Pinned Tweet
🎯 Exactly this.
We get so bogged down in the daily stream of atrocities committed by Israel that it's easy to lose sight of the big picture.
At the end of the day the reason why it matters so much, besides it being an affront to our most basic humanity, is because whatever we collectively let happen - or not - will define the fundamental structure of the international order for decades to come.
Why, and how?
The most important thing to remember about the period we're living in is that we're in a transition between world orders. We're exiting US hegemony - it's over already - and entering an new order.
Such transitions happen rarely, once a century or so. The last time was the end of the Cold War when we transitioned from a bipolar world order to US hegemony, or "Pax Americana" as it was known (which wasn't "pax" at all given the millions violently killed in U.S. wars, which is the very reason why it was so short-lived... but that's besides the point).
But this transition is extra special, because for the first time in 300+ years, we have non-Western states such as China becoming preeminent powers. As we all know, ever since the Industrial Revolution, it was the West dominating the system. Transitions occurred but between Western states: Portugal to Spain, Spain to the British, the British to the US.
So that's the backdrop. Now how does Israel fit in and why does it matter?
Orders are based on principles, and founding historical events matter enormously to underwrite these principles.
Go back to the past, when the West started colonizing the planet, at first timidly (a few "trading posts" in Africa in the 15th century) and then more and more boldly, all the way to claiming entire continents. Why? Because they could, they were writing the principles (or lack thereof) of a new West-dominated world order.
Or if you want a closer example, take NATO's bombing of Yugoslavia in the 1990s, one of the founding acts of the US hegemony era. Completely illegal with regards to international law or even of NATO's own treaty (Serbia didn't attack and wasn't preparing to attack a member state of NATO), so much so that - it's funny to recall today - even Ariel Sharon at the time called an act of "brutal interventionism". Looking back, it premised the entire US hegemonic order: a time of unilateral, hubristic and brutal interventionism with little regard for international law. The message was "we do whatever the hell we want"... And this first act was timid compared with what was to come afterwards and the millions killed in the post 9-11 so-called "war on terror".
Now I'm obviously not suggesting that Israel will be a preeminent state in the new world order, it's way too small for this. What I am saying is that the actions we collectively permit today will echo for decades to come and define the larger battles that will shape our future.
And everyone can see that the precedents that we're setting are beyond horrifying: some of the principles Israel breaks were established for centuries such as the illegality of bombing embassies, or the killing of medical staff. Even in the Middle-Age we knew better not to do that stuff.
People don't realize just how consequential this is: what's at stake is quite simply everything. If we let the future of the international order be based on the murder of Palestinians, and now the Lebanese, we're paving the way for the most unprincipled and nihilistic order we've ever known, where virtually anything goes.
I see many people, some of them I believe sincere, defend Israel on the basis that it's a "fight for civilization against barbarism". It's in fact the EXACT CONTRARY. Israel is literally destroying everything civilization is based upon: sovereignty, the rule of law, human rights, freedom, etc. If you care about any of these things and if you truly understood what's happening, you'd be an ardent defender of the Palestinians and Lebanese.
Many people cheered Israel on its "daring" actions against Hezbollah, including the killing of Nasrallah, on the basis that these were "terrorists" (remember that one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter...). What fewer people know is that the reason why Israel did those actions wasn't at all because they were "terrorists", which is always just a propaganda label for the gullible public: according to Israeli officials themselves as quoted by NBC (nbcnews.com/news/world/live-…) they did it because Hezbollah refused a side deal that abandoned the Palestinians and let Israel continue its its land grab and ethnic cleansing unimpeded. In other words the "terrorists" of Hezbollah were the only ones who actually decided to make Israel face accountability on what all UN resolutions and the immense majority of the international community have been calling for ceaselessly. They're the only ones who decided to actually enforce the rules we supposedly have. THAT is why they're getting bombed and killed.
All in all, if you genuinely care about the principles that underlie civilization, the Palestinian cause should be THE priority cause for you, because of the precedents that are being set.
Another non-trivial group of people defend Israel because they're essentially supremacists, wanting "the West" to crush those "Muslims" (notwithstanding the fact many Palestinians and even more Lebanese are Christian) for daring to rebel against their subjugation. But even if that's your case, if you were to take a step back and use a modicum of common sense, you'd see that in the grand scheme of things this is absolutely not in your interest.
Again the key characteristic of the emerging world order is the rise of non-Western powers: by supporting Israel's actions, you're effectively setting the rules of engagement for what may be done to you... Also if you're a supremacist, I imagine that you're not very fond of immigration: in Lebanon alone, one million people have already been displaced from their homes by Israel. As is the case with so many wars (remember Syria, Libya, etc.), Israel's actions are triggering yet another immigration crisis.
Or think about this: if you're a supremacist you by definition think that Western values are superior... Doesn't it disturb you in the slightest that objectively speaking what Israel is doing violates just about every single one of these values and thereby destroys the very basis of this supposed superiority? That endlessly, from now on, whenever you'll start your spiel about Western superiority, the immediate answer you'll receive is "yeah but Gaza though..."?
So all in all, no matter where you come from on this, once you start thinking through it, the larger implications become impossible to ignore. Every one of us bears responsibility for the world we're creating through the actions we let happen. Do we want a world underwritten by "anything goes" and "might makes right", do we want to step into an unprecedently nihilistic order? Or do we want a world with a vision for a shared future for mankind, underwritten by common principles, a world that makes us somewhat proud to be human? That's what's at stake with Israel today.
4
1,286
Peter Schurman retweeted
Troy Jackson volunteers are organizing a large rally demanding Angus King listens to Maine voters and backs Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader instead of Chuck Schumer.
Peter Schurman retweeted
During World War II, American aircraft bombed civilian neighborhoods in Germany, killing nearly half a million German civilians.
Later, in defending these attacks, the United States justified the bombing of civilian populations as a means of breaking German society’s morale. Another argument used to justify such attacks was that the German people’s silence under Hitler amounted to approval of his policies, and that they therefore deserved to be punished.
Yet many historians have challenged this reasoning. Not everyone who lived under Hitler was a Nazi, and not everyone who remained silent supported him. Still, that distinction did nothing to protect civilians from the bombs.
And yesterday, former German Chancellor Angela Merkel revived this same line of reasoning while defending Israel’s policies toward civilians in Gaza, pointing to the lack of widespread public opposition to Hamas within Gaza in the context of her remarks about Israel’s war.
And here is my question:
What exactly is a civilian supposed to do to deserve protection?
Must he take to the streets and confront an armed authority? Must he publicly declare his opposition in front of cameras? Must he prove to the world that he resisted hard enough before his death becomes worthy of condemnation?
I am from Gaza, and I know that opposing Hamas is not an abstract political position. I know that expressing such opposition publicly can carry very real risks.
I also know that Palestinians have criticized Hamas, both before and during the war. Some have even paid with their lives for doing so, even if their voices never reached Mrs. Merkel.
But more importantly, I cannot understand why we should have to pass this test in the first place.
A German child should never have had to prove that he opposed Hitler to avoid being killed beneath the rubble of his home.
And a Palestinian child should not have to prove that his family opposed Hamas in order to deserve to live.
We can discuss the responsibility of governments and armed groups. We can criticize them, condemn their actions, and demand that they be held accountable.
But the moment we begin measuring civilians’ right to life by how much they resisted those who governed them, we cross a dangerous line: we stop holding those in power accountable and begin holding their victims responsible for the violence inflicted upon them.
And what pains me most is hearing this reasoning, even by implication, from a German political figure who, of all people, should understand where the idea of treating an entire population as collectively guilty can lead.
A civilian should not need a certificate of political good conduct to deserve protection from bombs.
Peter Schurman retweeted
If a conservative Democrat like Ken Salazar is breaking with Chuck Schumer, that means it's likely that both Colorado Senators Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper will too.
If that's happening.... Then I do think it's over for Chuck.
We urgently need a new Democratic Majority Leader in the United States Senate, who will lead with courage and results for the greatness and unity of our great nation. U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer is out of touch with the American people and the urgent message from this historic 2026 election. Senators with the courage and proven experience to lead our Democratic caucus beginning now are Raphael Warnock, Michael Bennet, Catherine Cortez Masto, Elissa Slotkin, Chris Coons, Tim Kaine, Chris Van Hollen and Mark Kelly.
Peter Schurman retweeted
🚨 BREAKING:
Jewish actor Daniel Radcliffe:
"As a Jew, I have been fed lies about Israel my entire life."
"I was never told that Palestinians live there. Israel is a ridiculous and illogical state, built on ethnic cleansing and genocide."
Peter Schurman retweeted
Shakira's response to El-Sayed’s joke about the “Shakira law” was absolutely priceless.
During the campaign, El-Sayed faced questions about Sharia law, the Islamic ethical and religious framework.
Then, in an October 14 video, he redirected the accusation, saying no one is trying to impose Sharia law on anybody, but there is a "Shakira law,” with one commandment—the hips do not lie.
Shakira later responded on Instagram under a post from his team: "Finally, a law my hips can agree with! Habibi, think you can get it through Congress?"
El-Sayed’s turning a politically charged question about Sharia law into a pop-culture punchline—and Shakira’s taking it a step further by bringing Congress into the joke—was brilliant, turning a campaign joke into a viral celebrity moment.
Peter Schurman retweeted
I remember Chuck Schumer being unable to rein in Joe Manchin & Kyrsten Sinema
I remember Chuck Schumer not firing the parliamentarian when she wouldn’t approve a minimum wage increase
I remember Chuck Schumer saying he was going to send Donald Trump a “strongly worded letter”
Maybe we’ve seen enough of Chuck Schumer’s “leadership” & we’re ready to move on
Peter Schurman retweeted
I remember Chuck Schumer being unable to rein in Joe Manchin & Kyrsten Sinema
I remember Chuck Schumer not firing the parliamentarian when she wouldn’t approve a minimum wage increase
I remember Chuck Schumer saying he was going to send Donald Trump a “strongly worded letter”
Maybe we’ve seen enough of Chuck Schumer’s “leadership” & we’re ready to move on
Peter Schurman retweeted
Here's what's getting overlooked in the Schumer–Van Hollen leadership fight.
Under Senate Democratic Rule XIII, the party leader appoints the DSCC chair, subject to caucus confirmation.
Van Hollen pledges to stop leadership interference in Democratic primaries and refuse AIPAC money for the DSCC.
Schumer backed Haley Stevens in Michigan. AIPAC spent more than $30 million helping her defeat Abdul El-Sayed. El-Sayed won anyway and now supports Van Hollen's challenge.
The candidates who survived the establishment's attempts to defeat them now have a vote in who controls its Senate campaign machinery.
That's a much bigger power struggle than the latest endorsement count.
theguardian.com/us-news/2026…
Israel won’t allow the plastic needed to make a mask for a 6–year-old child for the burns on her face.
Blocking medical supplies isn’t a “dispute,” it’s a WAR CRIME.
Six-year-old Gaza burn victim caught in Israeli dispute over aid reut.rs/4zgJ7EQ
Peter Schurman retweeted
Schumer was such a great majority leader that he let the parliamentarian block a min wage increase and let Manchin decouple BBB from some tax credits for businesses (and gave him his oil pipeline), thus sinking Biden's social policy agenda which directly led to the 2024 wipeout
Here’s where I stand on all this:
— Schumer was a good-to-great majority leader, especially from 2021-2022.
— Schumer was a pretty bad minority leader, especially when he folded like a cheap lawn chair on shutdown stuff (twice).
— Schumer deserves credit for his Senate recruitment efforts in 2026 (and yes he whiffed on a few), but I don’t know if that means he’s earned another term as leader.
— It’s pretty clear he’s not a great fit for the current moment within the party and for the country writ large. He’s a bad communicator and (IMO) fails basic morality tests. He doesn’t come across like a bold leader of the opposition party. Van Hollen would be way better on all of those fronts. And would make the party look more like what voters put Democrats there to do.
— I’m having a hard time getting worked up about all this because the post-2028 election Senate majority leader (and House speaker!) race is way more consequential than this one (assuming, inshallah, that we have a trifecta), given that a lot of the next two years will be about blocking Trump cabinet and judicial nominees and making Republicans take difficult votes. I don’t expect there’s a lot, materially, that Van Hollen accomplish over the next two years that Schumer can’t, given that Trump has the veto pen.
— The thing I’m most concerned about is Schumer not standing up to Trump on budget/government funding given his track record. But I’m not sure that matters as much when we have 56 seats (as opposed to 47).
Peter Schurman retweeted
Angela Gonzales-Torres confirms she will vote NO on Hakeem Jeffries for Speaker of the House
"I was elected to Congress to fight for working families, not protect the political establishment.
We need to overturn Citizens United, Block the Bombs, and make life affordable for working people. I don't believe our current leadership is prepared to deliver."
Peter Schurman retweeted
Critically important analysis that succinctly explains how BAAJA is an AI data center accelerator
Peter Schurman retweeted
The UN found that 459 of 564 schools in Gaza took a direct hits.
You don't accidentally bomb 459 schools.
Peter Schurman retweeted
Democrats, we won the majority. But we still need to win the trust of the American people. We can’t return to the status quo.
If you agree, join us at chrisforleader.com
Peter Schurman retweeted
2028 Democratic Primary (Cygnal)
Men Under 55
🟦AOC 31%
🟦Pete Buttigieg 13%
🟦Kamala Harris 13%
🟦Gavin Newsom 12%
🟦Josh Shapiro 6%
Women Under 55
🟦AOC 27%
🟦Kamala Harris 17%
🟦Pete Buttigieg 15%
🟦Gavin Newsom 9%
🟦Josh Shapiro 3%
Link: cygn.al/wp-content/uploads/2…

































