Vall retweeted
Question: How should Americans who support Ukraine respond to reports of corruption in Ukraine, including allegations involving President Zelenskyy’s inner circle?
Kateryna Lisunova, Ukrainian journalist:
“russians are doing a lot of propaganda. They have a lot of money for propaganda. They are trained from USSR times on how to spread propaganda. That is why a lot of things are related to narratives, not to the actual facts.
And right now, we’re hearing the American president saying that supposedly America gave Ukraine $300 billion, which is not true. The numbers from $70 to $90 billion.
And most of it stayed in U.S., because it went to finance American military companies. So what Ukraine got was old weaponry from the United States. And most of the money went to the United States to replenish that, to build better weaponry and to build more missiles, et cetera.
So it actually went mostly to the United States to renew everything the United States had, and Ukraine got all the oldest versions of weaponry.
And when the American president keeps repeating that ‘Ukraine is so corrupt’, it’s becoming not a conversation about the facts, but a narrative. And we’re fighting against a narrative right now.
Ukrainians always want to raise these things (the issue of corruption) because Ukrainians are naively trying to be very open about that. And it’s okay. It’s great. I think truth is much better than hiding something.
So you can always talk about it (corruption in Ukraine), but when you talk about it, you should always underline that we know about it only because Ukraine is so open about it.
And that should be the underlying truth when you’re sharing this information.”
⸻———————————————
This was part of our discussion on November 18, 2026, at Northwestern University, where I joined fellow Ukrainian journalist Tanya Kozyreva to discuss: How can journalists balance impartial reporting with the responsibility to speak out during wartime?
The event was organized by the Ukrainian Club at Northwestern University and the Roberta Buffett Institute for Global Affairs.
A very special thank-you to Myroslava, a Ukrainian student originally from Kakhovka who is studying at Northwestern University, for her personal initiative and efforts in making this conversation possible 🙏
Vall retweeted
I want to begin with a word of thanks, and I mean it sincerely. Starlink has played an enormously important role in maintaining communications in Ukraine since the beginning of Russia’s full-scale invasion. And in February of this year, SpaceX, working with Ukraine, introduced measures to block the unauthorised use of Starlink by Russian forces. This helped counter Russian military operations, including the use of attack drones. We remember this, and we appreciate it.
But I would like to explain what the current controversy is actually about.
Musk argues that Ukraine wants to use commercial Starlink for offensive military operations. He emphasises that Starshield is a separate system controlled by the US government.
However, this explanation does not address the specific question Ukraine has raised: why are Starshield restrictions interfering with Ukrainian interceptor drones designed to protect civilians from Russian aerial attacks?
Russia uses jet-powered Shahed drones that travel at speeds well above 161 km/h. According to Ukrainian military reports, Starshield terminals lose connectivity once they exceed that speed in areas where the restrictions apply. This makes it more difficult to operate interceptor drones that need to catch up with Russian targets. On 12 November, President Zelenskyy explicitly stated that these restrictions allow more Russian strikes to reach their targets, resulting in the deaths of Ukrainian civilians.
So this is not simply about the ability to strike Russian military targets. It is about Ukraine’s ability to intercept a Russian drone heading towards a residential building, a hospital, or a power station. This is defence in the most basic, human sense of the word.
Now, who made the decision?
Musk maintains that Starshield is controlled by the US government and that decisions concerning its military use fall under the Pentagon’s authority. On 21 October, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said he was unaware of the administration having been informed in advance about the restrictions, and that access and speed limits were governed by the relevant commercial contracts. The Wall Street Journal, citing its sources, reported that Musk personally made the decision to impose the restrictions. Reuters, meanwhile, cited other officials who pointed to the White House. The Trump administration denied involvement, while SpaceX disputes reports of new changes to the restrictions in November.
I do not know which of these accounts is correct. But I see an obvious problem: Ukrainian military personnel are reporting restrictions that affect their defensive capabilities, while responsibility for those decisions remains unclear.
This uncertainty has also raised questions in the United States. On 13 November, US senators formally called on Musk and SpaceX to preserve technical records, correspondence, and documents that could establish who authorised the restrictions, when and on what grounds, and whether their consequences for Ukrainian air defence and the civilian population had been assessed.
There is another contradiction.
When asked directly in the interview whether Ukraine actually uses Starshield, Musk responded by saying that Zelenskyy was not telling the truth and that what he really wanted was to use commercial Starlink for offensive operations. Yet back in December 2024, Bloomberg reported on Pentagon contracts with SpaceX providing Starshield services for a total of 3,000 terminals in Ukraine. A US government agency confirmed that figure to Bloomberg. And in October of this year, Musk himself publicly explained that decisions concerning Starshield restrictions fell under the authority of the US government.
This does not prove that every Ukrainian terminal operates through Starshield, but it does establish that Ukraine had access to the system under these contracts. Therefore, accusing Zelenskyy of being untruthful requires a specific technical explanation, not simply a denial.
I also want to acknowledge Elon Musk’s personal role at the beginning of the full-scale invasion. On 26 February 2022, just two days after the invasion began, Mykhailo Fedorov appealed to him to provide Starlink connectivity to Ukraine. Musk responded immediately: the service was activated, and the first shipment of terminals arrived in Ukraine on 28 February. SpaceX had also been preparing to launch the service in Ukraine before the invasion.
This was critically important assistance at a moment when Russia was attempting to destroy Ukraine’s communications infrastructure. The speed of Musk’s response, his personal involvement, and his willingness to provide Ukraine with technology on which communications, defence, and human lives depended deserve genuine gratitude. I want to thank him once again for that.
A few words about history, because accuracy matters here too.
The Maidan was not a coup organised by the United States. It was a months-long popular protest movement that began after the Ukrainian government abandoned preparations to sign the Association Agreement with the European Union. The protests were marked by violence, and dozens of protesters were killed in February 2014. After Yanukovych left Kyiv, the Ukrainian parliament, the Verkhovna Rada, adopted a resolution on 22 February declaring that he had withdrawn from exercising his constitutional powers and calling early presidential elections.
The legal aspects of that decision, the role of external actors, and US diplomatic influence can all be debated. But none of this constitutes evidence that Washington organised a coup. Mr Musk presented no such evidence. Instead, this version of events is one of the central narratives Russia uses to justify its aggression against Ukraine. I find it deeply disappointing to hear it from Elon Musk.
And finally.
Musk speaks about the need to have empathy for those who die in war, including Russian soldiers. I understand this argument: every human life matters. But empathy should not erase the distinction between the responsibility of an aggressor state and the right of a country under attack to defend itself.
Moreover, the moral consequences of restricting communications cannot be judged solely by whether the technology helps carry out strikes. We must also consider how many lives it helps protect.
If a Ukrainian interceptor drone loses connectivity and can no longer catch a Russian attack drone, that does not mean the use of lethal force has been avoided. It means that other people are placed at greater risk — civilians in their homes, in their beds, in the middle of the night.
So my request is simple. Whoever makes these decisions must explain them openly, and responsibility for their consequences must be established. Restrictions on critical communications infrastructure, on which the protection of civilians depends, should not be introduced without proper justification, advance warning, and coordination with those directly affected.
Vall retweeted
NEW from @nytimes: Western intelligence agencies assess that Putin is not ready to seriously negotiate an end to his war in Ukraine, even though he plans to meet with Trump on Thursday. He could press Trump to halt sanctions. He hopes to break Ukraine's resistance this winter.
Vall retweeted
Turns out the U.S. intelligence assessment matches perfectly with 100 percent of the evidence we see in public about Putin not being serious about ending the war in Ukraine. Doesn’t matter. Trump and Kushner believe Putin over US intelligence every time.
NEW from @nytimes: Western intelligence agencies assess that Putin is not ready to seriously negotiate an end to his war in Ukraine, even though he plans to meet with Trump on Thursday. He could press Trump to halt sanctions. He hopes to break Ukraine's resistance this winter.
Vall retweeted
Trump administration cutting out the middleman and directly broadcasting Russian propaganda channels instead of merely echoing it as usual.
Vall retweeted
I destini del mondo affidati a un criminale di guerra, un autocrate spietato e un immobiliarista corrotto che si ritrovano intorno a un tavolo a parlare di “pace” e sicurezza internazionale.
In un’immagine, mille ragioni per cui è necessaria un’Europa unita e sovrana.
Vall retweeted
Можно так: Известная актриса София Эрнст похвалила известного режиссера Богомолова за его шедевр» Мраморная девочка « А можно так: жена Эрнста похвалила мужа Собчак за его надругательство над »Ифигения»» за государственные деньги.Вам как ближе?
Vall retweeted
I haven’t lived here in awhile, but I see no other way to answer the hundreds of texts/DMs asking me if the world is, indeed, ending.
In the span of six days, we’ve experienced;
11/12 — Microsoft outage
11/13 — Nationwide FAA ground stop
11/16 — Major US banking disruptions
11/17 — NSA’s classified internal network goes down
We need far more analysis of why so much is breaking at once. I don’t want to get out over my skis here, and what I am hearing does not contradict the messaging that most of this is the result of screwy updates.
But stepping back, the dots are starting to form a collective picture. We are seeing:
• An explosion in severe and critical vulnerabilities, with AI accelerating discovery to 3X the number of vulnerabilities discovered in the same period last year. This is collectively being referred to as “vulnageddon” or “the vulnpocalypse.”
• Mean time to exploit those vulnerabilities has collapsed to NEGATIVE SEVEN DAYS. AI allows attackers to find/exploit vulns far faster than software makers have time to fix them.
• Powerful AI-enabled offensive tools like ARTEX have been thrown into the hands of every third tier nation state, cybercriminal and digital arsonist, which logically creates havoc.
• This creates enormous pressure to compress patching windows and accelerate software updates, increasing the likelihood these fixes break things in unexpected, cascading ways.
• Pressure to just “AI everything” means we are rolling out automated AI tooling on top of brittle infrastructure that can’t support it.
My generation grew up in an extraordinary period of technological stability. We worked our way up the software stack, abstracting away layer after layer, until we lost a fundamental understanding of how the underlying systems actually work.
We were told to “move fast and break things.” VCS told us to celebrate the idea that “software would eat the world.” Now we’re telling ourselves we can simply “roll out AI” across everything, as though nothing underneath will buckle.
We never stopped to ask: SHOULD WE?
Should we be digitizing every last nook and cranny of our companies, infrastructure, healthcare, homes, cars, bodies, lives? Especially when the complexity, interdependence, and fragility we were introducing overwhelmed our ability to understand/secure/maintain the systems we built?
Nobody every asked: What if, in the name of progress, we were creating the ripest attack surface in human history?
We are now entirely dependent on software systems that almost nobody understands end to end, that increasingly few people can repair, and that attackers can now probe at machine speed. We are hearing that incident response firms, the 911 for breach victims, are backlogged six months. Even those paid on retainer lack the bandwidth to triage every incident. The cavalry is disappearing.
We are entering a period of unprecedented technological instability.
“Software Beirut” is an incredibly apt analogy. We are in for a period of cascading failures, whether triggered by attackers, bad updates, or our own accumulated complexity.
This, I’m sorry to say, is just the opening chapter.
Vall retweeted
Just a reminder of how long it took Ukraine to receive weapons:
First howitzer cannons? In 3 months.
First HIMARS? In 4 months.
First Western tanks? In 1 year (American ones in 1.5 years, with just 30 of them).
First Patriot defense system? In 1 year and 2 months.
First ATACMS? In 1.5 years.
First F-16s? In 2.5 years.
Permission to strike russian territory with Western rockets? After 2 years and 8 months.
If weapons had been provided to Ukraine faster and in the right quantities, russia would already have been defeated. But the West first needed to see enough Ukrainians sacrificed: Bucha, Mariupol, Bakhmut, Avdiivka. Thousands of civilians and children. Only after this sacrifice was "accepted" did the West begin giving Ukraine weapons.
How many more Ukrainians must die before the West provides Ukraine with everything it needs to defend itself against the russian evil? How many human lives must be put on the altar before moving to the next level?
Ukraine is fighting pure evil. If this evil empire is not stopped now, it will continue its expansion. Allowing russia to keep even a small part of Ukraine will signal to other dictators that aggression works.
The only way to end this evil is to give Ukraine everything it needs now. Stop playing catch-up at the cost of Ukrainian lives.
P.S. I made this post more than two years ago, when Joe Biden still was the president of the US.
Vall retweeted
- Giorgia Meloni : PM of Italy
"Accepting the occupation of Crimea would mean accepting that stronger nations can redraw borders by force.
Crimea is internationally recognized as part of Ukraine, and no illegal annexation can change that reality.”
.........
She is great😉
There is nothing more to add; Crimea is legally Ukrainian territory.
Putin recognized Crimea as part of Ukraine with his signature in 2003.
It is evident here that the treaty has become nothing more than a piece of paper for the Russians.!!
Vall retweeted
Kaja Kallas:
If we start to talk about what Russia is asking regarding the security architecture, we actually walk into the traps that Russia is setting us, which is that we divert the attention away from that there is no ceasefire and actually start to listen to their claims.
Vall retweeted
A friend of mine has just returned to the US after two weeks of difficult work in Ukraine. He shared with me some comments from several soldiers and commanders.
“When I think about why we lost Avdiivka, I always think about your Speaker Johnson. We could have held Avdiivka, and we could have stopped the russians. But we didn’t have the weapons.”
“If the U.S. government had allowed us to use Starshield on russian territory, we could have destroyed their missile launchers within weeks. We would have killed the archer instead of trying to intercept the arrow.”
Then he said, “As a U.S. citizen, I am deeply ashamed of this administration. There are simply no words left.”
Vall retweeted
乌克兰拆了一枚俄军新款小型巡航导弹,肚子里翻出将近一百个外国零件。
最扎眼的一块追踪模块,核心居然是一张英国产的民用树莓派微电脑。
再往下掀,里面还躺着中国微电脑、瑞士定位模块,外加四家美国厂商的芯片。
这份拆解来自乌克兰国防情报局(HUR)的战时制裁追踪库,美国保卫民主基金会(FDD)刚把细节拎了出来。
被拆的这枚导弹叫天竺葵-5 K5-K(Geran-5 K5-K),在俄罗斯阿拉布加工厂组装。
有意思的不只是零件像拼出来的,还有它的身份彻底变了。
以前的天竺葵-5,装了喷气发动机也还是按远程自杀无人机算的。
到了这个 K5-K 改型,乌克兰情报部门直接把它重新归类成了小型巡航导弹。
干嘛突然改头换面?
答案就在天上的新对手:乌军的高速防空拦截无人机。
以前那种贴着低空飞的慢速无人机,现在很容易被拦截无人机追上撞下来。
俄罗斯干脆动了大刀,先拿尺寸开刀。
老款天竺葵-5 机身 6.5 米,翼展 3.2 米。
新款 K5-K 直接把机身砍短两米半,缩到只剩 4 米,翼展也收到了 3 米。
流线型机身,高置后掠翼,配了 V 型尾翼和稳定舵面。
缩水这么多,威力减了吗?
没有。
4 米长的小身板,最大射程照样标到 1000 公里,肚子里塞的是一颗 90 公斤的 TBBCh-90 温压弹头。
巡航速度超过每小时 450 公里,升限从 5 公里拔高到了 6 公里。
据报到了末端俯冲攻击阶段,速度能飙到每小时 1000 公里。
说白了,就是把弹体压小、把速度拉满,专门往高速拦截无人机的防御空档里钻。
这么快一个小铁管,在强电子干扰下怎么找路?
顺着它塞满外国元件的机身往里看,就能看清这套制导拼图。
第一层靠抗干扰惯导和卫星。
导弹里装了一套叫 SADRA Seeker 的惯性导航系统,配一个 MOKh 模块,外加一个测气压的 AIR DATA TRD 单元。
天线用的是仿制 Harxon GI-006 的 16 阵元抗干扰天线,卫星定位模块则是瑞士的 u-blox。
那要是卫星信号被彻底掐断呢?
它肚子里还藏了一套代号苏萨宁(Susanin)的光电景象匹配系统。
原理很直接:机载双波段摄像头对着地面实时拍照,拿拍到的画面去比对事先存好的地形参考数据。
不靠卫星,自己看地貌认路往目标飞。
跑这套图像匹配算法的脑子,是一块中国产的 Coke Pi 微电脑。
飞出去之后,怎么传回遥测追踪状态?
拆出来的另一块追踪器代号罗宋汤(Borshch),里面焊着的就是那块英国产的树莓派 4 Model B 微电脑。
早在天竺葵-4 寻觅者(Geran-4 Seeker)喷气无人机上,这套同款电子架构就已经用上了。
把整套电路板摊开数一遍,里面一共找出了 93 到将近 100 个外国电子元件。
除了上面这几块微电脑和瑞士模块,底下的半导体、微控制器和基础芯片上,密密麻麻印着四家美国厂商的名字:德州仪器(Texas Instruments)、亚德诺(Analog Devices)、Diodes Incorporated 和 Vishay。
把参数和拆解单摆在一起,能看出一个很现实的拼图:
俄罗斯在阿拉布加工厂没能建起一条纯国产的军工供应链,却用买得到的民用微电脑和四家美国厂商的通用芯片,拼出了一枚 4 米长、末端时速 1000 公里、扛着 90 公斤温压弹飞 1000 公里的小型巡航导弹。
制裁清单写得再细,只要这些通用半导体和开源微电脑还能绕道流进阿拉布加的装配线,前线头顶上落下来的,就不会再是慢吞吞的螺旋桨无人机。
Vall retweeted
Dear Mr Biden,
THANK YOU for persuading us to give up our nuclear weapons in exchange for absolutely NOTHING.
THANK YOU for the years of security assurances that failed to protect Ukraine when Russia invaded.
SORRY we didn't all just quietly die, so things wouldn't be so hard for you, poor thing.
THANK YOU for withholding the weapons we desperately needed at the start, when they might have stopped Russia from killing us.
THANK YOU for saying "no" to F-16s, and then sending them a year and a half later, when the price had already been paid in Ukrainian lives.
THANK YOU for letting us hit the airfields Russia bombs us from only after almost three years, as if escalation were our problem and not Putin's.
And before anyone starts, yes, we are deeply grateful to the American people, to Congress, and to everyone who helped Ukraine survive. Your support has saved countless lives. But gratitude does not mean silence about decisions that came too late or never been made.
AND ONCE AGAIN, SORRY WE DIDN'T DIE STRAIGHT AWAY. AND THAT WE'VE BEEN STILL FIGHTING AND SURVIVING FOR ALMOST FIVE YEARS.
And apparently, still not grateful enough.
WSJ: President Biden calls Ukrainian President Zelensky "stubborn" and "not grateful" in new memoir
While Biden believed that while Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s acting background "turned out to be very good training" for a wartime leader, Zelensky "could be moody and stubborn in our private conversations, and not as grateful as I would have expected."
Link to article: wsj.com/arts-culture/books/t…
Vall retweeted
Absolutely unacceptable behaviour by Belarusian tennis player Aryna Sabalenka!
Aryna has failed to condemn the aggressive war against Ukraine, the mass repression of Belarusians, has not spoken out in support of the release of political prisoners, not even women, and now she is insulting Ukrainians @ElinaSvitolina, against whom a war of annihilation is being waged.
She should be banned from all WTA-sanctioned tournaments @WTA. This is the only proportionate response to such behaviour. She is a disgrace to the Belarusian people.
Vall retweeted
Wie man im November 2026 noch immer derart geschichtsvergessen über die diplomatische Vorgeschichte der russischen Invasion schreiben kann, ist einfach nur sagenhaft.
Gerade bei Varwick, aber auch bei Mangott, Kujat, Vad, fällt seit Jahren ein bemerkenswertes Muster auf. Gebetsmühlenartig werden westliche (und ukrainische) Kompromissbereitschaft und Verhandlungen eingefordert, während die tatsächlich stattgefundenen Verhandlungen und die konkreten westlichen (sowie ukrainischen) Angebote erstaunlich konsequent aus der Darstellung verschwinden.
Dabei ist die Chronologie eindeutig und für jedermann problemlos überprüfbar:
17. Dezember 2021: Russland veröffentlicht seine beiden Ultimaten an die USA und die NATO. Gefordert werden unter anderem ein verbindlicher Verzicht auf weitere NATO-Erweiterungen und ein weitreichender Rückbau der militärischen NATO-Infrastruktur auf den Stand des Jahres 1997.
10. Januar 2022: Die USA verhandeln mit Russland in Genf.
12. Januar 2022: Der NATO-Russland-Rat tritt in Brüssel zusammen. Die NATO bietet Verhandlungen über Rüstungskontrolle, Raketenstationierungen und vertrauensbildende Maßnahmen an.
13. Januar 2022: Weitere Verhandlungen im Rahmen der OSZE in Wien.
21. Januar 2022: US-Außenminister Antony Blinken und Russlands Außenminister Sergej Lawrow führen weitere Gespräche in Genf.
26. Januar 2022: Die USA und die NATO übermitteln Russland jeweils eigene detaillierte Gegenangebote, die eine knappe Woche später von El Pais veröffentlicht werden. Darin enthalten sind Vorschläge zu Raketenstationierungen, Rüstungskontrolle, gegenseitigen Inspektionen, militärischer Transparenz und vertrauensbildenden Maßnahmen. Alles Dinge, welche bei Umsetzung die objektive Sicherheit Russlands nachweislich erhöht hätten.
17. Februar 2022: Russland erklärt die US-amerikanische Antwort für unzureichend und beharrt auf seinen Maximalforderungen, insbesondere hinsichtlich des NATO-Erweiterungsstopps und des Rückbaus militärischer Präsenz des Bündnisses in Osteuropa. Lawrow glaubt zwar "vernünftige Ansätze bei nachrangigen Fragen" zu erkennen, besteht jedoch auf den zentralen russischen Forderungen.
24. Februar 2022: Russland beginnt die Invasion der Ukraine.
Welche Kompromisslinien genau hätte der Westen noch ausloten sollen? Man kann über die Erfolgsaussichten weiterer Verhandlungen streiten. Man kann sogar argumentieren, dass zusätzliche Zugeständnisse hätten angeboten werden sollen. Aber man kann nicht ernsthaft so tun, als hätte der Westen mögliche Kompromisslinien überhaupt nicht ausgelotet.
Wozu der Westen freilich 2021/22 nicht bereit war (und hoffentlich nach wie vor nicht bereit ist), Russland ein Vetorecht über die souveränen Entscheidungen europäischer Staaten und damit über die Zukunft von ganz Europa einzuräumen. Wer darin eine Verweigerung von Diplomatie zu erblicken glaubt, sollte seinen inneren Kompass überprüfen.
Insbesondere sollten ausgerechnet diejenigen, die unablässig mehr Realismus in der Außenpolitik einfordern, wenigstens bereit sein, die historischen Fakten zur Kenntnis zu nehmen. Denn es ist schon ein bemerkenswertes Kunststück, aus Russlands Ultimaten, der westlichen Verhandlungsbereitschaft, konkreten westlichen Gegenangeboten, der russischen Invasion und Russlands fortgesetztem Beharren auf seinen Maximalforderungen eine Geschichte über mangelnde westliche Kompromissbereitschaft zu konstruieren.

























