Pinned Tweet
Why is it insane? It’s how she feels lmao. And yes the Odyssey does have admirable female characters but it also has patriarchal elements. Mary Beard literally used the Odyssey as her opening example of Western literature beginning with a woman being told to shut up.
This is insane. Actually insane. I am left speechless. They don't even pretend to know the actual story anymore. If yall bothered with reading even the synopsis, you'd know how absolutely wrong this is and how vital and diverse the women of the Odyssey are.
13
1,919
dreyfus retweeted
You have Ukrainians, & foreigners, of all social & religious backgrounds fighting the russian invader in Ukraine. "Rayana" was a drone operator in the Sheikh Mansur Battalion. Sadly, like many drone operators in the last months, she fell in combat . Hero 🇺🇦.
A gem of the Arabic-Latin translation movement is al-Ghazali’s Aims of the Philosophers, translated in Toledo in the 12th century. I loved how they rendered the hadiths into Latin.
Professor Peter Adamson:
"The Arabic-Latin translation movement happened around the end of the 12th century and so from a European persepctive, philosophy in the Islamic world ends at around 1200 because that's when they translated stuff so anything that happened in the Islamic East after that was invisible to the Medievals because it was never translated."
1
1
422
More on the Arabic-Latin translation movement
Loud confidence and thin knowledge tend to travel together.
Voltaire, Essai sur les mœurs: “we received almost everything from the Arabs/Muslims: astronomy, chemistry, medicine, arithmetic, algebra, geography.” He wrote “presque”, and he was in polemic mode, but he wrote it.
Europeans went to learn. Daniel of Morley hurried to Toledo to hear the wisest philosophers in the world who were Muslims. Gerard of Cremona learned Arabic there to translate the Almagest. Regiomontanus lectured on al-Farghani at Padua in 1464. Risner’s 1572 Optics title page reads “Alhazeni ARABIS”. The books were never hidden, and Europe said where it got them.
Ibn al haythem laying the foundations for modern physics etc i can go on and on
Without that transmission, the Renaissance these people credit for their liberalism would have had far less to build on. Truth is without the Muslims translating the works of the greeks and bettering them the renaissance would not be possible
The Latin translation movement in Toledo and Sicily moved this library into European hands. Scholasticism, and the universities that grew out of it, ran on that inheritance. Anyone who traces the genealogy of Western rationalism honestly finds Baghdad, Cordoba and Cairo along the road.
Inside the tradition the debates were fierce. Mu’tazila, Ash’aris, Hanbalis, falasifa and Sufis argued about reason, revelation and the limits of each, in writing, for centuries. Anyone who thinks Muslims were forbidden to think has never opened a kalam manual.
Some of the thinkers our own tradition considers the ‘worst’ like Ibn Sina and Ibn Arabi, who were called kafir or zindiq by some scholars are when it comes to philosophy beside the giants of the West. Ibn Sina’s flying man sits next to Descartes’ cogito, and Ibn Arabi’s wahdat al-wujud gets compared to Spinoza’s monism, which came four centuries later. Any serious student of philosophy runs into these comparisons.
Meanwhile many liberals who say “Only stupid people are Muslim. To be Muslim you have to switch your brain off.” carry on as if history began in the 1990s.
They live on a moral inheritance shaped over centuries by Christianity, and thinkers from Nietzsche to Habermas to Tom Holland have argued exactly that, yet they attack religion as if their values came from nowhere. People who can’t say where their own beliefs come from are in a poor position to lecture anyone about knowledge
12
dreyfus retweeted
Ibn Arabi and Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi on the possibility of prophetic ijtihād being mistaken:
الـفتوحات المکیة، ج 4، ص 469 | ابن عربي، محيي الدين | مکتبة مدرسة الفقاهة
Replying to @SYED_A_L_I @fznmomin
3. The more controversial approach:
Even if, for the sake of argument, I grant that the Prophet himself believed it to be historically true, I still do not see that as much of a problem. The Prophet was not sent as a historian, and the precise details of history are not the ...
dreyfus retweeted
Being Arab doesn’t make her a better Muslim.
The Mutazili poet said:
“The Prophet’s true family are those who follow his religion, whether Black or White.
For were his family limited merely to his blood relatives, every prayer of blessing would encompass the tyrant Abu Lahab.”
Islam does this btw. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ (who was a merchant, not a farmer) once suggested that farmers stop pollinating their fruit trees. Their harvest suffered and he basically told them:
I just gave my personal opinion, y’all should know better since you’re the experts here

ALT This doesn’t diminish Prophet Muhammad’s ﷺ prophethood or the perfection of Islam. He was infallible in delivering God’s revelation, not all-knowing about every worldly matter. Things like farming techniques or what outfit works best for a job interview aren’t part of his prophetic mission. He was human, just like the other prophets, and only knew what God taught him. This is a reminder of his humanity and why we shouldn’t deify him.
For those wondering why he did this, he ﷺ just gave his opinion, but his followers took it as divine revelation, which isn’t on him. He even cleared it up later. Btw not everything a prophet says is from God and this was a learning experience for the early Muslims. No harm done.
Replying to @RealiaAmelia
He wasn’t familiar with pollination so when he saw them doing it, he asked what they were up to and said he didn’t think it’d help. It was just a passing thought but since they’d witnessed his miracles they took it seriously, unfortunately. Not on him, he cleared it up later.
dreyfus retweeted
Allah said:
وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَاكَ إِلَّا رَحْمَةً لِّلْعَالَمِين
“And We have not sent you (Muhammad) except as a mercy to the creation.”
Ibn Taymiyyah said about Ahl al-Sunnah:
“They are the most knowledgeable of people concerning the truth & the most merciful toward creation.”
dreyfus retweeted
If You Speak Against Every Salafi Who Makes a Mistake, No One Will Remain - Shaykh Saliḥ Aal Shaykh
dusunnah.com/video/if-you-sp…
dreyfus retweeted
Prophet Muhammad (SAW) was a deeply sensitive man. He felt for the brokenhearted. He cried for the orphan. He cared for the weak. He shortened his prayer at the sound of a baby's cry. Don't let anyone shame you for having a soft heart when the best of creation never hardened his.
Why’re you deliberately omitting the context? This isn’t even about marriage or interracial relationships. It’s about righteous companionship and befriending people with similar values and character. Stop trying to paint Islam as racist.
Being Arab doesn’t make her a better Muslim.
The Mutazili poet said:
“The Prophet’s true family are those who follow his religion, whether Black or White.
For were his family limited merely to his blood relatives, every prayer of blessing would encompass the tyrant Abu Lahab.”
dreyfus retweeted
There is actually no worse combination that an idiot + incel + muslim
Be stupid enough to present a ‘scholars opinion’ as evidence
Do we take anything any scholar says or do we weigh it wether it conforms to the Quran and the Sunnah
Furthermore no one should listen to Ghazali when it comes to women/marriage, he has some fascinatingly disturbing views regarding women
dreyfus retweeted
Pseudo intellectuals trying to dunk on salafis as usual they don’t even understand what they’re talking about
Priority doesn’t touch the claim. Nobody says Ibn Taymiyya discovered analogy. Shafi’i used qiyas and Ibn Sina used tajriba. His thesis is that definition and syllogism can’t deliver what the logicians promise, and that the logic carries an essentialist ontology: Sowa notes he accepted the syllogism’s form and rejected essence/accident. Ghazali treated logic as a neutral instrument, put a logic primer at the front of al-Mustasfa, and ruled that anyone without it can’t be trusted in his sciences. That’s what Ibn Taymiyya went after. Your own list has the man who brought logic into fiqh and graded metaphysics by demonstrative standards like let’s be serious man
dreyfus retweeted
People fail to realize that Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah (raḥimahullāh) was a true polymath through and through.
He was a muḥaddith, mufassir, faqīh, logician, scientist, mathematician, chemist, physicist, biologist. grammarian,
linguist. theologian, philosopher, etc.
ontop of that was a soldier fighting in the frontlines against the mongols, the fiercest military at the time.
Ibn Taymiyyah is amazing, modern computer scientists (like John Sowa) have noted that Ibn Taymiyyah’s aggressive critique of strict Aristotelian logic, where he favored situational analogy (Qiyas al-Tamthil) and learning incrementally from specific data points, uncannily models the exact way Modern Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning algorithms operate today. Instead of following rigid rules, they learn patterns dynamically from historical data.
The links to the resources:
share.google/GYlcjkEJin9ac00…
share.google/SkWr59jeLMHkT14…
>The Palmyran Creed (العقيدة التدمرية)
> The Epiphanian Creed (العقيدة الحموية)
>The Wasiti Creed (العقيدة الواسطية)
Salafis literally translated these 3 polemical works by Ibn Taymiyyah on theology and philosophy into a gorillion languages and distributed them globally
dreyfus retweeted
I hate to give him credit, but you can tell Mamdani isn't strict about his personal faith because his wife dresses just as casually as he does. It gives people more reassurance that he respects the secular nature of the office he holds, rightfully or otherwise.
But El-Sayed? Eh.
The numbers 70 and 72 keep recurring in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, which always caught my attention. The 72 sects of Ahl al-Kitab/Bidah, the 70 elders (+mentioned 70 times), and the Septuagint (literally 70) and its 72 translators.
something SUPER interesting to note about the clementine homilies is that it claims that the people responsible for corrupting the Torah are the 70 men men with Moses, who would corrupt it after hearing Moses recite it.
Interestingly, in our earliest tafsirs, many scholars took the opinion that 2:75, that is the group who used to listen to the word of god and alter it, are the same 70 man of Moses
1
400
dreyfus retweeted
Do Jinns Have Phones? Btw Phones didn't exist at the time of Ibn Taymiyyah, that makes it more crazy!!
















































