I was mad at Grok 4.7, but then it helped me find another way to explain "circular reasoning" in Einstein's Special Relativity paper. 😆
GPT 5.6 Sol also agrees that Einstein's re-derivation attempt of Voigt's Doppler Transforms are circular.
Grok link:
grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5LWNvc…
Replying to @OMinazzoli
Re: "As if I wouldn't be delighted to find a better theory than GR..."
You believe in the fantasy of "curved spacetime." You won't be able to find anything else, if you believe that Einstein's fantasy is correct.
Replying to @engineers_feed
Einstein reused Max Planck's energy element math incorrectly (e=hv)
Einstein reused Owen Richardson's work function from thermionic emission.
Einstein's formula did not predict Millikan's wave resonance effect.
Schrodinger photoelectric idea is the correct path.
Replying to @Magus_of_Mind
Planck length is theoretical and derived from Planck's constant, which is generally misunderstood. Scientifically, 'h' is the minimum amplitude of an electromagnetic wave (as far as we discovered it).
Our Ummo space brothers mention the minimum length is 12^-13 cm (femtometer).
Replying to @Shaun_Fosmark
Electromagnetic Energy = mass * (per permittivity) * (per permeability) of the electromagnetic medium.
The dielectric and magnetic inductions could be successive points that create 3d spherical waves.
The so called "photon" becomes an induction point of the medium.
Replying to @HeliosYourSun
How does the scam fly around like it did in the stabilized video and maintain the precession wobble?
Replying to @demystifysci
And Heaviside blasting the Brits and Royal Society is always good. He saw Einstein's grift...
Replying to @demystifysci
Wait, but that isn't correct. Heaviside proved that wrong with the telegraph equation that created the long distance communication industry.
That created Pupin Coils to help with balancing capacitance with more inductance.
Replying to @SonOfClawDraws
Re: "The Lorentz transformation preserves that null interval."
No. Fantasy physics that doesn't recognize the math as the Voigt Doppler transforms preserves the null interval out of ignorance.
Just read Klinaku's work. He unified Voigt's special case, Doppler work.
Replying to @SonOfClawDraws
Re: "does it recover the same observables as GR without inserting them independently?"
GR just claims to be "curving spacetime." Those spacetime transforms are Voigt's Doppler effect for the medium, so Einstein's tensorization of Newton's G is just pressure/density of medium.
Replying to @SonOfClawDraws
Re: "spacetime curvature"
This is a lie. It's simply a change in permeability and permittivity of the EM medium.
SPACETIME means you believe that two people that are moving away from each other are BOTH centered in a spherical wave pulse!
You can't be that stupid, can you?🤷♂️
Replying to @engineers_feed
Einstein got the photoelectric "law" wrong!
Millikan found wave resonance in the photoelectric experiments, which Einstein's law doesn't predict.
Einstein just combined Planck's Math (e=hv) and Owen Richard's workfunction.
Einstein's SR is Voigt's 1887 Doppler Transform math.
Replying to @thewreathwright
We have not properly understood the "electric body" of our human bodies. Electrical science was partly ruined by Einsteiners.
Start with the "silver chord".
Recognize the physical process learning progression described by Ummo.
















































