This should re-assure Zimi users that the batch of filter media suspected of being subpar is still standards compliant and protective.
But the issue wasn't a phantom. It is real. There was an actual, if small, reduction in filtration from the usual performance of that filter media.
"these batches demonstrated filtration efficiencies of 97.44%, 98.31%, 98.55%, and 98.08%, respectively....these results show a slight decrease; nevertheless, they remain fully compliant with the KN95 standard."
Thanks to
@zhouliang_mask for following up on this even though he left Zimi many months ago to start Ziga mask. And thanks to the community fit testers who noticed the deviation in PortaCount results and wanted to make sure Zimi's were still providing the protection people count on them for.
It's interesting and useful that PortaCount fit testing was sensitive enough to detect the slight decrease in filtration efficiency, but also a reminder that PortaCount testing in N99 mode won't necessarily give an OSHA passing fit factor of 100 even for NIOSH compliant N95s or GB2626-2019 compliant KN95 masks.
N95s and KN95s are allowed to have up to 5% filter penetration at 85 liters per minute of airflow. Even with a perfect face seal, 5% filter penetration would show as a "failing" fit test score in N99 mode. N99 mode can't tell the difference between allowed filter penetration and a face seal leak.
In practice, you shouldn't get full 5% filter penetration in an N99 mode fit test of an N95 fit test since, A) most N95 filter media has less than 5% filter penetration and B) you don't breathe at 85 liters per minute of airflow.
But even 1.5% filter penetration would be a failing fit test in N99 mode since only a 1% face seal leak or less is allwed. This is why N95 mode was developed for fit testing of N95s, to detect just face seal leakage. And why the Zimis could test lower than usual in N99 mode PortaCount testing, but still be compliant with the KN95 filtration standard.
Community fit testers generally use N99 mode on N95s for two reasons:
• Affordable surplus PortaCounts only have N99 mode, so we use what is available and keep the limitations of N99 mode in mind when evaluating fit test scores for series 95 masks.
•Because we want to test overall protection - how many particles get into a mask - not just meet minimum OSHA face seal leak requrements.
Some people would like fewer particles in their masks, fewer than allowed under the N95 standard, irrespective of how they get into the mask. N99 mode fit testing allows us to rate respiratory protection on a continuum from least protective to most protective.
N95 mode is a great tool for N95/KN95 fit testing and community fit testers do use it when appropriate and they have the equipment available to do it.
In the US, workplace fit testers pretty much always use N95 mode for N95s because their job is to test for face seal leaks, and only face seal leaks. OSHA requires all masks to be NIOSH approved, which thus are assumed to filter well. And N95 mode is designed to test just for face seal leaks and not filter penetration.