Farr Leshy retweeted
Okay, okay, let's go.
"Dain," you may be saying, "what the hell are you talking about? Why would you compare this troonish clownshow cartoon to a Harry Potter fanfic trend?"
Well, I said they're opposites. But they're not *perfect* opposites, more like rough antonyms to each other.
Both Harry Potter/Malfoid and TADC hit very hard on the themes of COMMUNITY and IDENTITY.
Community: family, friends, allegiance, loyalty, trust.
Identity: memory, heritage, potential, perspective and personal choice.
Yet even these themes are handled so differently that the stories are almost opposites.
It's important to keep in mind that The Amazing Digital Circus is written by a trans person, from a trans perspective, with all the cultural baggage that comes with trans-ness.
@Devon_Eriksen_ recently wrote about the reason Harry Potter was as wildly successful as it was. Harry Potter fulfilled the fantasy, the yearning need felt by Millenials: the need to feel special, to be chosen, to be loved by a family, to have a purpose in this life.
Because, of course, Millenials did not have these things. Boomer parents cannot love anybody but themselves, and modern society is really very bad at supplying anyone with a clear purpose, or choosing anyone for anything meaningful.
Malfoid deepens this yearning by supplying something complementary to that: a formidible love interest, with her own rich inner life and interesting story arc, who becomes Harry's greatest love and ally.
Good God, who wouldn't want that?
Well, okay, so it stands to reason that TADC is doing something similar, but aimed at a different yearning.
So what does TADC yearn for?
Well, let's try to pull it apart and see how it works.
The first thing that happens to anybody in TADC is that they are completely separated from their body, and then assigned a new digital body based on the whims of a cruel god.
To enter the Digital Circus is to lose all control of self, to lose all memory of who you are.
That which anchors your identity -- your body and memory -- are undone at the start. Your new "community" is miserable and broken. Nobody is in control of anything, everyone is struggling with themselves in different ways, and
This, to me, sounds an awful lot like the trans experience.
To be unable to reconcile with one's own existence. To yearn to remake oneself whole.
Malfoid arrives at Hogwarts with hundreds of years of family heritage, an identity all ready-made for her, a role she merely has to step into, but for the conflicts within her own heart. She has everything to lose and everything to gain; her story is rich with meaning because her choices are heavy with consequence for who she will become.
Pomni is torn from herself and arrives in a broken world among broken people, utterly disoriented and without direction except a hope that she might somehow find a way to escape. All she can do is try to relate to a group of people who have very little left of themselves to relate to.
Everyone Pomni encounters is fighting a losing battle within themselves. Kinger is losing his memory, Gangle cannot control her emotions, Ragatha constantly negates herself and bends over backwards to please others, Zooble can assemble herself any which way from a box of mismatched parts but none of the parts can help her feel like herself. Everyone in this story is losing who they are. Especially Jax, who cannot connect with anyone without lashing out at them. He, who is losing himself most of all, does the most to sabotage the identities of everyone around him.
Everyone in TADC is on a slippery slope toward Abstraction -- a total nullification of self, heavily implied to be a metaphor for suicide. When a personality in the Digital Circus can no longer maintain its identity, it becomes an enraged blob of unidentifiable monstrous nobody. An angry, hungry void of identity.
The actual antagonist of TADC is not Jax or the insane ringleader god or any of the monsters or even a character.
The antagonist of TADC is Abstraction.
And at the end of the story, Abstraction is not defeated!
The characters reconcile with themselves somewhat, but they're not really any less broken than they were at the beginning. Pomni has something of a heroic arc, but only because she was the least fractured personality at the outset. She came in with the most personal ability to adapt, and the strongest native sense of self.
TADC is a miserable story that ends on the bright and hopeful note of "now that we're not being actively tortured unto Abstraction, maybe we can make our lives in this Hell somewhat tolerable."
Evil is not defeated. In fact, the most evil character in the story is the one who receives the most sympathy! There's no shred of a sense of responsibility for the people he very clearly knowingly destroyed.
Harry Potter and its Malfoid adaptations are heroic stories. Even though you can see where Tom Riddle came from and understand his fall into evil, there's no sympathy for the Voldemort he became. Harry and Draconia offer him one last chance to repent and repair his soul, and when the evil bastard refuses, they destroy him without hesitation or fanfare. And then they live very happily ever after, with a herd of platinum-haired children named after the friends and family they tragically lost along the way.
TADC ends in total desolation. Meaning and future and even embodiment is robbed from everybody, and the remainder of their existence will be a desperate struggle to cling to whatever happiness they can make for themselves, lest they, too Abstract as all their friends did.
TADC yearns for identity, community, and some sense of control, but all it manages to do is pathetically cope with the various ways its remaining characters are broken. They are not healed! What is lost can never be recovered, and Abstraction is still there, waiting to take them the moment they slip up.
If this is the kind of story that trans folk are telling each other, then I think that they are far more lost than we know. Gooseworx's own statements make it clear that Jax is meant to be trans (coming out to his mother was made out to be the central trauma of his character), just about everyone in the story is some flavor of LGBT, and Abstraction is a metaphor for the mental decline that leads to suicide, or perhaps suicide itself.
Malfoid is a story that yearns for love, connection and personal excellence.
TADC is a story that yearns for a reprieve from degradation into nothing.
Malfoid is a story about becoming better people in order to overcome evil.
TADC is a story about succumbing to inevitability in order to cope with evil.
I yearn for the happy ending of Malfoid.
I wouldn't wish the ending of TADC on my worst enemy.
And that's why these two stories are as good as opposites.
🤖 Made with AI
Farr Leshy retweeted
"O problema dos incels é que seus cérebros foram cozinhados por mídias que mosttam romance clássico e genuíno ao invés de sexo casual e aborto"
Farr Leshy retweeted
The social contract is where you pay ruinously high property taxes so that the local government can side with the savage who strangled your daughter on the bus, doing nothing to stop it and indeed hiding it from you after it occurred
Thank you for this, Eisenhower
they realized that nobody believes their claims about being 'porn-brained' anymore, and decided to just say what they really meant all this time: they think men don't deserve love, intimacy, or even romance.
I think a big part of Incel's problem is that they've had their brains absolutely cooked by anime tropes about romance. Just the idea of "Confessing" to someone seems not only kinda childish, but puts the whole experience up on this pedestal when reality is much less dramatic
VA disability is social security for non boomers:
almost entirely fraudulent, and a person's view on it provides a quick judge of their character
People figured out they get $4000.00 plus a month for life after 4 years of service and are taking advantage of it. The consequences of VA disability fraud going unchecked.
Farr Leshy retweeted
"Incels are evil because they have hearts and romanticism".
Uh...sure.
I served 4 years in the military. any vet who is ironically proud of his military service is naive or retarded. The military does not exist for the sake of US citizens; its primary purposes are:
1
Latin America: The entire region is controlled by criminals and globalhomo
Middle East: The entire region is either Taliban, Islamo-nationalist, or Israel
1
Farr Leshy retweeted
A lot of people have real trouble thinking about the aggregate behavior of groups. They can only think about individuals.
So they think about Elon Musk as an individual. Maybe they think that he must be retarded, because they need that for emotional reasons. Or maybe they think he is a talented rocket designer.
But even if they realize he understands rockets, they can only think about him as an individual doing tasks. Not about his impact on what the whole company does.
If Elon Musk is just a talented rocket designer, then he can spend all day, every day, improving rocket designs.
But he is just one of 7000 engineers. So even if did a perfect job, he would only improve progress by about .014%
So, when a midwit looks at SpaceX, he sees 7000 engineers, and says to himself "Elon Musk cannot possibly be designing the whole damn rocket himself. These people are giving him too much credit."
This would be absolutely true if Musk were just a some random SpaceX engineer. But he isn't. He's the absolute dictator of the whole damn company.
He decides, with absolute and unquestionable authority, which behaviors are punished and which are rewarded.
Why is this important?
When I worked at Boeing, on various classified projects, I naively came in with the assumption that I was a software engineer, employed to design and build functional software as quickly and cheaply as possible.
Because of this, I focused on functionality and efficiency, for example suggesting changes that would obviate the need for entire projects and software components.
And I very rapidly became persona non grata.
At first, this caused me to adopt an air of aggrieved innocence. I was just trying to do my job well, and I was being punished for it.
Then I gradually came to realize that I hadn't properly understood what my job was, or what the actual mission of Boeing Defense, Space, and Security was.
Boeing DSS was not an aerospace company. Boeing DSS was a fraud company.
Its goal was twofold. First, to maximize transfer of public tax dollars to stockholder pockets. Second, to maintain the appearance of being an aerospace company, to prevent the fraud from being exposed.
Which meant that my real job was twofold. First, to generate billable hours. Second, to look busy.
This is why Space Launch System sucks. Why it is always late when it doesn't fail outright. Why it is at 300% of its target budget. Why it leaves American astronauts stranded and needing a lift from SpaceX.
That's because, for Boeing, building rockets is a side quest. Something they have to do to look busy. Yes, a rocket does occasionally fly, but that's just happening so programs don't get shut down.
For Boeing, coming in early and under budget would actually be failure. The system is functioning exactly as designed.
The cost, not the rocket, is the goal.
Musk and SpaceX don't work like that.
Unlike Boeing executives, Musk is not a useless grifter asshole. He is an entirely different kind of asshole... a rocket obsessed sperg.
So, at SpaceX, engineers do not get rewarded for generating billable hours. They get rewarded for making rockets fly. And for all the subtasks of this, like figuring out how to make rockets lighter, figuring out how to make engines reignite better, figuring out how to make rocket exhaust not destroy launch pads, etc.
And this attracts engineers who care about rockets. You've seen them on broadcasts, crying on open microphones because they dedicated their lives to something and it just flew.
As a rocket engineer, who designs rockets, Musk is probably replaceable. As a rocket company engineer, who designs rocket companies, he is not.
For over 50 years, the US space industry stagnated precisely for the lack of a Musk-like figure, who could not only create an effective aerospace company, but who could thereby demonstrate what an effective aerospace company looks like.
Which makes it much more difficult for fraudsters to get away with fraud.
I'm envious. I wish I could have worked for an aerospace company instead of a fraud company.
But what's more important is that some of us now no longer have to play "who gets the most cheese?".
They get to play "What can we build today?".
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.
Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?
Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?
I am genuinely curious about these questions.
Farr Leshy retweeted
Women were apparently so incompetent that every civilisation independently came to the conclusion that their rights needed to be restricted, despite having no contact or connection with one another.
Farr Leshy retweeted
My favorite part of Attack on Titan is when the Evil Fascist Antagonists hesitated to murder their longtime friends who betrayed their cause, and because of this hesitation they all get killed by these former friends who are helping the dictatorship that enslaved their whole race
American culture is White culture, which is why you identify more closely with your brown ancestors and their cultural heritage rather than your American nationality.
If White people want to establish a country built around a shared White racial identity, they're welcome to pursue that. I have no objection to the idea in principle.
The thing is, America is not, and was never intended to remain, a country exclusively for White people.
I'm terribly sorry this bothers you so much. Perhaps you should go find your bottle and blankie, crawl into bed, and have a good cry about it.
I care about the CULTURE of this country, not its racial makeup.
I care about American values. Individual liberty. Personal responsibility. Equality before the law. Freedom of speech. Freedom of religion. The right to keep and bear arms. The idea that people should be judged by their actions and character rather than their ancestry.
I care about people coming here and wanting to become AMERICANS, rather than demanding that America become whatever country they left behind.
If you want to fight to preserve those things, I'll stand shoulder to shoulder with you the entire goddamn way.
We can argue about immigration policy. We can argue about assimilation. We can argue about whether American institutions are doing enough to preserve the culture that made this country worth coming to in the first place.
Those are legitimate arguments, and I'm perfectly willing to have them.
However, if your entire complaint boils down to "THERE ARE TOO MANY BROWN PEOPLE!", you're going to have to find somebody else to stand beside you.
I don't give a flying fuck whether someone's ancestors came from England, Nigeria, India, Mexico, or the moons of Jupiter. If they embrace American values, respect our institutions, and want to contribute to this country, they're welcome in my book.
If somebody whose ancestors arrived on the Mayflower despises those same values, their pedigree doesn't impress me one goddamn bit.
If you can't handle this? I'd love to send you somewhere else on the same boat I want to send the Muslims that want to turn America into an Islamic republic. I don't give a fuck about their skin color, either.
Farr Leshy retweeted
“Incels problem is that they want their romance to be romantic instead of gay and modern and confusing”
Maybe you’re just subhuman cattle.
Farr Leshy retweeted
White guys love libertarianism so much because they’ve spent their entire lives living under a government that actively discriminates against them. So now they can’t even imagine a healthy govt that makes their lives better. A White guy libertarian is like an abuse victim whose idea of a perfect partner is “he doesn’t beat me.”



























