This is a problem that M4A advocates are going to have to contend with
As a doctor, avoid being that doctor that patients want to see every time except it’s your own private clinic
Always explain clearly that resources are stretched thin and every other doctor is equally capable
There’s no reward for being that guy
297
Epic gets a lot of hate from clinicians on X but I have to say, the haiku app has evolved to be genuinely useful.
AI scribe, view images on phone, write quick notes, respond to secure chats, notifications when room ready.
Next feature needed is secure dial from office #.
2
82
It's lame when surgeons talk down on other specialties. How does Dr. Lawton know how hard it is to do a cholecystectomy?
Everybody’s talking robotics. But robots are built to do one task w/precision, need simple, consistent anatomy to operate surgically, like w/cholecystectomy. This brain AVM extends from cortex to ventricle, is supplied by convexity arteries + deep perforators, sits next to motor strip. Good luck Optimus….
The biggest predictor of whether someone will move up in academic surgery is not technical skill or clinical/research productivity. It's just... likeability. And maybe integrity. People need to like and trust you before they care about anything else.
1
233
Ananth Eleswarapu retweeted
I think the #1 thing people need to learn early in their career (especially in startups) - you can either be right or you can be effective. Too often people focus on the former, not the latter.
If you try to be right all the time, people dislike working with you. If you try to be effective, people love working with you and you now have a platform to *then* be right.
Ananth Eleswarapu retweeted
No ownership?
But you want owner mentality?
Take a hike. 👎🏼
Doctors for generations accepted being at the mercy of their pagers. Now, younger physicians are questioning medicine’s workaholic culture.
“All us old guys are taking ER call, and you got guys in their 30s at home every night. It’s just a sore spot.” on.wsj.com/4saHdDE
This matches my observations in surgery.
Many great surgeons were not exceptional trainees (didn't get into med school or residency on their first try, for example).
And the most exceptional surgeons are often people who have deep curiosity about things outside the OR.
What does it take to achieve the highest level of human performance? Across athletics, science, chess, and music
@ScienceMagazine
science.org/doi/10.1126/scie…
2
270
My last 6 cases:
Emergent discectomy in young woman with cauda equina syndrome
Posterior cervical foraminotomy in single mom that can't work or take care of her kid due to radicular pain
Posterior cervical lami/fusion in pro athlete with OPLL and myelopathy...
I think spine surgeons should consider that despite how much they get paid for their work, when ppl say healthcare is a right we hardly think about
spinal fusion for low back pain. Like, sorry main character, spine surgery’s far from anyone’s first idea of essential healthcare.
1
2
271
Surgery is weird in that the income distribution is so flat.
A top software developer, lawyer, hedge fund manager etc can easily make 10 million +.
The best surgeons make salaries that are high compared to the median wage but low compared to other superstar professionals.
5
192
Every time a new AI model comes out I like to test it by asking difficult questions about spine surgery. So far the models have all given answers that would seem true to a layperson but are obviously false if you have real expertise.
Until Gemini 3...
2
3
67
Insurance companies should not be allowed to mandate that a patient joint a "virtual care" program prior to getting a treatment that their doctor has prescribed.
Most of these programs are slop and essentially a time tax to discourage the patient from actual treatment.
2
60
Moravec's paradox applies within radiology.
AI systems can't read films like a human radiologist. But they can do things no human can do, like reconstruct a synthetic CT from MRI images. That alone will cut costs and save lives from decreased radiation/cancer.
"AI isn't replacing radiologists" good article
Expectation: rapid progress in image recognition AI will delete radiology jobs (e.g. as famously predicted by Geoff Hinton now almost a decade ago). Reality: radiology is doing great and is growing.
There are a lot of imo naive predictions out there on the imminent impact of AI on the job market. E.g. a ~year ago, I was asked by someone who should know better if I think there will be any software engineers still today. (Spoiler: I think we're going to make it). This is happening too broadly.
The post goes into detail on why it's not that simple, using the example of radiology:
- the benchmarks are nowhere near broad enough to reflect actual, real scenarios.
- the job is a lot more multifaceted than just image recognition.
- deployment realities: regulatory, insurance and liability, diffusion and institutional inertia.
- Jevons paradox: if radiologists are sped up via AI as a tool, a lot more demand shows up.
I will say that radiology was imo not among the best examples to pick on in 2016 - it's too multi-faceted, too high risk, too regulated. When looking for jobs that will change a lot due to AI on shorter time scales, I'd look in other places - jobs that look like repetition of one rote task, each task being relatively independent, closed (not requiring too much context), short (in time), forgiving (the cost of mistake is low), and of course automatable giving current (and digital) capability. Even then, I'd expect to see AI adopted as a tool at first, where jobs change and refactor (e.g. more monitoring or supervising than manual doing, etc). Maybe coming up, we'll find better and broader set of examples of how this is all playing out across the industry.
About 6 months ago, I was also asked to vote if we will have less or more software engineers in 5 years. Exercise left for the reader.
Full post (the whole The Works in Progress Newsletter is quite good):
worksinprogress.news/p/why-a…
1
1
157
As spine surgeons, 90% of the benefit we can provide patients is neural decompression. Maybe 99%. Everything else is marginal.
88
There are two reasons for this:
One is incentives - Facebook makes more money if there ads are well targeted. Hospitals do not get paid more if their interventions are effective.
Two is competition - medical care is balkanized into local hospital systems...
companies like Facebook record every imaginable interaction their users have with the platform. they log each of your clicks and taps. they keep track of how long your gaze lingered on a post, whether you were on the same WiFi as that woman who might be your friend, which instagram reel you watched three times.
for a single user this is quaint, but these practices are done on a planetary scale across all technology giants. they create petabytes of data per day and keep it for as long as the European regulators will let them. then they can have machine intelligence instrument it into useful knowledge for their cybernetic control systems that build newsfeeds, serve ads, decide how much compute to spend on you, which SKUs should be in which warehouses right before you want them. the Hive metastore bills run into the billions
hospitals throw most of their data and telemetry out after each case, every single day. they record videos of vascular surgeries, endoscopies, discovering interesting physiologies. sometimes they're not recorded at all and most of them the time they delete them as soon as they’re done
it's even worse for physiologic waveforms (ECG, EEG, arterial lines) which are essentially never recorded anywhere at all. milisecond scale views of patient's brains, vasculatures, hearts are generated and instantly destroyed. all of these time series of course predict people's hearts stopping, brains exploding, etc ahead of time. surgeons teleoperate robots, none of the micro-movements are recorded, policies never learned, never correlated into which outcomes were successful or not
this would be unthinkable to most software people whose instinct is to record everything everywhere never mind the cloud costs, because we are sure there will be some use for it later and some model to be trained later. i don't have a prescription here per se my point is just that our civilization routinely hoards and treasures some of the silliest data in the world "i pressed like on the john pork reel" & destroys much of all the most important data it generates and limits what machines can learn
Low cost med school pathway:
Drop undergrad requirement.
Anyone that can self study and get 240+ on step 1/2 get admitted directly to 3rd year.
Years 3+4 are work study - tuition free but you spend half the time doing entry level work in the clinic/hospital...
Let me put this a different way. If we don't learn to train drs in a quick way. Let's say six to seven versus eight to ten year we will be living in a largely PA and NP world. Fine in some areas. Horrible in others.
There's a new version of this post
1
1
93














