
@oferneiman.bsky.social Israeli citizen, #AbolishIsrael #EqualRights #BDS. #CovidIsntOver. #WFPB. And...blocked by Steven Pinker
- Tweets137K
- Following6.7K
- Followers4.1K
- Likes117K

ALT There are two red flashing lights to look for in the Myanmar judgment, says Michael Sfard, one of Israel's leading experts in human rights and the laws of war, who notes the "enormous bearing" of this week's judgment on the Gaza genocide case. The first is whether it broadens the legal doctrine on proving genocidal intent. The Genocide Convention requires "intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such," making it far harder to prove than, for instance, airstrikes on an enemy target that result in a disproportionate, or excessive, loss of civilian life, part of the "collateral damage" debate surrounding the NAZA documentary. Until now, the previous case law on genocide from the ICJ and the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia set a very high bar regarding intent.

ALT There doesn't need to be an order, or written program, commanding genocide in so many words; the court needs to infer the intent from concrete actions taken by the Israeli government and the IDF. But the court can judge genocidal intent from deeds "if this is the only reasonable inference" from those actions, says Sfard; if there is another reasonable explanation, then genocidal intent has not been proven. For instance, when Israel blocked humanitarian aid to Gaza for 11 weeks in spring 2025, following the breakdown of the Israel-Hamas ceasefire, one reasonable inference could be the intent to "destroy, in whole or in part" the Palestinians in Gaza. But another could be Israel's contention that it was aimed at pressuring Hamas to release the 59 hostages it still held at the time, and to force Hamas to lay down its arms and surrender.

ALT The presence of two competing explanations would nix the Convention's requirement for genocidal intent. As Sfard himself notes in his recent book, "Occupation from Within: How Israel's Oppression of Palestinians Turned Inwards:" "This is an extremely difficult bar to meet, especially because human beings, and certainly states, almost always act out of a plurality of purposes." This is where the Myanmar case is so significant: The Gambia is "asking the court to deviate from this" requirement, says Sfard, by "arguing that genocidal intent must be the most reasonable, and not the sole, interpretation of intent." The Myanmar judgment may in effect create a new pathway to prove genocide.

































