Veni, Vedi, Velcro - I came, I saw, I stuck around. Ex-academic historian. Ex-policy advisor/speech writer. Ex-hausted father. Marginalia on history & culture.

🇫🇷 🇬🇧🇦🇪
Joined February 2023
Laughing at the AI made de Gaulle trailer, then immediately missing both de Gaulle and Churchill. When did politics stop producing people who actually looked like they belonged on the biggest stage of history? Those two had already lived real, formative lives - soldiering, writing, adventuring, and getting hardened by events -long before the crisis called. Now we get carefully focus-grouped candidates who can't even deliver a decent speech without a teleprompter and a team of handlers. The bar didn't just drop - it got buried.
That new de Gaulle film looks better than I thought.
1
1
7
842
"Le respect commence par la connaissance." Sure, but what use is knowledge if you aren't free to doubt it?
Le 31 janvier 1964, le général de Gaulle évoquait la Chine comme « un grand peuple » à la civilisation millénaire. 62 ans plus tard, certains feraient bien de relire son discours. Comprendre un peuple, c'est aussi respecter sa mémoire et ses grandes figures historiques. Le respect commence par la connaissance.
2
173
It may be cartoonish, but French people themselves have been trading these exact caricatures for aeons. I can only speak for three within my 'lived experience'. From a French point of view, the Parisian in that meme is the classic national punching bag, and with good reason: centuries of centralisation really did train many of them to treat anything south of the Périphérique as "la province." The râleur-snob combo is for real: always complaining, forever in a rush, and genuinely shocked that a coffee can cost less than nine euros outside the capital. The weekend dash to Normandy is less a stereotype than a lifestyle; half the TGV on Friday night is Parisians fleeing the city they claim is the only place that matters. The Lyonnais version is also pretty accurate, just with better food. They really do treat gastronomy as a civic religion and the Friday-night bouchon pilgrimage is still a thing. The bourgeois image has deep roots, and the automatic hatred of Saint-Étienne is as reliable as supporting OL. Local pride and mild eye-rolling at Parisians who call Lyon "the countryside" are very much alive. Strasbourg is dear to my heart and I love living there. For the Alsatian, the "half German, don’t say it" line is the oldest joke in the region - their dialect really does sound closer to across the Rhine than to Paris. It lands because the cultural layer is real, especially the food: proper choucroute, everyday tarte flambée (don't ever call it German pizza), the heavier baeckeoffe when you want something that simmers all day, and kougelhopf or streusel on every family table. Beer is taken at least as seriously as wine. There's a practical side too that fits the hard-working cliché - strong local consumption of regional products, cross-border commuting to Switzerland or Germany for better wages, and a slightly more reserved, direct style than the rest of France. Still, Alsatians will laugh at the exaggeration, then quietly order another glass of Riesling and note that their markets aren't quite "all year" - just from late November until the tourists finally leave in January. Every region gets roasted for the exact traits it secretly enjoys claiming as its own. The truth is the jokes stick because they contain just enough truth to be funny, and just enough exaggeration that no one has to take them too seriously.
7
2
2
41
3,831
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 retweeted
It's a little crazy that 90% of the most famous left-wing revolutionaries in the world had some kind of coming of age experience in France
Montargis may look like an average rural French town, but it played an important role in the historic development of China’s communist party and in turn, the modern Chinese nation.
29
152
13
1,670
102,015
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 retweeted
Si "le peuple chinois" ne peut pas ou ne veut pas regarder l'histoire de la République populaire en face, ce n'est pas notre problème. (Du côté "occidental", nous n'avons plus guère de leçons à recevoir de ce côté-là.)
Et Napoléon Bonaparte ? C’était un démocrate ? Je vois des gens reprocher à Mbappé d’avoir présenté ses excuses au peuple chinois après avoir qualifié Mao de dictateur. Tellement ils feignent d’ignorer qu’ici le sujet ce n’est pas ce qu’on peut penser ou ce que l’on sait de Mao, mais plutôt ce qu’il continue de représenter pour le peuple chinois. Cela pose aussi la question de la légitimité d’un Européen à distribuer des rôles et à assigner des jugements sur des civilisations dont les peuples entendent conserver un certain rapport avec leurs grandes figures, aussi controversées soient-elles, et avec leur histoire. Car la place d’une figure dans l’histoire ne se réduit pas toujours à son bilan factuel. Le régime mémoriel dépasse la seule question du bilan. Les prétentions occidentales à la supériorité morale sont hallucinantes. Aucune civilisation ne peut revendiquer le monopole de la liberté, de la moralité ou de la démocratie. D’ailleurs, historiquement parlant, les premiers dictateurs reconnus comme tels sont européens (romains), d’abord dans le cadre d’une magistrature exceptionnelle et légale, puis comme dictateurs au sens moderne du mot. On citera Sylla et César, ce dernier étant honoré perpétuellement, d’ailleurs, jusqu’à nous avec le calendrier. Son héritage politique ayant ainsi été banalisé et son personnage incorporé dans une convention collective, celle de notre rapport avec le temps. Je ne m’attarderai pas sur le cas de Napoléon Bonaparte. Mais pourquoi le doigt inquisiteur de la conscience occidentale n’est-il pointé qu’en direction des Mao et autres leaders politiques issus des histoires et des civilisations non occidentales ? C’est là encore l’expression d’un racisme enfoui et d’un sentiment de supériorité mal placé dans le chef de ces braqueurs d’histoire qui monopolisent la morale et qui pensent faire oublier leurs propres laideurs. Assez !
111
295
20
1,834
163,681
The ideal Napoleonic charge - especially the French heavy cavalry's version - was less a wild gallop than a carefully built crescendo. Squadrons started at a walk, moved through the trot and canter, and only went full out in the last stretch so the horses stayed fresh and the ranks stayed locked together ("boot to boot," or charge en muraille "like a wall"). That tight wall of men and mounts was meant to hit with real shock, preferably against an enemy already shaken by guns or infantry. British cavalry of this era often approached the same problem differently. They had fine horses and bold riders, and a single squadron could be formidable. Yet they had a well-known habit of prioritising speed over control - once they charged, they tended to keep going, scatter, and struggle to re-form. Wellington put it bluntly when he said he considered British cavalry inferior to the French from "want of order," adding that while one British squadron might match two French, larger formations generally favoured the French. In small numbers that dash could still win, but in larger masses the French usually held the edge because they kept better cohesion and were more reliable about holding reserves. The basic sequence of the charge was much the same on both sides. What set the French practice apart was simply greater consistency in keeping large bodies under control from start to finish.
Watch this amazing 1975 reenactment of a Napoleonic cavalry charge
7
38
3
793
52,481
Unapologetically French 🇫🇷
Léa Seydoux tries some of the finest French and British delicacies for ELLE UK.
7
239
Mbappé's Michael Jordan moment: "Republicans, buy shoes too."
🚨🇨🇳 MBAPPÉ APOLOGISES TO CHINA AFTER LOSING MAJOR SPONSORS Real Madrid superstar Kylian Mbappé has apologised after comments about a viral meme depicting him as former Chinese leader Mao Zedong sparked outrage across China. “I now understand that it hurt many people in China and in Chinese communities around the world,” Mbappé said, calling his comment “ill-judged” and expressing respect for the Chinese people and their history. 🇨🇳 Chinese companies Dongpeng Beverage, Mengniu and Milkground ended their partnerships with the French football star following the backlash.
1
2
215
A Japanese professor, Noako Sano, teaches Occitan history, culture, and grammar to a couple of dozen students at Aichi Prefectural University. She even put together a Japanese-Occitan dictionary after first encountering the regional language during her student days in Montpellier and later deepening her knowledge in Toulouse. There's something quietly striking about a language that's been clinging on in southern France - mostly among older speakers, with little reliable passage to the next generation - finding serious attention and actual students half a world away. The same quiet attrition has worn down other regional languages in France: Breton, Basque, Corsican, Alsatian. Historical pressure toward a single national tongue did much of the damage; weak day-to-day use and thin institutional backing have kept it going. It reminds me of living in Strasbourg, Alsace, where the practical work of keeping Alsatian alive still falls largely to grandparents, who pass it along to the grandchildren alongside French and German. Family effort becomes the last thin thread holding a once-everyday Germanic dialect.
Elle fait vivre la langue occitane… au Japon ! Naoko Sano enseigne l’histoire, la culture et les bases grammaticales de l’occitan à une vingtaine d’étudiants de la section francophone de l’Université préfectorale d’Aichi, au Japon.
4
14
1,110
There is no known record of actual conversations between Niven and Quayle (or others) on the Guns of Navarone set about their wartime experiences - sorry, @mschriner and @monstroso. A decent overview of the cast and crew's service appears in a YouTube documentary "The Real Commandos Behind the 1961 Guns of Navarone." Alongside Niven and Quayle, it covers James Robertson Justice (Spanish Civil War and RNVR, invalided out after a shrapnel wound), Allan Cuthbertson (RAAF, 1941–47), and director J. Lee Thompson (RAF Bomber Command tail gunner and wireless operator). Both David Niven and Anthony Quayle were characteristically reticent about their wartime service. Niven touched on his Commandos and Phantom Regiment experiences only lightly in his 1971 memoir The Moon's a Balloon. Quayle avoided public discussion altogether; the closest he came for decades was the lightly fictionalised account in his 1945 novel Eight Hours from England. Only in his 1990 memoirs A Time to Speak did he address his service more directly. At one time, while researching inter-war British intelligence, I met a few SOE historians in the seminar room, including M.R.D. Foot, the leading authority on the organisation. He mentioned Quayle's brief SOE posting in Albania. Apparently there's a record and Quayle's personnel file in the National Archives (notably in the HS series). Those files cover the New Year's Eve drop at Tragjas, his work with the partisans, and his evacuation after illness. Another historian of the Balkan theatre, Roderick Bailey in The Wildest Province, treat Quayle as one of the officers sent into Albania in 1943–44, though the episode remains a minor rather than central part of the broader SOE story. There's also a 2021 article by Jonathan Best in Intelligence and National Security ("The tortuousness of our Albanian allies" - vol 36 No.3) that uses Quayle's Eight Hours from England to examine the difficulties SOE faced in Albania - especially the inability to work effectively with competing communist and anti-communist groups more interested in fighting each other than the Axis. It also traces the personal cost of the mission, charting Quayle's shift from optimism to disillusionment and eventual abhorrence of his Albanian allies after repeated setbacks and betrayals. Hope this helps.
anyone happen to overhear cast conversations? Niven - DDay commandos..Quayle - Special Operations Executive-Balkans
6
366
Standing up to those with epistemic privilege. 😏
🚨 Statement on the invitation of Nathan Cofnas🚨
1
4
289
The great Shakespearean actor Sir John Gielgud once summed up Richard Burton's baritone voice in a single, luminous way: "the voice which would sing like a violin and with a bass that could shake the floor." The image is exact. Burton's voice was a richly resonant baritone with a natural Welsh lilt that Burton refined through rigorous training (projecting Shakespeare across valleys as a youth) yet never fully erased. It gave it an authentic, coal-dusted timbre that evoked the valleys of his upbringing. This duality made it electrifying on stage in Shakespearean roles like Hamlet, Henry V, and Coriolanus, where its range conveyed everything from introspective melancholy to commanding fury. On screen, where its measured, weary cadence - often laced with cigarettes, whisky, and world-weariness -added mythic weight to characters in films like The Robe, Becket, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, Where Eagles Dare. In an era of increasingly naturalistic acting, Burton's voice stood out as a throwback to grand theatrical tradition while feeling viscerally modern and personal -making him one of the last true vocal giants of the screen.
6
9
122
12,504
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 retweeted
Theodore Dalrymple on Islam and the riots, the best commentary I have read thereon. What lies ahead for any Western country whose citizens are ignorant of Western history and its civilization. @ufhamilton @UNCSCILL @CivitasInst @UTCivics @osuchasecenter @MadisonProgram @WashingtonWVU lawliberty.org/mere-anarchy/…
10
52
4
194
10,483
For Guns of Navarone, they built the entire interior of the gun emplacement as a large set at Shepperton Studios. The full interior (including the massive guns and working elevator) was constructed in the studio, with the huge cave entrance built outdoors on the Shepperton backlot because it was too large for a soundstage. The Telegraph described the guns set as one of the biggest ever built for a British film at the time - a three-storey structure. The exteriors were filmed on Rhodes, Greece. telegraph.co.uk/films/0/guns…
Anyone know anything about the making of Guns of Navarone? Did they build the entire interior of the gun emplacement?
1
1
5
210
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 retweeted
French universities are the least selective of the OECD... and unsurprisingly has one of the highest fail rate because students aren't good enough Some students complain that they don't know why they were admitted or not. And they're not wrong but that's because for most schools, admission is in parts a lottery. There aren't enough spots for everyone. Rather than select for merit (or for $$$... Universities in France are basically free for nationals and most non-nationals) we select through luck. And then the real selection happens a few years later when the "lucky" students realise they weren't up for it. In the meantime that has a massive cost for public finances So what is logical political conclusion of all this? Blaming parcoursup, the French equivalent of CommonApp or UCAS... Sure the app has some issues, but it's essentially a dating app between schools and students. It's at best the tip of the icerberg. When a wise man points to the moon, the idiot looks at his finger. Politically however it's quite savvy by the govt to lean into the app backlash. Let students rage against the machine, changing the app won't cost as much in € as the big structural changes And it won't cost as much in political capital than announcing we are ending the hypocrisy of a "non-selective" system that punishes the best students and let's weaker students crash.
Replying to @Hexagone_org
🔴 L’absence de sélection à l’entrée conduit logiquement à accueillir des profils dont le niveau ou les attentes ne correspondent pas aux exigences du cadre universitaire. La France affiche ainsi l'un des plus faibles taux de réussite en licence de l'OCDE.
10
77
8
382
21,615
When new French Marine Commandos receive their green berets, the tradition isn't purely French. It was shaped in Scotland in 1942, when Philippe Kieffer's Free French volunteers trained at the British Commando centre at Achnacarry and were folded into the Inter-Allied Commando structure. From that period they took both the green beret itself and the distinctive "à l’anglaise" way of wearing it - tilted to the right, badge over the left eye - a small but deliberate reminder of the British instructors and methods that formed the unit. Léon Gautier, the last of the 177 men of Commando Kieffer who landed on Sword Beach, was a regular presence at these ceremonies in Ouistreham until his death in 2023, sometimes placing the beret himself. Watching the clip, you see the same setting and the same unbroken line: men who completed the hard selection their predecessors endured under British training, now marching through the town that still marks the start of the liberation. The style of the beret and the place itself keep that 1942 origin visible without needing much explanation. For all the centuries of Anglo-French rivalry - the endless mockery, the old jokes about the "sweetest enemy," the habit of needling each other at every opportunity - there has always been a quieter understanding between their soldiers. When the stakes are real, the banter drops away. The men who trained together at Achnacarry, landed side by side on Sword Beach, and still wear the same green beret in the same way know how to recognise genuine courage when they see it, regardless of the flag on the shoulder.
Cérémonie de remise des bérets verts. Le béret vert porté aujourd'hui par les commandos marine est directement hérité des traditions des commandos britanniques auprès desquels furent formés les hommes de Philippe Kieffer durant la Seconde Guerre mondiale. Les commandos marine portent leur béret « à l'anglaise », incliné vers la droite avec l'insigne placé à gauche.
1
114
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 retweeted
Good article on Napoleon’s work ethic - many thanks to Brad Corbin for sending this to me - “Napoleon would dictate letter after letter to his secretaries, often on a variety of subjects, without needing to stop for a moment and think. To show this, during the first three months of 1807, Napoleon sent 1,715 letters, an average of 19 letters per day.” medium.com/@Chaosers/what-ma…
5
22
190
6,723
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 retweeted
It will never fail to surprise that the ancient Etruscan names for their major deity, the counterpart of Roman Jupiter, were…. Crap and Tin.
7
3
69
2,244