Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti) header
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti) profile picture

Professor of philosophy, author, philosophical counselor, meditation & yoga instructor, martial artist, anti-bullying advocate,😈😇 ☯️ Objectivist

NYC metro area
Joined April 2009
Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)Photo by Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer (@rickrepetti)
Congratulations to my friend and colleague on what I very much look forward to reading!
What is the human being? Not a closed system, but a received mystery. TI’m grateful to share Human, All Too Human, where philosophical anthropology is rethought through the Marian form of creaturely receptivity. 🍺
1
55
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
The cover for my forthcoming work. It should be out by May. 🍺
9
10
1
103
3,966
From a colleague: Have you started practising meditation 4 months ago or less, plan to continue meditating regularly & live in New Zealand, Australia, UK or US? If yes: melbourneuni2.au1.qualtrics.… US$140 or equivalent in gift cards, + More info: psychologicalsciences.unimel…
1
201
This article, chronicle.com/.../can-educat…..., explains how Perplexity tells students it'll do all their exams, so I tested it. Here’s the me/AI thread: [perplexity.ai/.../i-need-you…...]
1
30
I invite others to share their strategies for dealing with AI cheating, in my Facebook group, Philosophy Professors Go Virtual, facebook.com/groups/66240599….
25
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Major preprint just out! We compare how humans and LLMs form judgments across seven epistemological stages. We highlight seven fault lines, points at which humans and LLMs fundamentally diverge: The Grounding fault: Humans anchor judgment in perceptual, embodied, and social experience, whereas LLMs begin from text alone, reconstructing meaning indirectly from symbols. The Parsing fault: Humans parse situations through integrated perceptual and conceptual processes; LLMs perform mechanical tokenization that yields a structurally convenient but semantically thin representation. The Experience fault: Humans rely on episodic memory, intuitive physics and psychology, and learned concepts; LLMs rely solely on statistical associations encoded in embeddings. The Motivation fault: Human judgment is guided by emotions, goals, values, and evolutionarily shaped motivations; LLMs have no intrinsic preferences, aims, or affective significance. The Causality fault: Humans reason using causal models, counterfactuals, and principled evaluation; LLMs integrate textual context without constructing causal explanations, depending instead on surface correlations. The Metacognitive fault: Humans monitor uncertainty, detect errors, and can suspend judgment; LLMs lack metacognition and must always produce an output, making hallucinations structurally unavoidable. The Value fault: Human judgments reflect identity, morality, and real-world stakes; LLM "judgments" are probabilistic next-token predictions without intrinsic valuation or accountability. Despite these fault lines, humans systematically over-believe LLM outputs, because fluent and confident language produce a credibility bias. We argue that this creates a structural condition, Epistemia: linguistic plausibility substitutes for epistemic evaluation, producing the feeling of knowing without actually knowing. To address Epistemia, we propose three complementary strategies: epistemic evaluation, epistemic governance, and epistemic literacy. Full paper in the first reply. Joint with @Walter4C & @matjazperc
219
1,255
165
4,460
665,933
Escape the agency-capturing, attention-hijacking vortex.
I used to think the main damage from social media was to youth mental health. Now I believe that the global destruction of the human ability to pay attention may be even larger. A meta-analysis shows the damage, to adults as well as teens, from TikTok+ psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/202…
62
Zohran Mamdani, first socialist mayor of NYC, first Muslim mayor of NYC.
113