Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof) header
Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof) profile picture

statistics obsessor, economics enjoyer, currently building data software #Python/#rstats & everything social science; (some) opinions revised regularly

Chicago, IL
Joined June 2014
Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)Photo by Nathaniel Bechhofer (@bechhof)
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
Folks I am BEGGING you. Stop reporting youth unemployment rate trends without looking at employment and participation. This a huge source of confusion and its late to be still making this mistake.
Unemployment rates are an increasingly bad signal about the health of the youth labor market. The chart in the thread below, showing a steep rise in unemployment rates for young master’s degree holders, is a great example. Employment rates, the percent of all young master’s degree holders that are employed, is flat since 2019. A very different story! You can also see, as @ModeledBehavior and I have pointed out, those without a BA have seen employment rates fall as much or worse than those with a BA.
3
14
1
72
12,921
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
1
16
1
151
10,129
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
🎉 New CSES data! Module 6 Third Advance Release: 55,207 respondents, 29 election studies, 27 polities. PLUS: Our new Data Playground! 📊 Thanks to our global collaborators and CSES Secretariat at @VU_CGD & @gesis_org! 🔗 cses.org/2026/11/17/cses-ann… #CSES #ElectionStudies
12
1
32
1,839
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
This paper is the first to analyze immigrants’ fiscal effects over the 20th & 21st centuries, showing that immigrant surpluses have surged as deficits have exploded. Since 1900, immigrants reduced deficits by $14.6 trillion (excluding interest savings). cato.org/policy-analysis/imm…
3
13
63
3,752
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
the thing that everyone forgets is that COMPUTERS ARE FAST waiting SECONDS for things to load is NOT NORMAL
151
385
53
10,010
265,222
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
⚠️ Numerical issues can go on silently for decades like in the softmax/CE! Similar issues are present in other widely-used divergences like the KL and JSD I just posted this paper overviewing what they are and how to fix them: 📚 arxiv.org/abs/2611.18511
Hi all, I have a new result I'm excited to share. It turns out that *all existing implementations* of softmax and cross-entropy (that's JAX, PyTorch, textbooks, etc) have a subtle bug --- two bugs, actually. A simple rewrite fixes both, and eliminates "slingshots" when grokking:
13
77
12
460
38,205
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
A nice way to promote human collaboration in the age of AI
Ok, this may be my favourite teaching thing ever: for a class in which students write a paper, they were divided into small groups, repeatedly, to share their work with each other and get feedback. But then: after class, they filled out a survey with who helped them and how. They could each nominate up to three people for bonus participation points. And the responses are so heartwarming! First, it's great to see some people really stepping up and helping a lot of their classmates. Second, the answers are creative and funny, like the one about someone who helped out by not understanding (thereby forcing a rethink in how they explained their work). Third, students who didn't know each other exchanged contact info to stay in touch later, which I count as a win. Worked out really well, would do again.
1
5
1,291
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
in this post the Claude-Code dev team boast that 90% of claude-code code is written and verified by agents, without a human review. and then they provide some generic tips about what are good tests etc. but my take is that the real reason they can pull it off is not their amazing auto-testing skills, but the fact that claude-code is essentially a very simple piece of software, they don't have almost any efficiency concerns, no competitors, very little potential of actually harmful bugs or data corruption due to claude code itself, and that many bugs just got swallowed and compensated for by the underlying LLM being so freaking good.
Claude writes better code when it can verify its work. Checks that used to be expensive, like tests, benchmarks, and end-to-end runs, are now cheap. Here’s how the Claude Code team thinks about verification: claude.dev/blog/how-the-clau…
79
20
3
882
65,813
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
codeberg.org was suspended at the .org registry an hour ago, lmao...oh my lord please don't put your projects on here w/o a mirror somewhere else
24
24
15
502
51,927
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
We're in the news window where everything that seems somewhat similar to the last big thing that happened gets an alarming article even if there's no evidence it's unusual or interesting.
NSA CLASSIFIED NETWORK OUTAGE LINKED TO SOFTWARE UPDATE, NOT CYBERATTACK The National Security Agency's classified communications network, NSANet, is temporarily offline due to a software update, according to U.S. officials cited by The Wall Street Journal. Officials say there is no evidence of a cyberattack, easing concerns following recent disruptions involving Microsoft 365, U.S. air traffic systems and JPMorgan Chase. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin stated that the U.S. is not under cyberattack. The clarification suggests the NSA outage is routine maintenance rather than a national security breach.
7
4
1
113
6,949
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
I recently became aware of how confused even many academics are about Pangram. Please, please, look at the audits that have been done before you deliberately sow doubt. (link in thread)
15
69
11
435
46,312
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
New working paper with the brilliant Michal Kolesár: Shrink Responsibly: Empirical Bayes in Economics We review the ins and outs of eB "shrinkage," as applied in econ settings, and illustrate them with an application to public school value-added Some takeaways: - Conventional normal-normal shrinkage, perhaps with an adjustment for precision dependence, can work pretty well -- even when misspecified (like OLS!) - Plenty of interesting questions should not be (but often are) answered with shrinkage; we give alternative estimators for some cases - Elementary and middle schools in Charlotte-Mecklenberg vary widely in value-added, which appears causal. More popular schools are not reliably better, but better schools seem to have higher-achieving peers Link below!
4
39
4
166
15,065
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
Replying to @arindube @dandolfa
The reason more market power in setting wages or prices means lower costs (to profits) from mistakes in wage and price setting is ... the envelope theorem. Here is an example using labor market (monopsony) power and "mistakes" in setting wages.
3
5
1
50
8,830
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
Replying to @ChrSzegedy
You're too smart for this, you know better. Obviously a differentiable curve fitted via SGD can only interpolate. That's true by construction. But if you use this curve as a sampling guide in a search process, then you're doing search, you're no longer interpolating at all. Theorem proving is search. Reasoning chain generation is search. Etc.
17
24
6
543
45,073
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
Bai & Jia (2025) show that in Qing China's imperial exams, merit and ties to powerful examiners were complements: top performers gained most from patrons, so careers looked merit-based even as networks mattered. doi.org/10.1177/000271622614…
12
1
40
3,019
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
I've also been trying out Rex and have noticed the same, it feels like the new big flex will be software that is written with AI, but in such a thoughtful way that it has been refactored to human size and taste again
Rex by @superlogical is phenomenal software. tremendous fit and finish, feels like it was built and designed pre-AI (compliment)
12
4
2
118
7,287
For... reasons we are supposed to believe that this is consistent with a strong version of "RSI" being around the corner, with lame excuses like "you're not seeing the internal models" or "architecture/system design is harder than AI research in the important ways".
first results are in: fable 5.2 still sucks at architecture/system design.
1
4
409
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
Differences in GDP per capita across sub-Saharan Africa are large. Sub-Saharan Africa is the world’s poorest region. Its GDP per person is around $5,000 a year — less than a quarter of the global average of around $22,000. But looking at the region as a whole can make it easy to forget just how different the economies within it are. That’s what this chart shows, by ranking GDP per capita across sub-Saharan African countries. These differences are large. At the top of the chart, Gabon has a GDP per capita of about $19,000, roughly 18 times that of Burundi at the bottom. The gap between the richest and poorest countries in sub-Saharan Africa is even larger than the gap between the region and the world as a whole. (written by @EOrtizOspina)
5
72
6
158
16,155
Nathaniel Bechhofer retweeted
The creator of Sci-hub has finally added semantic search. Side effect: guest queries are public, so you can see what the world is curious about
17
207
14
2,210
57,499