SBCLitigation (@SBCLitigation) header
SBCLitigation (@SBCLitigation) profile picture

Watching litigation involving the nation’s largest Protestant group.

Joined March 2023
Southern Baptist Convention cases We're Following - Update: DOJ Investigation (NY) Rollins v. Pressler (TX) Roe v. Patterson (TX) Berry v. SBC (NC) Blue v. SBC (NC) Caldwell v. SBC (NC) Couch v. SBC (NC) Dockins v. SBC (NC) Doe v. SBC (SC) Doe v. SBC (SC) Duhart v. SBC (SC) 1/3
5
7
2
27
51,070
SBCLitigation retweeted
I'm thankful to have received summary judgment in my favor in the David Sills case. Others have said much about this case while it was underway; I was always confident and content to wait for the court's judgment. I am happy for the court's order to speak for itself.
1
3
1
80
14,293
Court: an even closer call, but reasonable jury could find Mohler and SBTS were negligent in calling relationship "non-consensual," even if using religious definition of "sexual abuse."
🚨SILLS: Court says Sills' claim for Defamation against SBC, SBCEC, Guidepost, SBTS survives summary judgment!🚨
1
2
6
6,369
Court: Reasonably jury could find SBC EC negligently failed to ascertain truth in publicizing Sills as part of a "list of abusers."
🚨SILLS: Court says Sills' claim for Defamation against SBC, SBCEC, Guidepost, SBTS survives summary judgment!🚨
2
1
7
1,479
"The List" was published along with a statement from Rolland Slade and Willie McLaurin. SBC EC's lawyers approved redaction decisions about "the List."
1
313
Court: a close call, but a reasonable jury could decide SBC and SBCEC knew Guidepost wasn't investigating veracity of Lyell claims, and was negligent in publishing Guidepost's report.
🚨SILLS: Court says Sills' claim for Defamation against SBC, SBCEC, Guidepost, SBTS survives summary judgment!🚨
3
1,005
Court: reasonable jury might find Guidepost was negligent in Sills investigation.
🚨SILLS: Court says Sills' claim for Defamation against SBC, SBCEC, Guidepost, SBTS survives summary judgment!🚨
1
6
1,135
🚨SILLS: Court says Sills' claim for Defamation against SBC, SBCEC, Guidepost, SBTS survives summary judgment!🚨
3
6
5
26
21,019
OUT: All claims asserted by Mary Sills. All claims for civil conspiracy, negligence, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Defamation based on the Barber Tweets. Defamation by Guidepost based on "the List."
2
4
1,009
For the most part, we expect the legal fees for defending the EC/SBC covered by insurance, and not paid with offering plate money.
1
273
The unusual part is that the SBC agreed to cover Guidepost's defense, even before insurance. And it's highly unlikely that the SBC's insurance covers those fees. So if there's large amounts of offering plate money going somewhere, it's to the defense of Guidepost.
1
172
Pessimist take: SBC Presidents can falsely call you a crook and get away with it. Optimist take: After you admit touching another man's wife, don't expect a judge to make you rich over the difference between "scoundrel" and "crook."
4
467
Sills: still pending. Judge has asked for briefing on whether Jennifer Lyell (former Defendant) was a public figure. That will be a much harder call compared to Hunt. Judge wouldn't ask, though, if it didn't make a difference to him. Set for trial in November.
5
2,250
New Suit: Heine / Arkansas. Parent of minor victim sues FBC Bentonville, NWA Association, Ark. Baptist Convention, SBC, 25 unknown leaders, and 25 unknown insurance companies.
3
1
1,837
Plf. says the abuser was effectively placed by Steve Gaines , SBC President and Pastor of Bellevue Baptist. And says FBCB should have known Gaines had mishandled abuse reporting in the past. /4
1
903
"Failing to apply heightened scrutiny, conduct exhaustive verification, or implement additional child-safety precautions when selecting a youth minister from a compromised church fell below the standard of reasonable care ...." /5
750