The Scottish Mail on Sunday has reported “ANOTHER gender storm” involving Dr Beth Upton at an Australian hospital. The Times has now repeated the story, explicitly citing the Mail. But what actually happened? An unidentified patient apparently noticed Dr Upton and expressed concern. Other staff became involved. Her husband reportedly stayed at her bedside because he feared she might be bullied into accepting treatment. And that’s about all we know. No date for the alleged incident. No firsthand account from the patient or husband. No evidence that Dr Upton even approached the patient, offered treatment, or was refused. No reported coercion, misconduct or adverse outcome. We have anonymous hospital staff offering opinions, two Australian campaigners expressing outrage, and now For Women Scotland adding its commentary. Yet none supplies evidence of what actually occurred. Notably, The Times adds further reported comments from hospital staff supporting Dr Upton, including a nurse describing her as the victim of a politically motivated “witch hunt” and saying she should be judged on the quality of her work. It also acknowledges that Dr Upton was not criticised in the Peggie tribunal judgment. But it contributes no independent evidence of the supposed Australian incident. Meanwhile, there’s little sign of Australian news coverage, despite transgender healthcare professionals having worked in Australian hospitals for years. So how did this supposed incident reach a Scottish journalist already associated with reporting the Peggie dispute? Why is there no identifiable Australian account? And why are two British newspapers presenting such a poorly substantiated allegation as a major controversy? Are we witnessing an actual controversy at an Australian hospital, or the manufacture of one around a doctor whose name is already familiar to a particular British audience? What is especially troubling is how repetition turns an allegation into something resembling an established fact, without adding a shred of evidence.

Tried to pop into Lidl for a pint of milk on way home from run this morning. Couldn't get parked - cars queuing out onto the road. 🙄 🙄 🙄 Same at Morrisons. Here we go ...

There’s a HRT shortage in the UK 🇬🇧 Women are once again left hunting pharmacies for HRT while the same estradiol is handed out so men can grow tits and pretend they’re women. Real women’s hot flushes, bone density and sleep come second to male entitlement. Every. Single. Time.

rest 🙏🏻 ✨✨ with trans voices in london ❤️❤️🥹 thank you for your channelings and moving your wild and hair-up-on-arms magic with me. i love you 🫶🫶🏳️‍⚧️ alanismorissette.lnk.to/rest…

I've failed as a trans activist. I don't think: Lesbians have to consider dating trans women. Any woman has to undress in front of a trans woman No women's service can exclude trans women Nothing for women can exclude trans women.

“A society which values freedom must protect everyone’s right to live openly and safely as themselves.” My piece for @IndyVoices on delivering our manifesto commitment to ban conversion practices 👉🏻 independent.co.uk/voices/con…