Powerful summation. 100% agree
Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey may be the most pro-Western civilization film Hollywood has made in decades - not because it flatters the Greeks, but because it understands civilization as a moral achievement rather than an ethnic possession.
The identitarian far-left and far-right share a premise: that the Western canon is ethnic property. One side condemns it on that basis; the other guards it on the same basis. Nolan refuses the premise, populating Homer's world with various identities while treating the story with absolute seriousness. That’s not a repudiation of the canon but evidence of its triumph: Homer can be inhabited by, and speak to, anyone.
The film’s deepest commitment is to individual moral agency. Odysseus cannot hide behind Greece, military orders, or victory. His choices are his own, and so is his guilt. No collective cause dissolves individual moral responsibility; his final heroism lies not in conquest, but atonement.
That principle extends to hospitality: treat the stranger as you would wish to be treated. When the Greeks violate it, they become the barbarians they fear. Penelope's devastating realization - "You're the people from the sea" - underscores that the enemies of civilization are sometimes its self-appointed defenders, exempting themselves from the principles they claim to uphold.
This is Western civilization at its best - not an ethnicity or a triumphalist myth, but a tradition built around the dignity of the individual, moral responsibility, and atonement. And a civilization strong enough to preserve stories that judge its own heroes remains a civilization worth defending.
4
392
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
MEDICARE PATIENTS: Please repost this message so other Medicare patients see it. Your community doctor is disappearing. Over the past 15 years, America has lost the vast majority of its independent private practices. As independent physicians disappear, patients are waiting months to see a doctor and access to timely care is being threatened. If Medicare continues on its current course, more physicians will be forced to opt out of Medicare or close their practices, putting your access to your trusted community doctor at risk. Medicare policy is being made without a private practicing physician at the table—and patients will ultimately pay the price.
Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) and email [email protected] today. Tell CMS to protect independent private practice medicine and make sure a private practicing physician has a seat at the table. After you call or email, reply “DONE” in the comments. Together, we can make sure CMS hears from hundreds of thousands of MEDICARE PATIENTS. @CMSGov @mcuban @AARP
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
Hey @DrOz,
When you started practicing medicine in 1993, the RVU reimbursement rate was $31.60. @CMSgov is proposing that in 2027, it is $33.40.
Adjusted for inflation (+132%),
that’s a 54% cut…
No wonder you quit practicing medicine. The financials don’t make sense.
Can you tell @CMSGov…oh, wait a minute…
🤔🤨😒
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
This is correct
This also seems like the time to share one my favorite pieces of writing from a friend reviewing the Michael Bay film ARMAGEDDON
=====
Last night, exhausted by the demands of ministering to the child post-surgery, I resolved to dull the senses with something other than the ravages of drink, and so found myself perusing the very worst action films Netflix has to offer. This is how I ended up watching the final thirty minutes — because plot is irrelevant, you have to skip straight to the action, and the best action is always at the end — of a movie I’ve never seen before: the 1998 Michael Bay epic “Armageddon.”
I set out to find the worst, and was handed the best. When I write “handed,” I may mean “punched in the face with."
“Epic” may be an unsuitable word. Masterpiece? Towering art? Genius cinema? The greatest depiction of American patriotism since President Harrison Ford killed all the terrorists on his plane? Perhaps it doesn’t matter what you call it: all that matters is that the entire Criterion Collection is replaced with “Armageddon,” over and over. There is the scene in one of the auteur MacFarlane’s works in which 1972’s “The Godfather” is dismissed because “It insists on itself.” In “Armageddon,” Bay's work insists on America. A multiracial crew of spacefaring heroes — there’s even a woman and an Italian, so expansive is Bay’s patriotic vision — ascends to the stars to, apparently, detonate a nuclear weapon inside a giant comet. (Is it a comet or an asteroid? The question is a burden to others, the answer a burden to myself.) They are aided by a semi-lunatic Russian who is properly subordinated to the American effort. There are no other nations represented in the effort to save the world, as they do not matter. Nevertheless, when this American effort succeeds, the entire world erupts in grateful celebration, as it ought to anyway. Children in the streets of other countries' cities pretend to be Americans, as they ought to anyway. Children in American streets pretend to be astronauts armed with nuclear weapons, as they ought to anyway.
The two main heroes are square-jawed old man and square-jawed young man, who have it seems spent the preceding two hours contending for possession of a young woman on Earth. At the end the former elects to forfeit the woman to the latter in exchange for the privilege of setting off a gigantic atomic bomb in space, which seems like a rational trade. The latter respects this decision — he may understand he was outwitted and is receiving the inferior deal — and at the climactic moment barks an homage to his erstwhile rival: “HE DOESN’T KNOW HOW TO FAIL.” Just like America in 1998.
The visual aesthetic is an aggressive assault upon the senses and cognition. Jump cuts are interspersed with smash cuts, alternating every fifteen seconds for the entire film. Emotive crescendos are succeeded by emotive crescendos amplifying and exceeding the preceding emotive crescendos. Bay is a filmmaker of clarity, a director with a direct line to the mind of the masses, who don’t want to miss a thing. As the old man approaches his moment of death, he shares a tender farewell with his daughter, poignant and intimate, which in Bay’s vision — which is a correct and fully American vision — means it is done over gigantic screens with the whole world watching. You know, in this moment, that everything he does is for her. Then, when he presses the button and dies in a comet-shattering atomic blast, Bay senses that the moment is right for a rapid series of cuts of his final fleeting thoughts and visions, which are all of his daughter. You know, in this moment, that everything he does is for her. You already knew that! KNOW IT AGAIN, says Bay, and behold it is so.
“Armageddon” is the Shepard tone of movies.
I feel no need to see the full movie. I know enough. I know what it is. I also know that Michael Bay understands America as no man has since Abraham
INDEPENDENCE DAY is the greatest movie about America. Maybe just the greatest American movie, period. Hard to say. (Also, objectively, one of the dumbest. But that's okay!) movieaisle.substack.com/p/in…
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
Replying to @FAHhospitals
“Self referral” is what hospitals make their employed physicians do, all the time.
If avoiding conflict of interest is so important, we should end hospitals employing physicians and restore physician’s independence
Don’t you agree?
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
Replying to @FAHhospitals
“The data is clear: POHs tend to treat more commercially insured and healthier patients than full-service hospitals.”
So what? Physicians can’t force patients to go to their hospitals. They have to offer quality care.
Patients are not going to choose bad care deliberately. If they choose a POH, it is not COI. It is because the care is better
Why would you want to limit to access of rural patients to the best quality care?
Must they be forced to use lower quality care because you can’t compete on an even playing field?
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
Three weeks into the war with Iran, a number of observations as someone who spent years war-gaming this scenario.
1. The U.S. and Israel may have produced regime transition in the worst possible way.
Ali Khamenei was 86 and had survived multiple bouts of prostate cancer. His death in the coming years would likely have triggered a real internal reckoning in Iran, potentially opening the door to somewhat more pragmatic leadership, especially after the protests and crackdown last month. Instead, the regime made its most consequential decision under existential external threat giving the hardliners a clear upperhand. Now we appear to have a successor who is 30 years younger, deeply tied to the IRGC, and radicalized by the war itself – including the killing of family members. Disastrous.
2. About seven years ago at CNAS, I helped convene a group of security, energy, and economic experts to walk through scenarios for a U.S.--Iran war and the implications for global oil prices. What we’re seeing now was considered one of the least likely but worst outcomes. The modeling assumed the Strait of Hormuz could close for 4–10 weeks, with 1–3 years required to restore oil production once you factored in infrastructure damage. Prices could spike from around $65 to $175–$200 per barrel, before eventually settling in the $80–$100 range a year later in a new normal.
3. One surprising development: Iran is still moving oil through the Strait of Hormuz while disrupting everyone else. In most war games I participated in, we assumed Iran couldn’t close the Strait and still use it themselves. That would have made the move extremely self-defeating. But Iran appears capable of harassing global shipping while still pushing some of its own exports through. That changes the calculus.
4. The U.S. now finds itself in the naval and air equivalent of the dynamic we faced in Iraq and Afghanistan. It’s a recipe for a quagmire where we win every battle and lose the war. We have overwhelming military dominance and are exacting a tremendous cost. But Iran doesn’t need to win battles. They just need occasional successes. A small boat hitting a tanker. A drone slipping through defenses in the Gulf. A strike on a hotel or oil facility. Each incident creates insecurity and drives costs up while remind everyone that the regime is surviving and fighting.
5. The deeper problem is that U.S. objectives were set far too high. Once “regime change” becomes the implicit or explicit goal, the bar for American success becomes enormous. Iran’s bar is simple: survive and keep causing disruption.
6. The options for ending this war now are all bad. You can try to secure the entire Gulf and Middle East indefinitely – extremely expensive and maybe impossible. You can invade Iran and replace the regime, but nobody is seriously going to do that. Costs are astronomical. You can try to destabilize the regime by supporting separatist groups. It probably won’t work and if it does you’ll most likely spark a civil war producing years of bloody chaos the U.S. will get blamed for. None of these are good outcomes.
7. The other escalatory options being discussed are taking the nuclear material out of Esfahan or taking Kargh Island. Esfahan is not really workable. Huge risk. You’d have been on the ground for a LONG time to safely dig in and get the nuclear material out in the middle of the country giving Iran time to reinforce from all over and over run the American position.
8. Kharg Island can be appealing to Trump. He’d love to take Iran’s ability to export oil off the map and try to coerce them to end the war. It’s much easier because it’s not in the middle of IRan. But it’s still a potentially costly ground operation. And again. Again, the Iranian government only has to survive to win and they can probably do that even without Kargh.
9. The least bad option is the classic diplomatic off-ramp. The U.S. declares that Iran’s military capabilities have been significantly degraded, which is how the Pentagon always saw the purpose of the war. Iran declares victory for surviving and demonstrating it can still threaten regional actors. It would feel unsatisfying. But this is the inevitable outcome anyway. Better to stop now than after five or ten more years of escalating costs. Remember in Afghanistan we turned down a deal very early in the war with the Taliban that looked amazing 20 years later. Don’t need to repeat that kind of mistake.
10. The U.S. and Israel are not perfectly aligned here. Trump just needs a limited win and would see long-term instability as a negative whereas for Netanyahu a weak unstable Iran that bogs the U.S. down in the MIddle East is a fine outcome. If President Trump decided he wanted Israel to stop, he likely has the leverage to push it in that direction just as he pressured Netanyahu to take a deal last fall on Gaza.
11. When this is over, the Gulf states will have to rethink their entire security strategy. They are stuck in the absolute worst place. They didn’t start this war and didn’t want it and now they are taking with some of the worst consequences. Neither doubling down with the U.S. and Israel nor placating the Iranians seems overwhelmingly appealing.
12. One clear geopolitical winner so far: Russia. Oil prices are rising. Sanctions are coming off. Western attention and military resources are shifting away from Ukraine. From Moscow’s perspective, this war is a win win win.
13. At some point China may have a role to play here. It is the world’s largest oil importer, and much of that supply comes from the Middle East. Yes they are still getting oil from Iran. But they also buy from the rest of the Middle East, and a prolonged disruption in the Gulf hits Beijing hard. That gives China a real incentive to help push toward an end to the conflict.
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
For me, the idea of an afterlife is unneeded; what matters is what we do here, in the time we have.
- Carl Sagan
"When My Husband Died”, Ann Druyan on the Passing of Carl Sagan. pioneerinphysics.medium.com/…
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
90% of people don’t hit their deductible.
Median spend is $500.
Insurance should only cover large unexpected loss. I hope to never use my homeowner or disability insurance!
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
RFK Jr. is misrepresenting a landmark Danish study that followed 1.2 million children over 24 years. The study found no link between aluminum in vaccines and autism or neurodevelopmental harm. Let’s fact-check his claims - using actual data. 🧵
The pharma-funded mainstream media has been touting a recent study of the Danish health registry—Andersson, et al.—which purports to show that aluminum-containing vaccines are not associated with neurological injuries including autism and Asperger's.
In the accompanying article, I inventory the long parade of statistical artifices that the industry-funded authors used to achieve their deceptive results.
Fierce criticism from the scientific community has now forced the authors to release their supplementary data, which shows calamitous evidence of harm.
These data are a devastating indictment of aluminum-containing vaccines directly contradicting the published study’s conclusions.
The data show a statistically significant 67% increased risk of Asperger’s syndrome per 1 mg increase in aluminum exposure among children born between 2007 and 2018.
Compared to the moderate exposure group, for every 10,000 children in the highest aluminum exposure cohort, there were: 9.7 more cases of neurodevelopmental disorder, 4.5 more cases of autistic disorder, and 8.7 more cases of the broader category of autism spectrum disorder.
By exposing these dangerous deceptions, @HHSGov is signaling a new era of gold standard science, obliterated taboos, and public honesty.
trialsitenews.com/a/flawed-s…
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
This is why academic medicine is in deep trouble. They are losing touch with their colleagues in medicine.
Want to open up primary care physician time? Stop acquiring primary care practices and overloading them with admin work.
Incredible person. His documentary was amazing ,worth watching for anyone but especially a child of the 80s.
Thank you sir
My favorite part of this story was the follow-through: I’ve heard from him and he was much happier and had created some fantastic wins in his life.
We all go through hard times. Just keep moving forward. Find small daily wins. Anything. Just keep going.
1
259
Someone take this guys phone from him before he says something even dumber
@MaxJordan_N @DrDiGiorgio
1
1
116
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
The first steps are as follows:
• Break up the vertical integration of healthcare
• Eliminate value-based care and metrics
• Eliminate Medicare Advantage
• Enforce antitrust and Medicare fraud laws against
large insurance companies
• Overturn Stark laws
• Don't allow hospitals and insurance companies
to employ physicians
• Restore private practice
• Restrict insurance policies to catastrophic ones
• Mandate price transparency and let the free market
improve health care
I’ve seen the comments—“What’s your solution?”
Here’s the truth:
I’m not a policy expert. I don’t have a 10-point reform plan.
What I have is anger—rooted in lived experience.
Mine. My colleagues’. My patients’.
I’m angry at both sides:
•Obama for pushing one of the most damaging healthcare laws in modern history.
•Trump for not fixing any of it.
•Republicans for folding to insurers and skipping real reform.
•Democrats for doubling down on bureaucracy and pretending the damage doesn’t exist.
You say, “Don’t be angry.”
But I’m living this every day—fighting payers, watching access crumble, drowning in red tape.
I’m not paid to solve policy policy nor do I claim to be a policy expert…
I’m paid to take care of patients.
You are. And if all you can do is gaslight physicians like me for being angry, I don’t think very highly of your opinions.
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
You’ve mistaken bureaucracy for benevolence and cartel consolidation for care.
Let’s forget the disaster post by your friend Max. I think we have all had enough of that debacle. Let’s just get your points.
1/ You assert private insurance companies “cost more” and “provide less care.” True enough, but only partially.
You omit that they operate within a system shaped, distorted, and reinforced by public policy: tax exclusion of employer-sponsored insurance, CMS-driven fee schedules, and anti-competitive Certificate of Need laws.
The private market has never truly existed in American healthcare. What we have is a state-sanctioned oligopoly, not capitalism.
2/ You invoke UnitedHealthcare as an example of failure, rightly, but neglect to mention its most powerful allies: nonprofit health systems, especially those like @UCLAHealth .
These institutions:
•Receive 3–5x higher Medicare reimbursements than independent practices,
•Pay no federal, state, or property taxes,
Issue tax-exempt municipal bonds,
•Collect tax-deductible donations,
• Dolinate regional markets like robber barons with clerical collars.
United is the villain and the nonprofit health systems are its bishops.
3/ Your call to abolish private insurance entirely rests on a romanticized faith in Medicare. But Medicare is the engine of price distortion:
•It undervalues primary care while overpaying large systems through facility fees.
•It entrenches administrative overhead via MACs and billing codes.
It also created the very Relative Value Scale, which deforms clinical incentives.
To suggest Medicare for All would resolve these issues is to propose the arsonist as fire chief.
4/ On workforce imbalance: you lament our surplus of specialists and shortage of PCPs. Fair critique. But again, who designed the pipeline? The federal government, comprised of Marxist bureaucrats, subsidizes academic centers to train specialists, funds residency slots through Medicare and allows hospitals to capture GME dollars without accountability.
The solution isn’t central planning of physician labor.
It’s exposing the actual cost, value, and demand for services via transparent pricing, something neither public nor private monopolies permit.
5/ You cite Amdahl’s Law to argue that physician salaries are a rounding error. True. But this only strengthens the counterargument: The problem is not the physicians, it’s the system.
A system that:
•Obscures price
•Rewards consolidation
•Penalizes independence
•And spins regulatory complexity into profit
Until that changes, your dream of government controlled, top-down equity , run by non profit health systems will produce the same result as all prior attempts: a bureaucratized empire of mediocrity.
1/ @MaxJordan_N Was raked over the coals for 2 basic truths: 1) high paid proceduralists are paid 5-10x as much as primary care w/o 5-10x the training or value. 2) Medicaid provides lifesaving care. @DrDiGiorgio was thinks vouchers or cash subsidies will cut it as a replacement.
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
I’m not the only doc who has seen vertebral artery dissections after nonsense like this.
These are usually associated awful strokes. The very bad kind. “Aren’t all strokes bad?” Yes. And these are the “very” variety.
Don’t ever let someone manipulate your neck.
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
Just a reminder that a physician’s worst enemy is often other physicians.
(And Dr DiGiorgio is underpaid for the type of work that he does.)
Paul Kraemer MD retweeted
This is how the physicians in Congress have failed us!
Greg has become a congressman who happens to be a physician instead of a physician who happens to be a congressman.
We have to live with terrible health policies, laws, and regulations; we don't need your insults as well! @noahkaufmanmd @BrentAWilliams2 @txsportsdoc @notaproviderMD @DrDiGiorgio @DrJMarine @mass_marion































