SEEN Scotland (@SEENScotland) header
SEEN Scotland (@SEENScotland) profile picture

Sex Equality and Equity Network for public sector workers in Scotland (Est. 2024) Contact: [email protected] Distinct from SEEN Scottish Government (2026)

Scotland, United Kingdom
Joined April 2025
Photo by SEEN Scotland (@SEENScotland)Photo by SEEN Scotland (@SEENScotland)Photo by SEEN Scotland (@SEENScotland)Photo by SEEN Scotland (@SEENScotland)
SEEN Scotland retweeted
'As far as I’m concerned, women are women who are born women, but women are also women who are trans women' -- Harriet Harman, 2002 You cannot defend what you're afraid to define. 2/2
291
2,570
36
31,952
424,198
SEEN Scotland retweeted
Bravo, @Keir_Starmer, for getting in an Adviser on Women and Girls who thinks the definition of women and girls includes men and boys. That'll definitely win back people who believe Labour's a party for smug, lanyard-wearing, luxury-belief-espousing cultural elitists. 1/2
I’m delighted to appoint @HarrietHarman as my Adviser on Women and Girls. Harriet is a strong advocate for women and girls and I know she will deliver greater opportunity for women in public life. I’m committed to tackling structural misogyny that is a barrier for too many women and girls. I look forward to working with Harriet to drive forward action on this important issue.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Harriet Harman and her then husband, Jack Dromey, were senior officials in the National Council for Civil Liberties (Now known as Liberty) when they supported the Paedophile Information Exchange and allowed it to affiliate to NCCL. theguardian.com/politics/2014/… telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/…
1,817
12,807
364
79,927
2,706,435
SEEN Scotland retweeted
"I hope MSP candidates are savvy enough to be aware they are being sold a pup, and commit to cleaning up this mess should they be elected."
1. The usual Scottish Government funded trans lobbying groups have got a shiny new manifesto to wave under politicians' noses. Do we actually think they will be abiding by the Supreme Court judgment regarding sports...? equality-network.org/wp-cont…
2
9
12
1,510
SEEN Scotland retweeted
Replying to @theglassfish13
Yes, the people who call themselves 'trans' exist and they deserve exactly the same rights as everyone else, which, fortunately, they already have in the UK. It would rightly be considered discrimination if a person was refused employment, housing or the vote because they identified as trans. 'Trans women are women' is a thought-terminating cliché. Men are not women. That doesn't mean they're not allowed to present themselves however they like, call themselves whatever they like and believe whatever they like about themselves. It means they haven't changed sex. If we replace the objective, observable characteristic of sex with the unfalsifiable concept of gender identify, women and girls lose, among other things, their right to fair and safe sport and women-only spaces, including changing rooms, prison cells and rape crisis services. Women and girls are provably more vulnerable to forms of abuse including sexual assault, harassment and voyeurism in mixed-sex spaces. There is no evidence that trans-identified men don't have exactly the same rates of criminal offending as all other men. Trans people exist. I have no desire for them not to exist; indeed, I wish them safety, happiness and health. However, 'existence' does not, and should not, mean the violation of other people's right to privacy, dignity and freedom of speech, or the reconfiguration of society to indulge a fallacy.
595
5,428
407
34,979
2,360,412
SEEN Scotland retweeted
"Freaks...ugly, ugly, ugly, with the worst hair and the worst clothes." Podcaster Grace Campbell describing the women celebrating the FWS judgment. I'm well accustomed to the nastiness of the other side, but the *vicious* internalised misogyny on display here still shocked me.
For anyone who hasn't seen Here's them saying this. I feel certain Campbell won't have the courage to face you and defend this.
319
798
59
5,323
419,738
SEEN Scotland retweeted
This is incredible, painstaking work by @SEENinHealth who are demonstrating that unlawful discrimination against women is more or less wholesale across the NHS - using taxpayer money to pursue their pet ideology
🚨 Have you checked your local hospitals policies? Our NHS policy map lets you click on your local NHS trust/board and see exactly what their policies say — including examples that may be unlawful. Here is an example: NHS Borders ⬇️ 🔗 seeninhealth.org/nhs-foi-map… Use the links to contact your MP or NHS CEO and help hold government and senior leadership to account. #OneYearLater @SeeninHR @SexMattersOrg @ForWomenScot @JournalismSEEN
2
3
181
SEEN Scotland retweeted
🚨 Have you checked your local hospitals policies? Our NHS policy map lets you click on your local NHS trust/board and see exactly what their policies say — including examples that may be unlawful. Here is an example: NHS Borders ⬇️ 🔗 seeninhealth.org/nhs-foi-map… Use the links to contact your MP or NHS CEO and help hold government and senior leadership to account. #OneYearLater @SeeninHR @SexMattersOrg @ForWomenScot @JournalismSEEN
12
2
27
1,136
SEEN Scotland retweeted
Straight from the Dentons playbook. A very deliberate strategy by identity activists to push for policy and legislative change away from media and public scrutiny. Deeply undemocratic.
Kaukab Stewart condemned the single-sex guidance for schools policy during Equality Network hustings this week. I went along but was asked to leave because I was a journalist. Given the org is publicly funded, I refused. Story here. @heraldscotland 👇 heraldscotland.com/news/2601…
4
139
1
416
12,524
Ministers say they accept the ruling, then immediately behave as though it is optional, conditional, or somehow waiting for a green light from the Equality and Human Rights Commission before it becomes real. That is simply not true. They were told they could act. They chose not to. Let’s call that what it is, not a legal gap, not a procedural delay, but a political refusal. There comes a point when the noise has to stop and the law has to speak plainly. That moment already came with the ruling of the UK Supreme Court April 2025 ruling on Equality Act. What we are watching now is not confusion or complexity. It is resistance, softened with the language of care, but resistance all the same. This is about whether the state still honours the meaning of sex in law under the Equality Act 2010 or whether it will continue to blur it until it becomes meaningless. The court clarified what many ordinary women already knew, that single-sex spaces exist because biological sex matters. That is not hostility. That is the basis of safeguarding. And then, as if on cue, the emotional crescendo. Children too afraid to use toilets. Claims of harm. Even the suggestion that a lawful judgment has cost lives. These are serious claims, but they are being used here not to illuminate the issue, but to close it down. Emotion is stepping in where argument should be. Distress is being used to override clarity. You do not get to nullify the law by raising the volume of suffering. Rights do not dissolve because they are uncomfortable to enforce. Girls’ right to privacy and dignity in single-sex spaces does not vanish because it is contested. That is precisely when it must be defended. @ForWomenScot has been consistent from the beginning. This is not about hostility. It is about whether the law still functions. Because if the category “woman” can be stretched indefinitely to mean anyone who claims it, then it ceases to function as a legal category at all. And when that happens, the protections built upon it do not evolve, they collapse every where as does safeguarding. And the truth is, the manoeuvre we are watching from ministers in this article is not new. @FAVORUK has been calling it out for years in a different arena. The false framing of harm reduction versus recovery was never the real shift. The real shift came when “recovery” itself was stretched beyond recognition, redefined to mean any positive change, any "stabilisation", until it required nothing and delivered very little. You are in recovery if you say you are. The word remains, but its substance drains away. It is the same trick playing out here. Keep the word, change the meaning. In one case, “recovery” becomes indistinguishable from ongoing addiction. In this case, “woman” becomes indistinguishable from self-declaration. And once that happens, the system does not become more compassionate. It becomes incoherent. Because once meaning is hollowed out, systems stop working. In addiction, it leads to containment rather than transformation, keeping people alive without helping them live. In law, it leads to protections that exist on paper but fail in practice. Because categories are not just words, they are the scaffolding that rights and responsibilities are built upon. Remove their boundaries, and the structure does not become more inclusive, it becomes unstable. There is also an honesty problem that cannot be ignored. The same voices now warning about “division” are often the ones who dismissed or silenced women when these concerns were first raised. The fracture did not begin with the court. It began when the meaning of sex was bent out of shape to accommodate an ideology, and dissent was treated as something to be managed rather than answered. We have experienced this exactly at @FAVORUK So this is not about proceeding carefully. It is about proceeding honestly. The law is already clear. The government does not need to wait. It needs to act. And if ministers cannot bring themselves to implement what the highest court in the land has already settled, then they should have the courage to say so openly rather than hiding behind consultation, delay, and endlessly deferred guidance. Because this is about rrdinary, everyday spaces where the law is meant to be clear and trusted. And that trust is already badly fractured. When a clear legal ruling can be acknowledged and then quietly sidestepped, when words are kept but their meaning hollowed out, the damage is not abstract. People see it. They feel it. They stop believing what they are told. At that point, the question is no longer hypothetical. If the government will not tell the truth or uphold the law here, in something this basic, why would anyone trust it on anything else? Well Done @_RebeccaMcCurdy #CourgaeCalls
Kaukab Stewart condemned the single-sex guidance for schools policy during Equality Network hustings this week. I went along but was asked to leave because I was a journalist. Given the org is publicly funded, I refused. Story here. @heraldscotland 👇 heraldscotland.com/news/2601…
10
169
3
485
11,061
SEEN Scotland retweeted
SG funded charities Equality Network & LGBTYS organised an LGBTQIA+ hustings attended by a government minister & several MSPs. The Herald was told it could not report or attend & was initially asked to leave. Serious questions about political gatekeeping & transparency here.
24
195
8
470
26,821
SEEN Scotland retweeted
3
18
2
54
1,542
SEEN Scotland retweeted
I do wish they'd stop wasting money on pointless things. What is this anyway? They chucking this money to Elect Her or Engender, or another of the completely useless entities that exist purely to perpetuate themselves, while actively opposing the Supreme Court judgment?
We want to see more women in public life because Scotland is stronger when decision-making reflects the people it serves. That’s why we will invest £300,000 into a Women’s Participation Fund to help more women into politics, starting with next year’s council elections. On May 7th, make it both votes SNP.
10
28
107
2,615
Lucy is quoted here. We have consistently argued that organisations submitting evidence to Holyrood committees should have to declare their Scottish Government funding. This was tested as a one-off for the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021. thetimes.com/article/af63fc6…
4
121
2
246
6,769
SEEN Scotland retweeted
How can this be healthy? It's clearly creating a system of patronage and dependency, without the oversight that direct government spending would and should have. It's shameful.
there is plenty of anecdotal evidence of the SNP’s capture of the third sector - but this excellent Sunday Times investigation adds much-needed analytical and journalistic rigour to the question and what it reveals is truly shocking - this is a *big* story thetimes.com/article/af63fc6…
3
34
3
78
3,129
Government has no ideas of its own across lots of policy areas. Charity proposes something. Government buys it. Charity campaigns for government. Other charities paddle in behind (objectives, schmobjectives) because we're all one big gang. Of course SG are happy with this.
Charity funding ‘must change’ after claims of SNP pressure. Share token. thetimes.com/article/233b1b7…
5
39
2
94
7,321
SEEN Scotland retweeted
Remember when BBC sport called us hateful for wanting this?
The women's category of Olympic sports will be limited to biological females from 2028, says the International Olympic Committee. Eligibility will be determined by a "once in a lifetime" sex test, which would prevent transgender women and those with differences in sexual development (DSD) from competing. It will take effect from the Los Angeles Olympics. IOC president Kirsty Coventry said the policy was "led by medical experts".
13
167
7
965
56,332
Ministers continue to tell Parliament they accept the Supreme Court judgment while simultaneously pleading to the Court of Session that it is not lawful. We have now asked the Independent Advisers of the Scottish Ministerial Code for assistance. forwomen.scot/07/01/2026/let…
34
445
14
1,374
25,637
SEEN Scotland retweeted
Whilst also defending putting men in women’s prisons and stalling on implementing the UKSC ruling. Where’s the policy coherence?
.@ScotGov is working towards delivery of the National Advisory Council on Women and Girls’ recommendation to establish a Scottish Centre for Gender Equality in Social Attitudes. ‘The Dots’ has been appointed to carry out the next phase of work on how such a centre should operate
3
24
1
54
2,039
SEEN Scotland retweeted
IIRC the consultation on banning conversion therapy was conducted before even the interim Cass Report was published. It's hopelessly out of date and is no reliable basis for public approval of legislation.
1
7
40
1,959