Berna Agar (@bernaagar) header
Berna Agar (@bernaagar) profile picture

Product Growth @Qase_io | Co-founder/CEO @ https://teapawt.net/t.co/0Ud8MODPS5 | Ex-Google Product Marketing Manager | Tweets in spare moments

Barcelona
Joined April 2010
Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)Photo by Berna Agar (@bernaagar)
I shall either find a way or make one!
| yolunu arayanlara.
1
2
650
🎉New book alert! 📢Do female combatants shape foreign support for rebel groups? My new @CambridgeUPress book shows that groups with women fighters receive more foreign backing because they’re seen as more democratic, gender equal and less violent. 🔓Free to read for 2 weeks👇
New Cambridge Element, Public Preferences, Gender, and Foreign Support for Armed Movements, by Çağlayan Başer, out now! Read for free for the next 2 weeks at cup.org/49HjK5q #cambridgeelements #politics
16
14
4
76
8,128
Love this post by @andrewchen! With AI lowering tech defensibility, great products won’t be enough. Marketing will be redefined. Excited to see how startups experiment with GTM & how we shape this shift. The Growth Maze vs The Idea Maze👇 open.substack.com/pub/andrew…
133
Berna Agar retweeted
The buzz over DeepSeek this week crystallized, for many people, a few important trends that have been happening in plain sight: (i) China is catching up to the U.S. in generative AI, with implications for the AI supply chain. (ii) Open weight models are commoditizing the foundation-model layer, which creates opportunities for application builders. (iii) Scaling up isn’t the only path to AI progress. Despite the massive focus on and hype around processing power, algorithmic innovations are rapidly pushing down training costs. About a week ago, DeepSeek, a company based in China, released DeepSeek-R1, a remarkable model whose performance on benchmarks is comparable to OpenAI’s o1. Further, it was released as an open weight model with a permissive MIT license. At Davos last week, I got a lot of questions about it from non-technical business leaders. And on Monday, the stock market saw a “DeepSeek selloff”: The share prices of Nvidia and a number of other U.S. tech companies plunged. (As of the time of writing, some have recovered somewhat.) Here’s what I think DeepSeek has caused many people to realize: China is catching up to the U.S. in generative AI. When ChatGPT was launched in November 2022, the U.S. was significantly ahead of China in generative AI. Impressions change slowly, and so even recently I heard friends in both the U.S. and China say they thought China was behind. But in reality, this gap has rapidly eroded over the past two years. With models from China such as Qwen (which my teams have used for months), Kimi, InternVL, and DeepSeek, China had clearly been closing the gap, and in areas such as video generation there were already moments where China seemed to be in the lead. I’m thrilled that DeepSeek-R1 was released as an open weight model, with a technical report that shares many details. In contrast, a number of U.S. companies have pushed for regulation to stifle open source by hyping up hypothetical AI dangers such as human extinction. It is now clear that open source/open weight models are a key part of the AI supply chain: Many companies will use them. If the U.S. continues to stymie open source, China will come to dominate this part of the supply chain and many businesses will end up using models that reflect China’s values much more than America’s. Open weight models are commoditizing the foundation-model layer. As I wrote previously, LLM token prices have been falling rapidly, and open weights have contributed to this trend and given developers more choice. OpenAI’s o1 costs $60 per million output tokens; DeepSeek R1 costs $2.19. This nearly 30x difference brought the trend of falling prices to the attention of many people. The business of training foundation models and selling API access is tough. Many companies in this area are still looking for a path to recouping the massive cost of model training. Sequoia’s article “AI’s $600B Question” lays out the challenge well (but, to be clear, I think the foundation model companies are doing great work, and I hope they succeed). In contrast, building applications on top of foundation models presents many great business opportunities. Now that others have spent billions training such models, you can access these models for mere dollars to build customer service chatbots, email summarizers, AI doctors, legal document assistants, and much more. Scaling up isn’t the only path to AI progress. There’s been a lot of hype around scaling up models as a way to drive progress. To be fair, I was an early proponent of scaling up models. A number of companies raised billions of dollars by generating buzz around the narrative that, with more capital, they could (i) scale up and (ii) predictably drive improvements. Consequently, there has been a huge focus on scaling up, as opposed to a more nuanced view that gives due attention to the many different ways we can make progress. Driven in part by the U.S. AI chip embargo, the DeepSeek team had to innovate on many optimizations to run on less-capable H800 GPUs rather than H100s, leading ultimately to a model trained (omitting research costs) for under $6M of compute. It remains to be seen if this will actually reduce demand for compute. Sometimes making each unit of a good cheaper can result in more dollars in total going to buy that good. I think the demand for intelligence and compute has practically no ceiling over the long term, so I remain bullish that humanity will use more intelligence even as it gets cheaper. I saw many different interpretations of DeepSeek’s progress here in X, as if it was a Rorschach test that allowed many people to project their own meaning onto it. I think DeepSeek-R1 has geopolitical implications that are yet to be worked out. And it’s also great for AI application builders. My team has already been brainstorming ideas that are newly possible only because we have easy access to an open advanced reasoning model. This continues to be a great time to build! [Original text: deeplearning.ai/the-batch/is… ]
277
997
128
4,274
618,281
Harika bir başarı! 👏👏Yalnız inşallah bunu gören halam ekonomi okuyup ekonomist olmadım diye beni darlamaz 😂
BREAKING NEWS The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2024 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James A. Robinson “for studies of how institutions are formed and affect prosperity.” #NobelPrize
2
219
Seni Kimler Aldı (live) feat. @bengubeker Youtube'da yayında! youtu.be/bXwljtONzb8?si=W8uw…
1
216
“insanı olgunlaştıran şey karar vermektir. iki yol görüp, buradan deyip gitmektir. insan her şeyi bırakıp nazilli'ye taşınırsa da büyür. ama bunların hiçbiri başına gelen şeyler olmamalı, bunları tercih edip yaşıyor olmalısın.”
45
959
159
10,914
799,616
AI is like water! How you'll differentiate your product in the AI era is a huge question. Check out this video and essay linked to the video for insights. youtu.be/vYedXHY2yfA?si=CaoP… Thanks for sharing @yigityucel
2
173
Berna Agar retweeted
Paola Egonu'ya söylemek istediklerimiz...
9
158
7
4,311
320,569
Türkiye - İtalya maçına 12 saat var!
3
150
Volleyball Nation’s League started today. Our first game is tomorrow 🏐 Can’t wait. OpenAI, Gemini işinize bakın kardeşim. Kafam çok meşgul 😏
2
292
"Anything that can go wrong will go wrong, and at the worst possible time." Edward Murphy'nin canı rahmet istedi zaar.
1
3
251
We lost a monumental figure in psychology & economics, Daniel Kahneman, yesterday. His groundbreaking work on human judgment & decision-making leaves an indelible mark on how we perceive the world and ourselves. His legacy will continue to inspire and challenge us. Rest in peace.
1
2
265
Berna Agar retweeted
7
23
213
12,251
If Google wants to win the AI competition, it needs to find a way to stop internal politics and bureaucracy. Often times Googlers focus on small wins to progress in their career. This mindset needs to change imo.
GenAI poses a much deeper pickle for Google than I initially assumed... The last few weeks completely echo the time I was at Google in the early 2000's when we were up against Microsoft - except this time Google is on the receiving end. Looking back, we beat Microsoft not because we had better tech, but because we forced them to play on our terms AND at our "clockspeed." Many (myself included) were viewing Google's LLM problem as one of catching up with the technology - specifically OpenAI. It stands to reason that with all its incredible talent, infrastructure, users and data, Google can and will catch up to OpenAI and likely be able to build better technology. But I'm realizing that's likely to be wrong. The debacle last week (and even more, Google's response) puts a point on the real and somewhat unsolvable problem Google faces now. Google isn't going to lose to OpenAI tomorrow - it lost to it over the last ten years. The problem that Google faces today relative to the likes of OpenAI and Perplexity is very similar to what we did to Microsoft 20 years ago. What ChatGPT in particular has made us realize is that many of the tasks that we have so far labeled "search" and where we click on blue links are really tasks of research, analysis and decision-making. We viewed Google as the way to complete these tasks because 20 years ago, Google solved the most important challenge in that workflow, which was to bring all the world's information to within one click in the form of a search engine. Over these 20 years, Google built and has been harvesting one of the most profitable business models in history (remember that we used to talk with similar admiration of the operating system + desktop productivity biz model). The problem now, is that ChatGPT, Perplexity and others have shown us that A LOT of the tasks we used to think of as search engine-based workflows are even better served through an exchange with this new piece of technological magic (similarly to how PageRank made Google Search feel magical 25 years ago). The real problem for Google is one of clockspeed. Google all of a sudden has its ass on fire and is trying to innovate into the future. But, that innovation now has to happen at the heart of its business. OpenAI doesn't care about messing up an ads business model - they can just iterate with a product/quality purity that is impossible for Google to get. Google isn't going to lose to OpenAI in the coming few years. It has lost over the past decade, when it could have evolved/iterated AI into its model at its success-encumbered clockspeed. Now that the game is on, but on a startup clockspeed, there is no chance for Google to catch up and even less win this next cycle. This problem compounds over time, because every single day that goes by, we are all feeding OpenAI our usage patterns, feedback, custom GPTs, integrations, etc... At this stage, there is no way for Google to shift its clockspeed unless it is willing to give the middle finger to the market and its customers for a while and say sorry, the future beckons - feel free to opt out and invest your money elsewhere. The sad part is that Google actually has the wherewithal to do that, but few incumbents are ever able to pull it off. Meta/Zuck have done this several times (mobile transition, VR bet and now AI), so we know it's possible, but it is exceedingly unlikely for that to happen. People often think that's only possible because Mark is the founder, but I think it's because of his posture between risk and opportunity. I'll close this with the phrase that I think captures this posture: Our missed opportunities will cost us more than our mistakes
3
294
Berna Agar retweeted
Introducing Sora, our text-to-video model. Sora can create videos of up to 60 seconds featuring highly detailed scenes, complex camera motion, and multiple characters with vibrant emotions. openai.com/sora Prompt: “Beautiful, snowy Tokyo city is bustling. The camera moves through the bustling city street, following several people enjoying the beautiful snowy weather and shopping at nearby stalls. Gorgeous sakura petals are flying through the wind along with snowflakes.”
8,577
28,994
42,200
127,486
98,245,930
♥️ Tired of swiping left on love? Love should be joyful, not stressful. This Valentine's, share your dating experiences with us anonymously and help shape the future of dating. It's quick and confidential. forms.gle/LisrWXTFgBhVWPYAA #ValentinesDay #valentinesday2024
3
5
331
They can watch me cleaning :) I volunteer.
A robot that will do all of our housework? We're sold. Carmaker Toyota is developing robots capable of learning to do household chores by observing how humans take on the tasks. wired.trib.al/xF9YKKj
2
321