video Game Reporter Ash Parrish
"the urge to blog about why hades horny is different than stellar blade horny is very powerful. we'll see"
NOTE: What say you Hades fans?🧐
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
At first glance, I thought it was cuz of Buttercup getting a makeover cuz some people get defensive over tomboys being "feminized", but apparently it's cuz of the artist's interpretation of Bubbles as chubby. Insane either way.
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
"Who cares about those (sick) children."
She used these children for PR. That's disgusting. She never had the intent to donate the money as she had over 13 months to do so before getting sued. She was proven to have lied about DV and SA. But who cares right?
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
Lyle 🇹🇼👍 retweeted
Shocking...pieces of shit.
New: OpenAI—which has scraped the internet and fed copyrighted works into its own products—has filed a copyright claim over the OpenAI logo being used on the ChatGPT subreddit
"It does not seem wise for OpenAI to start enforcing copyright claims."
404media.co/openai-files-cop…










































