Paul Yowell retweeted
One of my favourite passages in contemporary legal philosophy - John Finnis on the radically practical question 'What should I decide?'
On John Henry Newman's feast day recall his account of a university: where "the intellect may safely range and speculate, sure to find its equal in some antagonist activity, and its judge in the tribunal of truth. It is a place where inquiry is pushed forward, and discoveries verified and perfected, and rashness rendered innocuous, and error exposed, by the collision of mind with mind, and knowledge with knowledge." Newman, Historical Sketches.
Paul Yowell retweeted
It still feels unreal. Almost two years since Kim Leadbeater first announced she was going to bring forward her assisted suicide bill, almost two years since we started organising the lawyers' letter to the Observer where serious concerns over the bill were first expressed, and it's finally been defeated.
Doubtless supporters will try again, but the appetite is clearly not there in Parliament, the Senedd, the Scottish Parliament and across the country as a whole for such reckless social change.
Yesterday was a real victory for society's most vulnerable. This bill, under the pretence of alleviating suffering, would have endangered those most at risk of coercion, social pressure and their own dark thoughts because of their race, sex, social standing, disability or mental ill health.
Canada, Oregon, and other jurisdictions show the ineluctable propensity of assisted suicide laws to expand further. I'm certain that the Terminally Ill Adults Bill would have snowballed into a capacious assisted suicide and euthanasia regime in this country as well. It was right for the Commons to think again, to heed the House of Lords' concerns, and to decide not to cross that moral Rubicon.
I'm glad to wake up this morning in a country where the spectre of a state that assists terminally ill people to end their own lives has been banished. But now it's time for us all to commit to the state truly assisting terminally ill people to die with dignity and peace. Excellent, universal palliative care is sorely needed in this country. If advocates of yesterday's reckless bill were to put even half the same effort into campaigning for true dignity in dying, the political pressure to improve palliative care would be unstoppable. It's time for us all to commit to that project.
Brilliant article on what happened after the assisted suicide bill was initially approved by the House of Commons, and some enduring strengths of the British constitution.
The British constitution, a bit like life, sometimes gives you a second chance.
First thoughts on today’s momentous vote in @firstthingsmag: firstthings.com/how-britain-…
Paul Yowell retweeted
Many words, many speeches. But this deeply moving, impassioned, plea to @HouseofCommons from Lancashire MP @AshleyDalton_MP - who has stage 4 incurable breast cancer - was simply outstanding: ‘My days may be numbered, but that doesn't mean that I want this chamber to rush through bad law just so I might have a chance to see it or use it’. Mercifully, @UKParliament heeded her courageous warning not to ‘rush through bad law’. Instead, Government must swiftly respond to calls from both Houses, and the Scottish Parliament, for urgent focus on life enhancing palliative care and comprehensive hospice provision. @andyburnham @YvetteCooperMP @CommonsSpeaker @UKHouseofLords @scotgov
@GordonBrown @ShabanaMahmood @wesstreeting
Watch in full:
By a decisive margin @HouseofCommons has rejected the assisted suicide Bill. Thanks to all those who had the courage of their convictions. Now both Houses of @UKParliament @UKHouseofLords should unite with the devolved administrations and insist on world class palliative care and hospices. To die with dignity we don’t need doctors to kill us. @andyburnham @KemiBadenoch @EdwardJDavey @Nigel_Farage @danny__kruger @timfarron @NazShahBfd @AshleyDalton_MP @ShabanaMahmood @wesstreeting @KanishkaNarayan @MarieRimmer @frankcottrell_b @Rachel_deSouza @RachaelMaskell
Paul Yowell retweeted
Parliament's rejection of the Assisted Dying Bill today brings much relief.
Scenes of disabled people protesting against the Bill outside Parliament were truly heartbreaking. The Bill raised deeply troubling questions about coercion and whether its safeguards could truly protect the most vulnerable amongst us. Had it passed, something very precious in the fabric of our society would have been changed irreversibly, leaving vulnerable people exposed to pressures they should never have to face.
Today, that line was not crossed.
Our response to suffering must be compassion, care and empathy, investment in people, proper resources and a palliative care system that ensures nobody is left without dignity, comfort or hope at the end of life.
We as a society must do more, much more, to help people to live with dignity, to care for them in the best and most humane way possible, and never make them feel that death is the answer to their suffering.
I feel a profound sense of honour to have played my part in today’s vote, helping to ensure that this Bill did not become law and that the most vulnerable among us remain protected from the possibility of coercion and undue pressure.
Paul Yowell retweeted
If there was one speech which swung it, it was this from @AshleyDalton_MP, who has stage 4 cancer and spoke so powerfully about how the bill failed the people it purported to serve:
Paul Yowell retweeted
A huge moment and not just for Britain.
No parliament has debated assisted suicide so thoroughly, forensically and passionately. The result has been a collapse in support as people woke up to the dangers.
Paul Yowell retweeted
I honestly don't see how any responsible MP could look at the following and think "but let's vote this bill through anyway and let's do it in a way that cuts off any Lords scrutiny via the Parliament Acts". It will be a travesty if the Commons passes this bill today.
Paul Yowell retweeted
Basically the Edwards plan to use the Parliament Acts removes the normal parliamentary safeguards.
This is why assisted dying supporters like Louise Haigh have said they don’t support the Parliament Acts plan.
Paul Yowell retweeted
To all MPs whether for, against, unsure or abstaining on the assisted suicide vote on Friday in the Commons, please watch Better Off Dead? @BBCOne @OpenUniversity It’s my documentary explaining why no disability rights organisation supports this unsafe law bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0…
Paul Yowell retweeted
It’s interesting that both times the Commons has voted, the promise has been “Don’t worry, the precise text in front of you won’t become law.”
Replying to @philipmurraylaw
So while Edwards continue to present Friday's vote as an opportunity to allow the Lords simply to finish the job, the reality is quite different. A Commons vote for the Bill is a vote that it becomes law, even in a form that supporters appear to accept as far from perfect.
Important point by Philip Murray on the assisted suicide bill; read the whole thread.
Replying to @philipmurraylaw
So while Edwards continue to present Friday's vote as an opportunity to allow the Lords simply to finish the job, the reality is quite different. A Commons vote for the Bill is a vote that it becomes law, even in a form that supporters appear to accept as far from perfect.
154
Brilliant thread
1. Cicely Saunders was perhaps the greatest Briton of the post-war era: the founder of an extraordinary new kind of institution, which has rapidly spread around the world.
But today, her legacy is under threat. And in 10 days MPs will be voting on whether to endanger it further.
6
213
From the Freedom of Speech (Higher Education) Act 2023: “The governing body of a registered higher education provider must take the steps that, having particular regard to the importance of freedom of speech, are reasonably practicable [for] securing freedom of speech within the law …”
Paul Yowell retweeted
The Spanish state failed this rape victim. So it will help her to kill herself instead. There are no depths to this horror. news.sky.com/story/gang-rape…


























