
Assoc Prof @PittLaw & @SciPitt, fellow @yaleisp, 🐕s🐇s, 🏀⚾🏈, @Cal alum #cybersecurity | #blockchain | #law | #techpolicy (RT,♥️ ≠ agreement, views mine.)
Dallas, TX
Joined February 2009
- Tweets8.2K
- Following916
- Followers1K
- Likes16.1K
Pinned Tweet
I study, teach & tweet about law, computer/info science and public administration topics: #cybersecurity, #cybercrime, #blockchain, the #presidency, public #administration, #CyberWarfare, #privacy, #AI, criminal #law and procedure, & #NationalSecurity.
More info on my website.
2
12
David Thaw retweeted
If you work in tech policy long enough, you'll see lots of friends sticking theory-based views as techincal & political realities change. Especially true of academics, who stick to outmoded ideas for decades! It's quite jarring for pragmatic folks who are trying to make a change.
Lessons for *so* many fields in here...
John von Neumann helped invent the modern computer, and he got furious when one of his grad students made programming easier.
The student, Don Gillies, was stuck hand-translating programs into binary for von Neumann's machine at Princeton. So he wrote a program to do the translating for him, which he later said was the first assembler. Von Neumann told him you don't use a valuable scientific computing instrument for clerical work.
And honestly, for the early 1950s he had a point. The machine was the precious thing back then, and a grad student's afternoon was close to free.
That math flipped fast. John Backus, who led the FORTRAN team at IBM, later wrote that by 1954 a computer center's programmers usually cost at least as much as the computer itself, and a quarter to half of the machine's time went to debugging their code. Human time had become the thing worth saving.
So Backus's team built a language where you write something close to algebra and the machine writes the code. A lot of experienced programmers hated it. Backus said many of them saw themselves as "members of a priesthood," guarding skills too complex for ordinary people. He also wrote that they rightly saw their work as a creative art, and he took that seriously. His team was convinced FORTRAN would never catch on unless its programs came out almost as efficient as hand-coded ones, so that's where most of their effort went. Once it delivered, people could stop worrying about the machine code underneath. Most programmers working today have never read the assembly their code turns into.
That's the question this video is asking. What was every programming language reaching for?
Karpathy, who's at Anthropic now, posted in January that he's "mostly programming in English now" and admitted it hurts the ego a bit. In Sonar's new survey, developers say AI writes or heavily assists about 65% of the code they commit, up from 42% a year ago.
So we're back in 1957, fighting over whether you can trust what the machine wrote without reading it. Only 45% of those developers think AI code is even functionally correct, and the share who say they always check it before committing still dropped from 48% to 39% in a year. 76% admit they generate AI code faster than they can verify it.
That's where the old-school programmer comes back in. By this summer, software job postings on Indeed were up almost 15% since Claude Code launched, while postings overall fell 7%. 71% of that rebound went to senior roles, mostly people who know the new tools too. Knowing what's actually happening underneath, the same skill the priesthood guarded, is what checking all that code takes.
Grace Hopper had the answer in the 1950s. She wanted people to write programs in plain English, and she was told computers didn't understand English. She died in 1992, about 30 years before they did.
71
"The Turing Test doesn't test what you think it tests" just like "AI doesn't think the way you think it does" (teapawt.net/dbthaw/status/20984197…).
@bengrossbg and @SamBuntz make key points and over-anthropromorphization impedes meaningful debate.
Full 🧵 here: teapawt.net/dbthaw/status/20984197…
Saw this Nagel quote going around and wanted to offer some more elucidation. Here's a brief thread 🧵:
Let's start with a question: Why do we think that models that can chat with us are conscious but models that can recognize faces or produce images or drive cars aren’t? (1/8)
68
Apropos of nothing, the unrestricted "Move Fast and Break Things" and "MVP" bills are coming due.
1
3
126
Apropos of nothing, my book with @GusHurwitz, @dbambauer, and @cybersimplesec says useful things that might be helpful to stuff. Nothing in particular, just stuff.
faculty.westacademic.com/Boo… or amazon.com/Cybersecurity-Int…
David Thaw retweeted
A lot of places learning at a visceral level the meaning of key man risk this week. All the committees and PowerPoint decks and placemats in the world cannot paper over the reality of the unique mind doing things that others can barely explain in hindsight.
David Thaw retweeted
1. You can tell me it's a waste of time for schools to teach literature, but half the executives in Silicon Valley seem to have misunderstood their favorite book, with potentially devastating consequences.
David Thaw retweeted
Be the teacher and scholar you trained years to become.
See our open searches: uaustin.org/careers
David Thaw retweeted
We are hiring an Open-Rank Professor of Economics at @uaustinorg. Start Fall 2027, priority review for applications by Jan 4, 2027.
Please share with any candidates that would be a good fit!
jobs.lever.co/uaustin/1e6d12…
David Thaw retweeted
12 unsolicited emails *today* from high schoolers, undergrads etc., 8 of them fully AI-generated.
I used to read and respond to these, I just can't anymore. The cold email used to be a positive signal of confidence, entrepreneurship, willingness to risk rejection, having done a bit of research. Not anymore.
Capable and entrepreneurial people will need to find a new way to distinguish themselves. I'm not sure what it will be. Maybe by building something original.
It's a lot harder than sending a cold email, but that's good, it means there's still some signal in it.
This could be one of the more important advances in appellate opinion accessibility since PACER.
(Have fun decoding the sarcasm/seriousness synergy in that one!)
Congratulations to the First Circuit on starting to potentially issue opinions not in Courier (Times NR isn't great but it's better) …
5
378
Reverse-engineering deterministic code (think 1980s/1990s-era video games) is a remarkable demonstration of the tremendous abilities of today's AI technologies and of their utter and complete failures to deserve the name or the anthropromorphizations we ascribe to them.
1
45
Relatedly, I'm even more convinced now than I have been so far of the import of this paper, particularly my analysis of contemporary AI systems and too many participants' misunderstanding of Turing's paper in Mind (the so-called "Turning Test").
I'm excited to share the draft of Impersonating Volition, forthcoming in the @BelmontLawRev, based on a keynote I gave @BelmontLaw in March.
It's a crim/AI piece that makes a short argument for why *current* "AI" technologies cannot be criminally liable.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…
29
David Thaw retweeted
Y2K catastrophism tracing a direct psychological line to AI/SI doomerism hits the cyber intelligence profession harder than would be typically credited. Much of the earliest commercial cyber intel coverage from shops like iDefense went hard on projections of fears but too often untempered by continuity & resilience net assessment. The intel adjacent analysis supporting much of the worst case scenario arguments over hyperscale compute outcomes is of a piece. But there are real matters of concern here, demanding serious consideration and clear eyed methodological approaches.
David Thaw retweeted
“The Chronicle’s freelancer policy asks that submissions be ‘written by you, not AI’ (with rare exceptions). I wrote this essay the way I wrote the article that inspired it, and I invite its editors and readers to judge it accordingly.”
“The author drafted this essay in extended collaboration with Claude Fable 5.1.”
The story of “the article that inspired it”:
“A professional journal recently accepted an article of mine. The editor congratulated me on the acceptance and then made an unusual request. Could I submit another draft written ‘in my voice,’ since this one had some sentences that ‘read like something written by AI’? If I preferred, the editors would revise the piece themselves, ostensibly to ‘humanize’ it, and I could approve their changes.”
“This amusing episode helped me to understand a confusion that now runs through the academy. We have begun to judge analytical writing not by its content but by its suspected origin, which no reader can verify. Because an analytical essay is an argument, and an argument can be evaluated, professional analytical writing should be judged as it always has been: by its quality.”
I'm not sure there's a greater nationwide Rorschach Test than the debate over permanent standard vs daylight time.
No, it's not solvable by science - not real science anyway - the base assumptions "science" depend on artificial constructs.
This is a textbook political question.
1
1
185
The more we allow science to fail to recognize the difference between
(1) scientific inquiry (e.g., under what conditions does dihydrogen monoxide form, disperse and recycle through the environment), and
(2) political questions (when do people prefer to schedule things)
...
1
12


















