Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
The cover for my forthcoming work. It should be out by May. 🍺
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Major preprint just out!
We compare how humans and LLMs form judgments across seven epistemological stages.
We highlight seven fault lines, points at which humans and LLMs fundamentally diverge:
The Grounding fault: Humans anchor judgment in perceptual, embodied, and social experience, whereas LLMs begin from text alone, reconstructing meaning indirectly from symbols.
The Parsing fault: Humans parse situations through integrated perceptual and conceptual processes; LLMs perform mechanical tokenization that yields a structurally convenient but semantically thin representation.
The Experience fault: Humans rely on episodic memory, intuitive physics and psychology, and learned concepts; LLMs rely solely on statistical associations encoded in embeddings.
The Motivation fault: Human judgment is guided by emotions, goals, values, and evolutionarily shaped motivations; LLMs have no intrinsic preferences, aims, or affective significance.
The Causality fault: Humans reason using causal models, counterfactuals, and principled evaluation; LLMs integrate textual context without constructing causal explanations, depending instead on surface correlations.
The Metacognitive fault: Humans monitor uncertainty, detect errors, and can suspend judgment; LLMs lack metacognition and must always produce an output, making hallucinations structurally unavoidable.
The Value fault: Human judgments reflect identity, morality, and real-world stakes; LLM "judgments" are probabilistic next-token predictions without intrinsic valuation or accountability.
Despite these fault lines, humans systematically over-believe LLM outputs, because fluent and confident language produce a credibility bias.
We argue that this creates a structural condition, Epistemia:
linguistic plausibility substitutes for epistemic evaluation, producing the feeling of knowing without actually knowing.
To address Epistemia, we propose three complementary strategies: epistemic evaluation, epistemic governance, and epistemic literacy.
Full paper in the first reply.
Joint with @Walter4C & @matjazperc
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Whenever you're solving a problem—you have to solve these two meta problems in order to be adaptive:
• Anticipation: You need to anticipate the world. The farther out you can anticipate the world the more intelligence people will attribute to you. It's way better to avoid the tiger than to fight it
• Relevance Realization: There's way too much information to pay attention to—and you're intelligent by ignoring most of the information (and zero in on the relevant information)
But it’s not a cold calculation—you care about this information rather than that information
Machines don't care about the information they're processing—you do
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Atlas is demonstrating reinforcement learning policies developed using a motion capture suit. This demonstration was developed in partnership with Boston Dynamics and @rai_inst.
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
New study from the Rutgers Social Perception Lab found that DEI programs with an "anti-oppressive frame" (such as those espoused by Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DiAngelo) increase a "hostile attribution bias" and perceived discrimination that doesn't exist: networkcontagion.us/wp-conte…
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
It’s a silent epidemic affecting nearly everyone:
The Meaning Crisis
We are drowning in bullshit—literally “meaninglessness”
We feel disconnected from ourselves (each other) and a viable future
Alienation without (anxiety within)
So how can you reclaim meaning in your life?
We're addicted to our phones.
We're disconnected from nature.
Jobs are at the threat of replacement.
Schools and religious ideologies are losing trust.
We're going through a meaning crisis.
Here's how you navigate it:
youtu.be/uy9_bfhfFvQ
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Political season has brought out the worst in many people.
Extreme division in itself is a bigger danger to our nation than either candidate.
Don't believe anyone who's telling you to hate the other side.
We're in this together 👊
Tomorrow, go vote.
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
What’s worse?
A warm up comic making a single bad joke 7 hours before Trump went on stage at MSG, or a former president peddling the endlessly debunked Very Fine People hoax two days before the election?
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
The counter to misinformation is not censorship, but better information
🚨ELON MUSK ON COMMUNITY NOTES:
"Community Notes is awesome. Everybody gets checked. Including me. All the community notes software is open source, and all the data. So you can recreate any given note independently. It's total absolute transparency in every way. The counter to misinformation is better information."
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Here's my conversation with Vejas Liulevicius on the history of Communism and the atrocities it led to in the 20th century.
He is a historian specializing in Germany & Eastern Europe, so we also discuss WW2, including a response to Darryl Cooper's statements on Hitler & Churchill made on the Tucker Carlson podcast and elsewhere.
It's here on X in full, and is up everywhere else. Links in comment.
Timestamps:
0:00 - Introduction
3:10 - Marxism
30:55 - Anarchism
45:52 - The Communist Manifesto
54:51 - Communism in the Soviet Union
1:14:45 - Lenin, Trotsky, and Stalin
1:24:33 - Stalin
1:31:48 - Holodomor
1:45:38 - The Great Terror
1:58:39 - Totalitarianism
2:09:40 - Response to Darryl Cooper
2:24:49 - Nazis vs Communists in Germany
2:31:11 - Mao
2:36:19 - Great Leap Forward
2:43:20 - China after Mao
2:48:52 - North Korea
2:52:56 - Communism in US
3:00:26 - Russia after Soviet Union
3:11:57 - Advice for Lex
3:19:39 - Book recommendations
3:22:38 - Advice for young people
3:29:29 - Hope
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
I had the opportunity yesterday to talk to CNN’s viewers about how the debates have become part of the political theater that the Harris campaign and Propaganda Media would love us to focus on rather than the disaster that awaits the American people if we elect Kamala Harris.
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Courage is contagious. This is our moment. We are the ones we’ve been waiting for.
Check out the video and spread the word!
#RescueTheRepublic
It's our time.
We must unite. It's time to RESCUE THE REPUBLIC.
Join us in Washington D.C on 9/29/24
#RescueTheRepublic #JoinTheResistance #Unite
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Yes there is, Tim. It is called the U.S. Constitution. That is exactly what prevents the government from stifling dissent by labeling something “hate speech” or “misinformation.”
Yes, I understand, some forms of speech are repugnant, such as expressions of racial bigotry. Problem is, the category of hate speech expands to include everything the censors “hate.” As for misinformation, who decides what is true and what is false? The government? In authoritarian countries, yes, the government. That is why freedom of speech lies at the very heart of democracy.
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
The good news is, Kamala Harris wants to add more taxes into our life. We already have this:
Your income comes from your employer, who already pays a tax just to pay you. Then, you pay a tax on that money that was already taxed. Next, you use your taxed cash to buy things that are also taxed. And then once a year, you pay the government more money. That is on top of paying taxes just to live in the home you paid for and in addition to inflation, which is also technically a tax.
Rick Repetti, Fallacy Patrol Officer retweeted
Here is the most dramatic real-world test of The Anxious Generation yet done by any journalist. @DeccaJourno of @thetimes is the only journalist who got both halves of the book. She arranged for UK teens to give up their smartphones, as many others have done. But she did it for a month (not a week), and she did it with a GROUP of friends (not just a few random individuals), AND she added on a phone-free and adult-free camping trip. (I don't know how she got that past the lawyers; it could not have been done in the USA.)
The result was a joyous demonstration of what happens when a GROUP of friends opts out of the phone-based childhood, together, and what happens when adults give them the chance to do something adventurous, on their own. I just heard Decca's son (one of the participants) say, on a radio show, that the camping trip gave him "one of the best nights of my year, maybe of my life."
The essay offers complete vindication for @FreeRangeKids and @LetGrowOrg. It shows parents how they can restore a real-world childhood, IF they do it together, with a few other families. It offers a vivid illustration of our mission, at
anxiousgeneration.com/
to reclaim childhood in the real world. Join us.
Here's a link to the article. Thanks to @thetimes for making the essay available without a paywall, at least for those in the USA (I think).
thetimes.com/life-style/pare…




























