Bearfighter (@lost_angeles) header
Bearfighter (@lost_angeles) profile picture
Los Angeles, CA
Joined March 2009
Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)Photo by Bearfighter (@lost_angeles)
Yep.
The owners have staked their argument for the salary cap on competitiveness. They have no choice. Back when Bud Selig's blue panel commission was recommending contracting teams that are now worth billions, the owners might have been able to convince the players and the public that the financial health of the game was at stake. But no one will believe that now. I and many others have offered solid rebuttals to the competitive balance argument, but let's grant the owners the following: 1) Big payroll disparities are bad. 2) Teams spending 50% of net revenue on payroll is fair to the players. Also, let's put aside nominal payroll figures and focus on payroll percentage (i.e., how much a team spends relative to the entire league). In 2025, under the current system, payroll percentage ranged from the Dodgers at 6.5% to the Marlins at 1.3%. That's a wide gap, but, those figures don't tell us what teams CAN spend currently...only what they are willing to. To address this disparity, the owners have proposed a cap/floor tied to modified revenue sharing, but what if every team simply spent 50% of net revenue (which would still leave some teams below the $174 million floor)? That shouldn't be any more of a burden than forcing teams to a salary floor. In 2025, only nine teams met this threshold, so if you simply had the 21 other teams spend to the 50% level, you'd reduce the gap to the Dodgers at 5.5% and the White Sox at 1.9%. It's amusing that LA and Chicago, two of the three biggest markets, are at both extremes, but putting that aside, without fundamentally changing the game, you have significantly narrowed the gap. But is it narrow enough? In the charts at the bottom of this post are every single team season since 2003 (advent of the current CBT) plotted by payroll% (red dots are WS winners and yellow are WS losers). The first displays every season. The second narrows the focus between the indicated bands of the adjusted range. The result? By getting underinvesting teams to spend more, you effectively eliminate the extreme outcomes, both good and bad. It's worth noting that if 21 teams collectively spent another $1 billion on payroll, it would likely either divert talent away from the bigger markets or drive up their costs on certain players. Either way, this trickle down effect would likely tighten the band even more. If the smaller market teams were already spending significant sums (i.e., the Pirates weren't one of the most profitable teams), the owners' salary cap idea might be sympathetic. If the financial health of the league was at stake, there'd be merit. If high payroll teams were always winning, there might be justification. But, the truth is, to the extent there is a competitive balance issue created by payroll disparity, much of it could easily be mitigated by smaller market teams investing reasonably in payroll. Or, put more bluntly, the @MLBPA's response to the salary cap should simply be "don't ask us to solve a problem that either doesn't exist or you haven't taken reasonable efforts to solve on your own".
388
Hard to explain how much a cap/floor kills cheap teams. I know no one wants to hear it. If you’re a homegrown star and don’t want the Acuña/Witt Jr. team friendly deal—you’re out. A floor becomes a cheap owner’s cap. You aren’t signing for a team where you’re 1/4 the payroll.
Paul Skenes salary will be out of the Pirates comfort zone after next season and he will likely be playing somewhere else in 2028, per @JPerrotto (pittsburghbaseballnow.com/pi…)
1
328
Great ballgame. Nice one, Brew Crew.
296
Blowing the bubble, little bat flip, walking backwards, disappointment, helmet slam is a forever gif.
1
2
13
606
Muncy hit it hard enough to jog out of the box. Albies hit it hard enough to cost his team a triple. Next.
Max Muncy's 19th postseason homer of his career, lmfao.
8
460
Love the Padres approach first inning
293
I was told it meant more down there. Who cares what the weather is.
The start of LSU-Clemson will be delayed due to lightning in the area (Via @chapelfowler)
1
6
994
Hmmm.
So many heat casualties at this Texas State vs Texas game. I haven't seen anything like this in a long time. Already seen paramedics bring 4 stretches in and it's still Q1. People are huddled in the stadium like it's a hurricane shelter. 2:30pm kickoff is a certified disaster. 🥵
8
831
This is wild.
Breaking: The SEC sued LSU in U.S. District Court in Alabama on Thursday, alleging the university is violating the league's First Amendment right of expressive association by ignoring SEC rules that prohibit signing and playing former NFL players.
1
480
Not having something better to do than attend week zero football in an excessive heat warning isn’t the flex these other fanbases think it is.
58
23
4
167
7,183
Ridiculously beatable.
Any team truly interested in Skubal could have beaten that package, so save the takes about the Dodgers ruining baseball.
8
1,475
It is wild because the Dodgers gave up talent, but not the talent we didn’t want to. Ryan is great but redundant. Hope not ahead of De Paula, Pages, Sirota. Emil Morales stays. No Sheehan or Wrobo is Highway robbery. What are the brewers doing? This was beatable.
4
18
1,675
Machado like the only player the dodgers haven’t offered 9 figures to.
418
As an American and Arsenal fan, the headloss over *checks notes* Flo Balogun is wild.
425
Rushing’s OPS would lead the Padres ☠️
309
Bro, the Jays can’t field.
1
285
Dodgers full Real Madrid. Doesn’t matter the contract details. You just go.
BREAKING: Star outfielder Kyle Tucker and the Los Angeles Dodgers are in agreement on a free agent contract, sources tell ESPN.
3
608
Tweets that precede unfortunate events.
Who is gifting these set piece merchants all these set pieces? Just let them keep the ball they‘re useless when it comes to open play
1
702
If you are a Dodger casual and a Laker hardcore (a reverse me), this is really, really good.
How do the Lakers start operating more like the Dodgers? They bring in Dodgers executives Farhan Zaidi and Andrew Friedman to start consulting on the Dodgers way. Zaidi is serving as new owner Mark Walter’s representative from TWG Sports in the transition process, sources told ESPN. espn.com/nba/story/_/id/4704…
2
4
1,054