J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass) header
J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass) profile picture

Social Studies teacher and Department Chair in N.J.; Ed.D. Rutgers University (Education, Culture and Society). Always curious.

New Jersey
Joined May 2012
Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)Photo by J. Negraval, Ed.D. (@negsclass)
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
John Taylor Gatto was named New York State Teacher of the Year. Upon receiving the award, he quit and spent the rest of his life writing devastating critiques of the educational system he had mastered. Gatto argued that regardless of the official curriculum, schools actually teach seven hidden lessons. The first is confusion. Students learn disconnected facts across dozens of subjects with no integration or meaning. The second is class position. Students learn their place in the social hierarchy. The third is indifference. Students learn that nothing is worth finishing because the bell always rings. The fourth is emotional dependency. Students learn to surrender their will to a chain of command. The fifth is intellectual dependency. Students learn to wait for experts to tell them what to think. The sixth is provisional self-esteem. Students learn that their worth depends on expert evaluation. The seventh is that they are always being watched and have no privacy. These lessons, Gatto argued, are the actual function of schooling. The explicit curriculum of reading, writing, and arithmetic is almost incidental. The real purpose is to produce passive, dependent, compliant citizens who wait for authorities to tell them what to do and think. Trad schooling amounts to thirteen years of training in being passive and dependent. I have seen this play out with hundreds of students. When I created Montessori middle schools in the San Francisco Bay Area, about half the students came up through Montessori elementary and about half came from public schools. When we opened, the Montessori kids immediately began doing their work, taking initiative, choosing what to tackle first. The public school students were lost. They would stare at their desks until we walked over and helped them plan their morning. It took at least a semester, sometimes a full year, before they could function in an environment that asked them to direct their own learning. These were not less intelligent children. They had simply been trained differently. For years, someone else had made all the decisions about what they would do, when they would do it, and how they would do it. When that structure was removed, they did not know how to operate. Agency is natural to children unless we train it out of them. When I coach parents on evaluating their children's education, I tell them to ignore grades entirely. The question is whether their children are taking initiative, being responsible, and becoming empowered moral beings. If a child is getting straight A's but has no initiative and no sense of personal responsibility, that child is being damaged by their education regardless of how it looks on paper.
122
1,204
107
4,344
157,621
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
The CEO of Palantir just said the quiet part out loud. Alex Karp — whose company builds surveillance and defense technology for the U.S. government — just openly stated that AI will deliberately shift economic power away from highly educated, often female, Democratic-leaning workers and toward vocationally trained, working-class, often male voters. He then admitted these technologies are — his word — “dangerous” and “suicidal,” and that the only justification for deploying them is the military argument: if we don’t, our adversaries will. So let’s be clear about what was just said on the record: A defense contractor CEO told you AI is being built to restructure the American class system, that it will destroy the economic power of an entire political demographic, and that the only way to sell it to the public is to wrap it in national security.
702
7,647
637
15,593
1,857,626
Don't question the system.
124
1,457
61
4,344
174,857
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
We are in an era of “pedagogical clutter.” There’s a surplus of methods, practices, and acronyms to learn—and administrations are in a hurry to implement them.  Teachers are constantly cramming new info, and retaining little.  Let’s slow down, simplify, and focus.
9
8
1
83
1,868
We’ve known this for decades yet there is an overwhelming refusal to put more recess or physical fitness into the school day.
🇫🇮 New Finish study: More physical activity during school day associated with higher self-esteem for boys, lower reports of depression in girls, and positive prosocial skills for all. ▶️Cites research that school-based preventive programmes in general have only small beneficial effects on mental health ▶️But more physical activity easy to integrate into school day, with minimal effort by teachers
23
111
3
494
36,365
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
These School Leaders Don’t Want a Statewide Cellphone Ban. Here's Why edweek.org/technology/these-…
1
3
1,696
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
Dr. Erica Komisar just said what many parents whisper but few say out loud: Modern schools are built for girls, not boys—and we’re paying a steep price. Little boys (ages 3–6) surge with testosterone. They need to run, jump, play, burn energy. Instead, we sit them in circle time, demand emotional regulation, and label normal boy behavior as ADHD or “behavioral problems.” Result? Marginalized, stressed, diagnosed early, and tracked that way through school. Her fix if she ran the world: Separate boys and girls in the early years. Boys get multiple recess periods, short focused bursts, and space to move. Girls get a calmer environment where they feel safe taking STEM/math risks. Both thrive when not forced into the opposite gender’s learning style. Single-gender early education: Boys try art/music without teasing. Girls try science without self-consciousness. Evidence already shows it works. Parents/teachers: Do you see boys struggling more in today’s classrooms—or is this overblown? What’s one change you’d make to education for boys right now?
1,170
4,799
1,018
22,699
4,034,947
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
I hated school history. I think school history textbooks are the most boring, meaningless artifacts of education ever created. They're designed by committees to offend no one and inspire no one. They're written at grade level, which means they're dumbed down. They're comprehensive, which means they're shallow on everything. I'm a voracious reader of history now. I read history for fun. The subject itself is endlessly fascinating. School history is garbage. Real history is wonderful. The institution takes something inherently interesting and makes it unbearable. That's almost an achievement.
45
22
5
244
6,546
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
"Most assignments in college are not relevant. They're hackable by AI, and I just had no interest in doing them." Nah, I'd say higher ed and most existing institutions and processes are what's cooked.
The kids are cooked
69
28
45
566
816,399
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
In response to the linked article. 1: The rampant use of ChatGPT is due in part to a society-wide failure to value education for its own sake. By treating a pure means to an end - wealth - as a final end, we have ethically crippled a generation. nymag.com/intelligencer/arti…
32
789
83
5,813
225,146
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
Your 9-to-5 job is dying. By 2034, it'll be extinct. That's Reid Hoffman's latest prediction – the founder of LinkedIn who predicted the rise of social media in 1997. Here's what he said next:
1,218
9,706
1,216
59,164
18,854,093
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
Nothing a child can ever learn is more important than their love of learning itself.
11
23
2
187
7,083
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
Colleges are closing at a rate of 1/week, nationally, due to lack of enrollment. Kids are choosing not to go for many reasons: inflating costs, diminishing value, the rise of other paths. By the time your kids graduate, their college path will very likely *not* be a given.
23
26
14
239
15,455
The internet changed *everything* about education. And our systems (and our society) are not even close to catching up.
12
12
7
128
21,953
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
Parental satisfaction with their kids’ school took a dip during 2020-2021 but has rebounded — national perceptions kept trending downward.
9
16
8
73
122,671
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
82% of U.S. public K-12 teachers say their school or district has policies regarding classroom cellphone use. Of those, 56% say these policies are at least somewhat easy to enforce, 30% say they’re difficult, and 14% say they’re neither easy nor difficult. pewrsr.ch/49o9UC4
1
6
1
13
8,174
J. Negraval, Ed.D. retweeted
I have #GoogleGemini in my #GoogleDocs As soon as I open up the student document it shows me a summary in the sidebar. I ask it to make a rubric based on my criteria and assess the student. 🧠 THIS IS A GAME CHANGER!!!! #GoogleEDU
5
34
3
169
30,759