Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019) header
Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019) profile picture

UR, MS General Surgery. Here to share my thoughts and some controversial opinions about Indian Healthcare System.

Jammu, Jammu & Kashmir, India
Joined April 2011
Photo by Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019)Photo by Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019)Photo by Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019)Photo by Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019)Photo by Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019)Photo by Dr. Payal Choudhary (@Payal019)
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
High priests realised medical students can be taught Appendectomy and C section so they hid it behind MS OBG and surgery through PG coaching exam rituals. Then created DM/Mch to teach what was meant to be taught in PG residency. Now fellowship to teach what was to be in DM/MCh
There is a new emergent caste system in academia. The high priests, thinking what they do is special and rare, look down on AI use as "slop." Unfortunately for them, Fable / GPT 5.5 Pro can do in 10-15 min what they spent years learning and feeling special about. So like true high priests they will develop more guardrails and initiation ceremonies to determine who enters the temple. This would be a mistake. The correct approach is to embrace AI use and do more creative science that was not possible before.
1
11
1
72
4,741
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
Assessment of cerebral bood flow is one of the central pillars of my field of Neuroanaesthesiology and Neurocritical Care. And where I work, we regularly use non-invasive methods like Transcranial Doppler and Near-Infrared Spectroscopy to try our best to find out how well the blood is flowing in the brain. "Try our best to find out". Anyone doing TCD, knows how difficult it is to even get a window to peep inside the brain with an USG probe. And it still only measures the velocity and direction of the blood flowing in an artery. Non-invasive accurate assessment of cerebral blood flow is still an area of active interest and research. So when I see someone selling something that claims to give a picture of how blood flows inside the brain, I only wonder at the state of science and rationality in our society. And at the consumer so gullible and blind to the scientific method, that anything fancy looking is automatically assumed to be accurate. The sellers are just selling because there's a market. The consumer needs to get smart first.
Dear Concerned Indian Doctors, I see your rage against Temple on X. I have a few points to make: 1. First and foremost, a business lesson: if Temple were a scam, and any of what we said weren't true, people would know it in just a few days of using Temple. We have 14-day, no-questions-asked returns (which even Apple doesn't offer in India). If the product doesn't work, it fails out of the gate and the company dies before recovering a tenth of its R&D. 2. We have already spent $30m building Temple, $20m out of which is my own money. Selling a few thousand devices recovers a small fraction of this investment. A scam that pays nothing is not a scam anyone would run. 3. I left the Eternal CEO role to chase purpose with Temple. This is not about money. I have enough of it to last for generations. My incentives are fully aligned with getting the science right. I am not staking a reputation earned over 20 years on making a quick buck. 4. Our employees bought into our round a few months ago. The round we're raising now is mostly our customers. Scams don't build that cap table. 5. Most wearable companies start with internal studies. Whoop shipped its band in 2015, and the first published validation followed a few years later. We hold ourselves to a higher standard; pre-prints are a step prior to peer reviewed publications, and they are coming up. 6. At some point you have to stick your neck out and say: we believe in our science, and the product is now valuable enough for people to pay for and use. We believe we are there. More validation continues in public. 7. We are confident that we are building something that the world is going to be positively astonished with. We stand by our science and our methods. Each of our claims is easily verifiable by individuals and institutions alike, and you will see a lot of independent studies come up on their own when the device becomes available to use. Last but not the least, the most ground breaking features in Temple are not even public yet. And some of them, thankfully, have nothing to do with doctors 🤭 Hope this addresses some or all of your concerns. If not, keep raging 😘🤗
40
295
15
1,500
64,538
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
desi auntiyan/buddiyan badi harami hoty hain yaar, life is not easy for desi bahus at all. every day i hear their stories, every day it breaks my heart This antenatal patient on my follow up had anemia for which i gave her iron injections, her Hemoglobin improved well. U won't believe what her mother in law said in front of her in the OPD, when i told her aaj khoon badd gaya hai acha ab. She said Haan mera khoon sara peeti hai badega kyu nhi🤡🥲 i was like bc buddi nikl meri OPD se. Desi buddis are too much toxic man. Tabse uski entry banned hai meri OPD main.
20
36
4
601
23,270
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
Someone who took ₹10 crore for one movie is calling doctors “looters” for charging ₹500 while the audience lounges on ₹500 recliner seats, munches ₹1000 popcorn, and cheers. How much more development do we need?
12
100
6
634
12,544
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
At my teen's autism assessment, the doc asked me if I remember her ever having issues with eye contact. I said, "I never really paid much attention to that. When I talk to people, I don't really look them in the eye because it's distracting to me and the only time I do is when it's like an important meeting because a teacher taught me to do that. And even then, I tend to look between their eyes to maintain the illusion of eye contact. Direct eye contact is weird..." She just looked at me.
66
133
20
6,582
318,201
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
I’ve officially become THAT relative: Nobody knows where the fuck I am, what the fuck I do, who I’m with, or how the fuck I’m living.
292
6,082
423
30,705
650,060
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
I hate when lay people opine on healthcare issues when they actually have no fucking idea what they are talking about. Until you’ve started aging a little prematurely from stress and worked a few 80 hr weeks or overnight shifts on wards, you do not get to opine on how doctors should operate
7
3
66
2,506
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
getting mad at me because YOU tried to be mean to ME and found out i'm meaner than you is INSANE.
33
1,349
97
5,636
89,925
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
hyrox is just takeshi's castle for people going through midlife crisis
151
7,114
497
42,620
1,130,646
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
Half of the problems in residency will be solved by giving post duty off after 24 hrs duty. No 36-48hrs.
15
54
8
623
45,414
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
It’s telling that the IIT staff & students who have gone on camera seem far more shaken & distressed than the parents who appear composed while making extraordinary allegations.
15
72
1
475
9,252
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
When you were a kid or a teenager, your parents imposed certain restrictions on you and there were some rules they made that you could not break, all of which may have felt unjust and unfair at the time. It is only when you become a mature adult do you realize in hindsight that they did everything based on their lived experiences to try and shield you from how cruel, ruthless, random and unfair the world can actually be. You can debate that their means could have been better but their intentions were always to wish the very best for you.
1
8
1
81
3,209
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
Not even two days since his son death, and he’s already filing sc st Act case against the professor who merely caught his son cheating in exam, just to claim compensation money. Banana republic.
Mumbai, Maharashtra: On the IIT Bombay student suicide case, Advocate Nikhil Kamble says, "Our main demands include the appointment of a Crime Branch team, allowing the victim’s father and five to seven representatives to monitor the investigation, and having the entire investigation supervised by the Joint Commissioner. In case the accused seek anticipatory bail, a Special Public Prosecutor will be appointed to represent the state. Three lawyers suggested by the victim’s father will oppose the bail plea in the High Court. In addition, compensation under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act will be provided at the earliest..."
57
1,017
16
6,290
110,139
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
Issue with most Indians when they come to govt hospital and their conduct with govt doctors is they confuse service with servility. A doctor at a govt hospital is providing you service, he/she is NOT YOUR SERVANT. Healthcare service is not hospitality service.
28
152
9
1,419
28,737
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
A piece of honest advice for every budding or young doctor who plans to stay and work in India - the entire country will collectively try to guilt trip you for earning money and leading a decent lifestyle after two decades of grinding in out. It is very important that you do not fall for it. Being good and ethical at what you do is non-negotiable and you may use your discretion to help the needy or those who aren't as fortunate, but do not be ashamed to earn a good living, to provide your family with every upgrade possible in life. You have dedicated your teens, 20s and even your 30s to get yourself educated and subsequently (somewhat) established, you deserve every luxury that may come your way.
34
106
7
634
27,812
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
First in my blood line to see a state sponsored birthday celebration of a man who’s still alive and is head of the state. A new low everyday.
17
905
14
8,166
45,991
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
"Listen to your body" My body at 8:00 AM on a workday: - Quit immediately - Disappear off the grid - Befriend the crows - Return to nature
49
6,299
73
47,375
530,775
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
I saw a post that said: “I think being forced to be hyper independent as a child has caused me to be irrationally angry with any adult who needs their hand held through anything they do.” And I felt that in my soul.
185
8,940
579
43,946
604,434
Dr. Payal Choudhary retweeted
CJP leaders finally get time to visit the only state where their master cockroach is still in power and instead of talking about the alleged paper leaks in the state, they want the country to believe the situation there is as good as the nordic countries. Shameless Pro Max.
🚨PUNJAB SCHOOLS SOCIAL AUDIT A Cockroach Janta Party team reached Ludhiana, Punjab to conduct school audit. Watch the video to know our observations. Was impressed with the “Schools of Eminence”. Most of the 20 points were on positive side. Yet, problems were observed. We conveyed them to the Education Minister @harjotbains who readily agreed to meet us. We demanded the problems be resolved immediately. The Minister assured us of swift action. @Cockroachisback @whattalawyer Watch:
2
14
160
4,665