Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979) header
Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979) profile picture

Alberta teacher. Systems thinker. Data over spin. Writing about classrooms, complexity, and power. Autistic. Evidence-driven. Pro-public education.

Alberta, Canada
Joined March 2011
Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)Photo by Carmen Has Questions (@albertaMind1979)
Apparently, Alberta students have made such poor choices that they’ve lost the core strength to sit upright, yet they’re perfectly capable of choosing which core academics they’ll need for life. Fortunately, Nicolaides is putting them in the driver’s seat. At least that comes with a seatbelt to hold them upright. Core strength optional. Core curriculum negotiable. Seatbelts mandatory.
Why is Danielle Smith making Phys Ed mandatory? According to her there are kids who sit and play video games so much they lack the core strength to sit in class. Read that twice. #abpoli #ableg #cdnpoli
13
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
A Georgia Tech couple appears to have a breakup live on air and the commentators analyze and break it down #StingEm #GoDeacs
780
6,816
1,310
141,691
17,121,328
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
This is my favourite Key and Peele skit of all time.
168
1,194
106
15,754
1,926,407
Minister Nicolaides, your government requires parental consent before a student under 16 can use their chosen gender related name or pronouns at school. Your gov has restricted gender affirming medical care on the grounds that young people must be ^protected^ from decisions affecting their futures. Yet, you now champion students’ autonomy to choose educational pathways that may leave them without prerequisites for future careers. Why does your government trust teenagers to make consequential decisions about their education, but not certain decisions about their own identities? What principle explains the difference? @demetriosnAB #abpoli #albertawillnotreelecttheucp
15
11
28
677
I agree that comparing medical decisions with course choices wasn’t fair, and it distracted from my point. I am NOT advocating for teenagers to make physical changes before adulthood unless medically advised. My point is about who supposedly knows best. When it comes to preferred pronouns, parents know best. When it comes to certain books, the government knows best. But when it comes to choosing graduation courses that could limit future career options, suddenly teenagers know best. It seems the UCP changes its answer to “who knows best?” depending on what the UCP wants the answer to be. That’s the inconsistency I’m questioning, not whether these decisions are equivalent.
18
Electrician. Plumber. Mechanic. Millwright. Students could graduate without the courses needed to enter these careers. That’s possible today, too, so what are we actually improving? Use welding as an example: a hs grad can already pursue it without advanced high school courses, but they still need to find an employer, get to work, complete apprenticeship training and learn the math and science needed to do the job well. A diploma alone does not provide any of that. Students who struggle with math will graduate without the skills to perform the math they need in these jobs. Students who don’t see the value of Social Studies will graduate without thr knowledge they need to understand the world around them, question what they're told, and make informed decisions about the society they live in. #maybethatsthepoint #abpoli
Replying to @albertaMind1979
What careers can they not have by this change?
12
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
Replying to @demetriosnAB
You are lowering the bar. Just change your mind, don't double down.
1
4
23
190
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
Replying to @Alberta_UCP
You could expand opportunities without lowering academic requirements. Instead, you’re calling it ‘choice’ when students can graduate with fewer qualifications and potentially fewer options. That is not expanding pathways. #justsayin #abpoli
2
3
35
310
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
If the UCP government wants students to have more choice, then it should not allow students to choose pathways that ^limit^ their options. The trades require strong mathematics skills, and ^many^ require specific English and science courses. University pathways also require specific academic courses. So please, someone from the UCP, tell me: What choices are we adding by allowing students to opt out of courses that are prerequisites for so many career opportunities? I don’t believe we can argue that this encourages pathways into the trades when we know that many trades require strong skills in the very subjects the UCP is now allowing students to opt out of. @demetriosnAB ? If students can already access all of these outcomes with the current graduation requirements, then why would we put any sort of incentive towards students opting out of potential career options? It just doesn’t make any sense. #abpoli
5
8
28
475
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
Opinion: Alberta students need more social studies, not less edmontonjournal.com/opinion/…
14
26
1
69
2,864
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
She’s just so stupid. She is so breathtakingly stupid that the above statement is all it takes for every person reading this to know exactly who I'm talking about.
113
96
6
303
6,943
Danielle Smith, please explain why during question period, when you are challenged on the decisions you make instead of explaining and providing valid reasons for Albertson’s to be supportive of what you are proposing you instead rehash the same insults and jabs at the opposition leader? What does this accomplish? #abpoli #daniellesmithisnotfittolead
3
17
52
593
Alberta UCP, please tell me what career pathway students currently do not have the ^choice^ to pursue? #ucp #abpoli #Alberta
1
1
7
138
If the UCP government wants students to have more choice, then it should not allow students to choose pathways that ^limit^ their options. The trades require strong mathematics skills, and ^many^ require specific English and science courses. University pathways also require specific academic courses. So please, someone from the UCP, tell me: What choices are we adding by allowing students to opt out of courses that are prerequisites for so many career opportunities? I don’t believe we can argue that this encourages pathways into the trades when we know that many trades require strong skills in the very subjects the UCP is now allowing students to opt out of. @demetriosnAB ? If students can already access all of these outcomes with the current graduation requirements, then why would we put any sort of incentive towards students opting out of potential career options? It just doesn’t make any sense. #abpoli
5
8
28
475
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
.@demetriosnAB @UCPCaucus Is this 👇 true?
8
17
49
1,481
Except that budget constraints may push school boards to eliminate/ restrict courses, especially in rural schools where staffing and enrollment already limit what’s available. Students can’t choose courses their schools no longer offer.
There is a perspective that students can still choose to pursue academic subjects to a higher level despite the changes. I think the world of teens. I work with them every day. I was one. I didn't know at 14-18 what core courses I would need for my unknown future career.
1
2
69
Carmen Has Questions retweeted
CorruptCare involves $614,000,000 of Albertans’ money and an RCMP investigation into fraud, money laundering & breach of trust. The Alberta NDP is demanding answers and a real public inquiry. The UCP is dodging both. What are they afraid of? #ableg
18
185
5
407
6,271