Evan Singleton retweeted
Wow. I genuinely did not suspect she was this dumb. From here:
1) Amazon adds NYC-only surcharge to try to maintain profitability after socialists force unions into its distribution chain.
2) People are outraged.
2) City Council outlaws the surcharge.
3) Amazon stops delivering to New Yorkers. We're already the only ones who don't have Walmart.
4) Affordability!
It defies logic that Amazon, a $3 trillion corporation, would raise New Yorkers’ cost of living if it’s forced to adhere to basic regulations and worker protections.
We are crafting legislation that regulates Amazon and protects workers, without impacting prices or jobs.
If Amazon thinks this deceptive campaign will effectively threaten New Yorkers and intimidate this City Council, they are dead wrong.
Evan Singleton retweeted
This is incredible.
Tenants went on a rent strike.
When the owner got foreclosed on, tenants launched a "buyer beware" campaign to scare away investors.
They hoped a nonprofit would step in.
Instead, the building failed to sell at auction.
"Auctions closed without a bid, sending them back to the bank for just $500 apiece," the article says.
The city tried to intervene by backing a proposed bid from one selected group. But the creditor rejected the bids, which did not match the "upset price" -- the size of the judgment the bank holds.
The tenants are now "trying to get repairs on their neglected buildings."
But there's no money for it. The building is being managed by a court-appointed receiver.
citylimits.org/rent-stabiliz…
Frédéric Bastiat gave economics its most useful diagnostic tool in 1850, and most people in government today have never applied it; in fact, they avoid it like the plague.
The tool is simple: when you evaluate any policy, law, or intervention, you must account not only for what you can see, but for what that intervention could destroy before it could exist.
A shopkeeper's son smashes a window. The glazier gets paid. The crowd watching decides this is good for the economy because money circulates. What they cannot see is the suit the shopkeeper planned to buy, the tailor who goes without a sale, the capital that evaporates into replacement rather than expansion. Destruction consumed resources. Nothing was created. This is the broken window fallacy.
Governments run this logic on a civilizational scale.
The 2009 Cash for Clunkers program destroyed 690,000 working vehicles, most of them affordable transportation for lower-income buyers, in exchange for a brief sales spike at GM and Ford. Congress saw the spike; nobody in the Congressional Budget Office modeled the used-car market that you, specifically, lost access to when supply collapsed and prices jumped. The program cost $3 billion, and you paid for it, then you paid again at the used lot.
Minimum wage laws work exactly this way. The politician sees the worker earning $17 an hour instead of $14. The camera follows that worker. The teenager never got hired because the entry-level position was automated or simply eliminated when the math stopped working for the employer. That teenager's first job, his first reference, his first skill set, disappears into the unseen and nobody holds a press conference about it.
Trade tariffs are perhaps the most dishonest application of the seen-and-unseen problem. The steel mill in Pennsylvania stays open. Those workers are visible, photographed, quoted in dispatches. Invisible are the downstream manufacturers, the auto plants, the appliance makers, the construction firms who now buy steel at artificially inflated prices and either raise their prices or cut their own payrolls. The 2018 Section 232 tariffs saved 8,700 steel jobs by one Federal Reserve estimate, while raising costs across steel-consuming industries that employed 6.5 million workers.
Every resource a government spends was first extracted from somewhere else. Every job a subsidy preserves is set against jobs the private sector never created because capital was redirected by force. The seen is always photogenic. The unseen never gets a ribbon-cutting ceremony, which is precisely why politicians ignore it, and you keep paying the difference.
Evan Singleton retweeted
It's concerning that such a large part of the case for Medicare for All (M4A) involves people straight up helping themselves to cartoonishly fictional numbers that almost certainly do not even remotely represent reality.
Presenting the Galvani (2020) figure of 68,000 people based on a poorly adjusted comparison of mortality rates, a biased exclusion of Medicare, Medicaid, and VA/CHAMPUS recipients that increased the mortality gap, and with the entirety of the effect attributed to insurance coverage status instead of the numerous confounders that come along for the ride is incredibly misleading and should give people reason to be cautious about taking what you say about this topic seriously (and if these issues are corrected, the result is essentially null btw).
Of note, the causally informed randomized interventional data available do not even remotely show anything close to this figure on an intention-to-treat analysis, and even when taking the most extreme upper limit of the 95% CI (Re: hurr but the OHIE trial was underpowered 4 mortality) we still don't get such a figure.
Bernie continues to live in a fantasy world. As do the rest of the Medicare for All (M4A) advocates who cite the Yale slop study (or anything from Galvani really), Data for Progress polling, or just their intuitions about administrative burdens and how low-value care partitioning will pan out.
It is already incredibly challenging to have serious good faith discussions with intellectually honest interlocutors about M4A who are willing to be forthcoming about the very real drawbacks and why they think the case for the benefits M4A offers outweighs them when anti-vaxxers are more willing to acknowledge the risks of going unvaccinated than these lunatics are willing to acknowledge just about any drawback of the system they are insisting we subject the entire nation to. It's even more challenging when they feel entitled to help themselves to any comical figures as established empirical fact on top of that.
Evan Singleton retweeted
Apparently if you believe in economics and scarcity you’re a right wing nut job with a shitty attitude.
Evan Singleton retweeted
Austin, Texas, is an excellent example of how this plays out in practice.
Demand for housing in Austin surged in 2020, and as a result rents soared. Developers responded to the opportunity to make a profit by building tens of thousands of homes.
In fact, Austin added 120,000 homes between 2015 and 2024, increasing its housing stock by 30%.
The resulting increase in supply helped drive rents down by 16% from their late-2021 peak.
Developers weren't out to make housing cheaper but each builder was responding rationally to an chance to make a profit.
But collectively, all that building increased supply and lowered rents.
That's competition. Firms pursue their individual interests and can produce outcomes that benefit consumers, even when those outcomes run against their industry's collective interests.
Evan Singleton retweeted
Billionaires didn't make you worse off by getting rich because the wealth pie isn't zero sum, it's POSITIVE sum. Let's use an example.
Assume tax filings cost $300 so Jane starts a tax app that processes taxes for $50 and it's funded with equity:
1. Jane starts with an idea and 100% of a company worth nothing.
2. Investors pay $1M for 20% of it. They swap $1M of cash for $1M of shares, so their wealth doesn't change. But the deal implies the company is worth $5M, which makes Jane's 80% worth $4M. That $4M is new wealth that didn't exist the day before. She didn't take your wealth or mine. It's new, from thin air.
3. She spends the $1M on engineers and servers. That money becomes their income. It isn't gone. It moved to the people building the product.
4. The app works and the company is valued at $2B as revenue grows and consumers save money on tax filings. The investors' 20% is now worth $400M and Jane's 80% is worth $1.6B.
The result: The investors turned $1M into $400M, the employees got paid, customers save $250 each, and Jane is a billionaire. Everyone involved is better off and nobody lost anything (except Jane's competitors, other millionaires/billionaires). The $2B wasn't taken from anyone. It was created when the business started producing something people value and the market priced those future profits.
Evan Singleton retweeted
The $2,500 colonoscopy cash price is misleading.
Independent US centers advertise bundled cash prices of $975–$1,275.
Florida surgery centers average $1,166 versus $1,650 at hospitals.
We also have substantially more availability of services. MRI scanners per capita: 38 per million in the US versus 11.5 in Belgium and 19 in France.
Yes, US spending is higher…
But direct independent cash prices are competitive or cheaper with much more availability to the care and technology.
It’s why a direct system needs to be part of any solution…
But your ideological viewpoint doesn’t allow for that.
Replying to @JahangirAsgha10
The US medical system is overcharging, that is clear by comparing the "cash prices" in US and in Western Europe (colonoscopy USD 2500 vs 830 Euros in Belgium for foreigners). US is spending (between gov and private insurance) $3.7 trillion. In Belgium, adjusted for population, it is $1 trillion (1/3 on national hospitals, 1/3 national fees, 1/3 private insurance to top off national fees). The US medical system is over charging by 200% for the same quality system. And no, the Belgian medical system is not of worse quality than the US medical system.
Evan Singleton retweeted
The only issue with nuclear fission is that it’s good. And that’s why climate zealots oppose it. It delivers dense, reliable, near-zero-emission power 24/7 with a tiny land footprint. If we cut the bureaucratic red tape to lower costs and standardized reactor designs like China has, it would solve the climate change “issue” overnight. But climate alarmists only want solar and wind, which need endless overbuilding, backup power, and rolling blackouts to keep the electric grid going. Intermittency justifies rationing and state control over how much energy you are allowed to use. If you control energy, you control human behavior. And that's what the climate debate is about. It's not about science. It's not about energy. It's about power, control, and wealth redistribution.
Evan Singleton retweeted
there are two types of environmentalists:
the type that looks at this picture with admiration and the type that looks at this picture with disgust. only the first type is serious about addressing the climate crisis
Replying to @sam_d_1995
French high speed rail, powered by safe and clean nuclear power, might just be the most efficient and sustainable form of transportation known to man.
so of course melenchon opposes both the trains and the electricity
Evan Singleton retweeted
This is true
Using force to take what belongs to one person and transferring it to someone else is indeed the entire point of government
That's b/c you're not smart enough to understand the beauty of price-based allocation. Uber rapidly raising prices (to the market-clearing price, i.e. the price at which everyone who wants to take an Uber at that price can, and every Uber has a customer):
1) Allows people who need the scarce service the most to get it.
2) Incentivizes people to look for substitutes: call a friend to drive you, walk if you can, etc., etc.
3) Incentivizes others to provide that service: people come with private cars, even from distant places, to offer rides for profit, etc. (and, in the process, lower the price).
In contrast, forcing them to sell below the market-clearing price does NOTHING to improve the availability of transportation. It just imposes allocation according to some other function: who has a personal connection with an Uber driver or management (corruption), who's lucky enough to get a ride, etc., etc.
So you end up with a situation where a single mother with two babies has to stay at the airport, while a young man who can walk, call a friend, or has another option that's cheaper than the market-clearing price but more expensive than the "capped price" simply takes the (cheap) Uber that the mother would have gotten at the market price.
Evan Singleton retweeted
The problem with Modern Monetary Theory is how easily it becomes an excuse for politicians to make bad decisions.
MMT argues that a government issuing its own currency can create money to fund spending. Inflation and productive capacity set the limits; taxes help control demand.
That gives liberals seeking larger government programs a convenient justification for expanding spending without matching tax revenue. Politicians in either party can use the same logic while downplaying the constraints.
The weakness is expecting those politicians to recognize inflation risks and impose unpopular tax increases or spending cuts in time. Neither party has earned that trust.
Democrats are back. So is economist Stephanie Kelton’s big idea go.f-st.co/YvzGBgg
Evan Singleton retweeted
One of the important questions regarding Medicare for All is how much of the financing burden will fall on the middle class.
Approximately 28 million of our 163 million employed people already have public coverage or care through Medicaid, Medicare, TRICARE, VA and related programs. Most are lower income and pay low premiums and limited patient charges.
If those workers face a substantial new payroll tax. They will pay substantially more than they currently spend on health care. If their earnings are exempted, more of the financing requirement shifts to the remaining 135 million workers and their employers, including the middle class.
Fully exempting the earnings of those 28 million workers from both portions would increase the combined rate to approximately 24.4%, or 12.2% each.
That is a 13% higher rate, shifting approximately $345 billion annually onto the remaining workers and their employers.
The effect on individual paychecks is substantial:
At $50,000 in wages, the employee’s new annual tax rises from approximately $10,810 to $12,216.
At $100,000 in wages, it rises from approximately $21,622 to $24,450.
Employers would split the amount but it would still have a profound impact on paychecks.
Protecting one group from the new tax increases what others must contribute if the same amount is still being raised through payroll. That includes working families who may themselves be struggling with health care costs.
A financing proposal needs to be clear and transparent, which it currently is not.
The middle class needs to see the bill before it can evaluate the promise of savings.
We’ve been lied to before
Evan Singleton retweeted
Another reason the public is routinely disappointed with our politicians is that our society is economically illiterate. Our politicians promise incoherent and impossible policy agendas for the sake of winning elections, but can't deliver on them because they literally make no sense.
The good news: Democrats are now one presidential win from getting to govern.
The bad news: Their top 3 economic goals may be incompatible with each other.
To prepare a viable governing agenda, the party must grapple with the tensions between its aims
vox.com/politics/510291/demo…
Evan Singleton retweeted
This is completely unsustainable.
I was surprised at how much Medicare/Medicaid/Social Security are now propping up local economies and personal incomes
If you look through the data, Medicare/Medicaid have become the biggest sources of income for particularly non-metropolitan areas. Some stats in the data:
- Government transfers are now 17.6% of all personal income in the US, up from about 8% in 1970. Medicare and Medicaid are 46% of all government transfer dollars!
- 53% of counties get more than 25%+ of their income from government transfers (this covers about 72M people).
- Kentucky seems to be the home of the Colonel and government transfer programs. Twelve of the top fifteen counties receiving government transfers are there. Owsley County gets 63% of personal income from transfers, and Medicaid alone is 32% of all income in the county.
Those government transfers via Medicaid/Medicare get transmuted alchemically into jobs. Phoebe Putney Health System has 6000+ workers and is the largest employer in southwest Georgia. Dougherty County, where it's based, gets 34% of its personal income from government transfers.
In New York we have a program that pays friends and family as caregivers. In 2023 it grew by 57,000 jobs and became 38% of all job growth in the state (they’ve made changes to the program now that have flattened it).
We have become a country of healthcare jobs with a propping of government dollars. Is that fine?
I think this grand bargain worked for a while. We were still seeing economic productivity, government spending hadn’t yet gotten too crazy, etc. But a few things are happening now that suggest the bargain is falling apart.
Evan Singleton retweeted
I'm proposing a new healthcare system called Quality Care for All.
I agree with the goals of Medicare for All. Care should cost less, nobody should go broke because they got sick, and everyone should be able to get quality care when they need it.
However, coverage for all is not the same as quality care for all. A coverage card does not create more doctors, shorten a wait, or make sure a patient can get an appointment. Moving toward a one payer government system does not fix any of this.
People look at American healthcare and conclude the free market failed. What we have right now is not a free market. It is crony capitalism and regulatory capture. The biggest hospital systems, insurers, and middlemen have spent decades shaping rules that protect them. Hospitals buy up physician practices and then add facility fees to the same visit in the same office, a second charge an independent practice can never bill. Prices stay hidden, so nobody can compete on them. Only 35 percent of physicians have an ownership stake in their own practice, down from 53 percent in 2012.
Quality Care for All takes a different route. Insurance built to protect against catastrophe, with far lower premiums because it stops prepaying for routine care. Tax free health savings accounts for every American, with no contribution limits. Prices posted upfront, and cash pay for routine care. A real safety net for people who cannot afford care, spendable at any practice they choose. Site neutral payment, so the facility fee game ends. Insurers held legally accountable when a wrongful denial harms a patient.
Competition has proven what it can do. LASIK is one of the few areas of healthcare where patients pay directly and prices are advertised, and the price has stayed flat in dollars for over 25 years while the technology improved dramatically. Cash pay surgery centers publish their prices online, and common procedures there cost a fraction of the hospital price for the same operation.
Lower costs, more choice, real access to quality care, and a safety net that is there when people need it. Those are the goals. Quality Care for All is how we reach them.







































