
Melbourne Victoria š¦šŗ supporter of @gomvfc @ManCity @CollingwoodFC @Warriors
Melbourne, Victoria
Joined January 2023
- Tweets1.1K
- Following602
- Followers149
- Likes4.7K
Donnarumma is objectively a worse keeper than Trafford. Gigi is a massive liability #RBLMCI
Allan Cullinger retweeted
šØJamie Carragher absolutely tears into Premier League referees over Vuskovicās controversial handball against Manchester City:
š£ļøReporter: Jamie, whatās your reaction to the decision not to award Manchester City a penalty for Vuskovicās handball?
šļøCarragher: Honestly, how is that not a penalty? I want someone to explain the decision to me because Iām genuinely struggling to understand what these officials are seeing. His hand is involved in the incident, the ball makes contact, and somehow weāre expected to accept that itās not a penalty?
Weāve seen penalties awarded for much less this season. Weāve seen defenders punished for incidents that are nowhere near as controversial as this one. So why is this particular decision different?
And this is exactly why people are beginning to lose faith in Premier League officiating. Every weekend thereās another controversial decision, another explanation from PGMOL and another situation where supporters are left scratching their heads.
The Premier League is losing its credibility because of these referees. You cannot market this competition as the best league in the world while allowing officiating standards to become such a major talking point.
VAR was introduced to eliminate these obvious mistakes, not to give referees another opportunity to confuse everybody. Whatās the point of having five officials watching the same incident from different angles if they still cannot reach the correct decision?
And imagine being a Manchester City player or supporter. Youāve worked throughout the game, youāre fighting for the result, and then a decision like this goes against you. These moments can completely change the outcome of football matches.
At some point, the referees have to take responsibility. You cannot keep blaming interpretation every time thereās a controversial decision.
Allan Cullinger retweeted
šØRoy Keane on Luka VuÅ”koviÄās controversial handball against Manchester City:
š£ļø Roy Keane: āIām genuinely struggling to understand what football has become when we can look at an incident like that and somehow conclude that itās not a penalty because it wasnāt intentional.
āSince when did we introduce a system where officials have to establish whether a handball was intentional before deciding whether itās a foul? What exactly are we watching here?
āLetās go back to the incident. Anderson gets the ball inside the box and takes a shot. It takes a deflection off a Brighton playerās head, and then the ball clearly strikes VuÅ”koviÄās hand. His arm is away from his body, the ball hits it, and it changes the direction of the ball.
āNow, Iām not a referee, but I know what Iām looking at. His hand is in a position that makes his body bigger, and the contact has a direct impact on the play.
āVAR takes its time, examines the incident and comes back with the explanation that it was unintentional. Unintentional? Thatās utter nonsense!
āAre we now saying that every handball inside the penalty area should be ignored as long as a player can convince us he didnāt mean it? Thatās not how the game should work. The position of the arm, the movement and the impact on the play all matter.
āAnd if Iām Enzo Maresca right now, Iām absolutely furious. Youāre losing 1-0, youāve had two potential handball decisions go against you, and youāre not getting a penalty from an incident that deserves serious scrutiny.
āI would be asking the officials what exactly theyāre seeing. Iād want somebody to explain that decision to me because, from where Iām sitting, it makes absolutely no sense.
āIāve watched the replay, Gary has watched it, Scholesy has watched it, and weāre all looking at the same incident. You donāt have to agree with every decision, but you have to explain how the officials arrived at that conclusion.
āAnd letās not pretend Manchester City havenāt had their own frustrations with officials either. Weāve seen them lose important decisions in games where the consequences are enormous. Itās absolute broad daylight robbery, mate! Big decisions are being missed right in front of everybodyās eyes.
āAnd the problem is that this is becoming normal in the Premier League. Every weekend, weāre discussing another controversial decision, another VAR explanation and another manager demanding answers. Thatās not what this technology was introduced for.
āThatās the problem with VAR. It was introduced to correct obvious mistakes, but sometimes it creates even bigger arguments. We spend five minutes examining an incident, only to come away more confused than we were when it happened.
āIf a defenderās hand is away from his body, the ball strikes it and that contact changes the direction of the ball inside the penalty area, then I want a proper explanation for why itās not a penalty. You cannot tell managers and supporters to respect the rules when the people enforcing those rules cannot provide a convincing explanation.ā
āAnd please, donāt come back to me with the word āunintentionalā as if that ends the discussion. Football is not played with your hands in your pockets. The officials have a responsibility to get these decisions right.ā
Allan Cullinger retweeted
šØšøšŖ Zlatan IbrahimoviÄ on Premier League clubs celebrating Manchester Cityās 115 charges:
š£ļø Zlatan: āI donāt blame them for celebrating these charges. (laughs) We are talking about a club that has traumatized almost every other club in this league for years. Pep came to the Premier League hearing everyone say itās the most difficult league in the world, then he came and farmed the league like it was a Division Two league.
āHe exposed them. He dominated them for years. So if they canāt win against Manchester City on the pitch, I understand why they are celebrating what is happening off it.
āBut now they talk as if these charges were the reason Manchester City dominated. Like that was the main tactic City came with onto the pitch. Forgetting the beautiful football they played, how they controlled games and how they actually won those trophies.
āYou can celebrate the charges, you can talk about them, you can wait for the verdict. But donāt rewrite football history. Manchester City dominated on the pitch. That is why they won all those trophies.ā
Iām not arguing that City should just be excused if the findings stand. If the independent commission has found that the club breached the financial rules, then those breaches are real and City should face whatever sanction is ultimately determined after the appeal process.
What I disagree with is the jump from that to āCity cheated, and thatās why they won everything.ā
Firstly, the famous ā115 chargesā were never 115 separate acts of City buying players they werenāt entitled to buy. A lot of the number comes from the same categories of alleged conduct being charged under multiple rules and across multiple seasons, plus a large group of charges concerning failure to cooperate with the Premier League investigation.
More importantly, look at the actual periods covered by the substantive financial charges.
The Premier Leagueās own charge sheet says:
⢠inaccurate financial information: 2009/10ā2017/18
⢠manager remuneration: 2009/10ā2012/13
⢠player remuneration: 2010/11ā2015/16
⢠UEFA FFP compliance: 2013/14ā2017/18
⢠Premier League PSR: 2015/16ā2017/18
From December 2018 onwards, the charges were about Cityās cooperation with the investigation ā not allegations that City continued breaching FFP/PSR or falsifying their financial position.
That distinction matters.
If the argument is that Cityās entire era of dominance only happened because they were financially cheating, you then have to explain the period after 2017/18, because that is where a huge amount of Cityās success occurred.
City won the Premier League in 2018/19, 2020/21, 2021/22, 2022/23 and 2023/24, as well as the Champions League and Treble in 2022/23. Those seasons are not the subject of the substantive financial-accounting charges in this case.
Obviously, you can argue that investment in the earlier period helped build the foundations of the club. I think that is fair. And if City improperly increased their allowable spending during those earlier years, that could have provided a competitive advantage.
But that is very different from saying āCity cheated, therefore the trophies are only because they cheated.ā
To establish that, youād need to show what the actual financial advantage was, how much extra spending it permitted, and how that advantage caused the subsequent sporting success. Simply saying ā114 chargesā doesnāt answer any of those questions.
Thereās also a massive difference between saying:
āCity breached financial regulations.ā
and:
āWithout those breaches, City would not have won their trophies.ā
The first now appears to be the commissionās finding, subject to appeal.
The second is a counterfactual claim that hasnāt been established just because there are a large number of charges.
So Iām perfectly happy to acknowledge that if the findings stand, City broke rules and should be sanctioned accordingly. What I donāt accept is rewriting nearly two decades of football as though 114 charges means 114 instances of buying success illegally.
Especially when the substantive financial allegations themselves end in 2017/18, while much of Cityās greatest period of success came afterwards.
140
Allan Cullinger retweeted
The fact that you can kick a player while on the ground twice and NOT see even a Yellow šØ says a lot about this referee.
Hey @AlboMP, could Labor put as much effort into ensuring first home owners can afford to keep their homes as you are getting people into their first home ?
95
Isnāt it funny how we only see these type of antics from the ātolerantā left.
Pauline Hanson says she tells it like it is.
But her record says otherwise.
Sheās opposed wage rises, affordable childcare, higher pensions and affordable housing measures ā every time working Australians needed someone to fight for them.
We thought someone should say it plainly. So we did.
Bullshit, Pauline.
211
Allan Cullinger retweeted
Socceroos World Cup opener falling at 2:00 PM on a Sunday. These World Cup time slots feel like a little treat for all the years of waking up to watch football at stupid hours in the morning.
Allan Cullinger retweeted
Kids crying out for Khusanov to sign their City shirts. And he just walks right over and does it. What a player, man. š©µ
Allan Cullinger retweeted
šØšØ| JUST IN: Julian Ćlvarez is set to šššššš Arsenal's approach as he 'doesn't want to go to London'. āš¦š·
[@goal]
Imagine thinking you could win the Champions League by getting a sneaky goal then defending from the 6th minute.
Arsenals anti-football play style might work in the PL, but it will never work in one off games. 1 SOT and 25% possessions š
They think they were the ābetterā team and deserved to win it. Stats say otherwise.
Football won last night.
1
68























