Steve Butler retweeted
The whole “free Palestine” rubbish is a Trojan horse. It’s becoming increasingly obvious as time goes on.
It’s an Islamist, anti-West ideology distilled in one movement. One flag. One cause.
It’s sneaky. It convinces Westerners into believing they’re supporting humanitarianism. But it’s built on lies.
In reality, it’s a subversive black hole. A demoralising agent designed to poison our societies with self hatred.
But the horror of this movement is that it doesn’t just sit in the realm of geopolitics—In a war taking place in a region many couldn’t even point to on a map.
No, it attacks the very soul of Western civilisation.
Steve Butler retweeted
ZETEO. Where cancel culture thrives.
According to Zeteo in their guide to “Ranking Celebrity Responses To The Gaza Genocide”, Amy schumer, Jerry Seinfeld and Michael Rappaport are in the UGLY section. Non-Jews like Ed Sheeran and DJ Khaled are in the BAD section for their apparent silence on Gaza.
Also in the ‘silent on Gaza’ BAD section are Po from the Teletubbies, Roland Rat, Basil Brush, Peppa Pig and Paddington Bear. Mehdi is also right that he has never heard Sooty and Sweep say anything about Gaza. The observation that SpongeBob Sqaure Pants seems suspiciously on the fence, also bang on.
Well done Zeteo & Mehdi Hasan with their deep dive exposé on these morally bankrupt children’s TV charlatans. May we never see them on our screens again.
We note with interest that Bungle from Rainbow was unavailable for comment.
On a separate note, I am fully behind the urgent Owen Jones recommendation that Bruce Forsythe should be exhumed to see what he thinks.
Steve Butler retweeted
Socialists discovered that corporations have too much power and proposed merging your employer, landlord and grocery store into one institution with a police force and military.
Steve Butler retweeted
The only lives improved by this motion were those of the handful of activists pushing it who got a rush of happy hormones when it passed.
This is the problem with having that kind of democracy. It ends up promoting the views and interests of only those who are personally inclined and able to put in the time and put up with what can be boring, overwhelming and downright unpleasant events. It rules out people busy with caring responsibilities and demanding jobs, the money and time poor and obviously the 99,9% of the population who simply can’t think of anything worse to do with their weekend than pack into a hall like sardines with shouty, emotionally volatile people. All to vote on something that will have zero impact on their lives or the world.
Steve Butler retweeted
People who genuinely believe that a single democratic Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine is a solution to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict are completely delusional and detached from reality.
Steve Butler retweeted
Replying to @PhilipProudfoot
Zionism, of course, pre dates Theodor Herzl you clown, and Jews have historically prayed towards the land of Israel for around 3/4000 years!
Steve Butler retweeted
Britain Is Sleepwalking Into Lebanon.
Lebanon did not fall overnight. It was once the most cosmopolitan, pluralist state in the Arab world. Beirut was the Paris of the Middle East. A functioning democracy. A free press. A Christian majority that built a nation generous enough to welcome those who came. It believed that openness would be met with openness. That tolerance would be reciprocated. That good faith was a universal language. It wasn't. It never is.
The Palestinians arrived after 1948 and in their hundreds of thousands after 1970, expelled from Jordan with their militias intact. The Lebanese state, too timid to enforce its own sovereignty, allowed armed factions to operate as a state within a state. Then Iran exported its revolution westward and Hezbollah was born, funded from Tehran, running its own hospitals, schools, courts and welfare networks. It made the Lebanese state optional for an entire community. Every accommodation encouraged the next demand. Every retreat was read as weakness, because it was.
The civil war that followed lasted fifteen years and killed 150,000 people. But the war was merely the violent expression of something that had already happened. The state had lost its monopoly on violence. Communities had retreated into armed confessional blocs. The centre had hollowed out. Lebanon was already two countries sharing a flag but not a future.
The Christians didn't lose because they were cruel. They lost because they were naive. They believed demographic generosity could be squared with political stability. They believed armed factions could be absorbed into a civic order. Power follows population. Identity hardens under pressure. Every community with a coherent creed will eventually act on its interests. The moral high ground is not a defence. In Lebanon it became a grave marker.
Now look at Britain.
Since 2018, boats have arrived on the Kent coast carrying tens of thousands of men, the overwhelming majority unvetted and undocumented, from Iran, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Eritrea. They are housed and supported at public expense while the state performs the pantomime of processing them. Anyone who raises the subject is accused of racism before the sentence is finished. This is not immigration. It is the progressive dissolution of Britain's right to determine who enters its own territory.
The parallel institutions are already here. Sharia courts operating alongside civil law. Educational environments teaching loyalty to the Ummah rather than to Britain. Areas where policing is negotiation, investigations are quietly dropped, and the state modifies its own behaviour for fear of communal reaction. In Lebanon they called it accommodation. They kept calling it accommodation right up until the checkpoints went up.
The electoral bloc pressure is already here. Candidates selected on the basis of foreign conflicts. Representatives answering to communal leaderships rather than constituents. The institutional failure is already here. The Charity Commission investigated the Islamic Centre of England for three years. Little changed. Universities host vigils for mass murderers and hold nobody accountable. Prevent is applied selectively. Everyone knows it. Nobody says it.
Lebanon did not collapse because its enemies were strong. It collapsed because its institutions were weak. Because it confused tolerance with the abandonment of standards. Because it believed the centre would hold without anyone holding it. Britain is not Lebanon yet. But Lebanon wasn't Lebanon yet, once. It drifted. Demographics shifted. Parallel loyalties hardened. The state lost the nerve to enforce a single standard of law. Bit by bit the centre hollowed out.
We are drifting. The question is whether anyone in authority will admit it. Before the drift becomes a current too strong to swim against.
"Power follows population. Identity hardens under pressure. Every community with a coherent creed will eventually act on its interests."
Steve Butler retweeted
This is dispiriting. My immediate thoughts reflect that. In fact, this is the biggest missed opportunity in Yookay politics that nobody will talk about, and the most damning indictment of our political discourse that nobody will consider. How many times have we complained that there is a lack of seriousness in politics, that the political class has become critically unmoored from what the people want, and that the country needs are policies that are radical yet carefully considered?
Well, here we had an insurgent party that actually matched the views of a plurality of voters, that took the time to do proper research and present brave policies, and that was led by somebody whose views were drawn from deeply considered first principles; who saw things with a clear eye as they were rather than what the SW1 NPC Narrative claimed; who wanted to engage in serious and proper debate; and who seemed above the focus-group refined soundbites and shouty, student common room pie-throwing contest that passes for politics in this country now.
And what did he get for the hard yards he put in? Nothing.
I found the Clacton by-election hugely affecting -- sometimes wretchedly dispiriting and sometimes radicalising. To be clear, nobody deserves a political platform: they must earn it. But it was a terrible shock to see the media in unison push Binface as a sort of public school yah boo sucks jape that would allow them to slap a cream pie in Farage's face; but where the joke was really on the voters in one of the poorest and most disenfranchised constituencies in England. There was, after all, at least one serious politician standing against Reform.
William's reign at the SDP was a chance to improve British politics. To show that insurgent parties weren't all shouty golf club yahoos or callow, Keffiyeh-wearing, third-generation Crypto-Trots for whom Israel seemed to be as important as the NHS or schooling. To keep the mainstream parties honest by foregrounding ideas from outside the Westminster bubble. Instead, it was studiously ignored (I suspect, but cannot prove, that I am correct to use that adverb).
Peter Hitchens has said that William Clouston's resignation is 'a pity'. I think it's more damning than that. It seems to me that people like him are aggressively extruded from the mainstream parties, and simply ignored outside it. What chance is there for national recovery, or to avoid the emergence of dangerous demagogues when the big crisis eventually hits (which it increasingly looks as though it will), if we exclude voices like this?
Look, it's true that I am a supporter of the SDP that William built. I agreed with most of their platform. I liked many of the people there, who were engaged, concerned citizens of the best sort, and who were refreshingly normal, decent people (not necessarily a given in the world of political activism). I also liked William very much. I found him friendly, generous and wise. He was a stoic (in the philosophical sense) and far more intelligent than many people realise -- and certainly more than me, which is something that is always engaging. So perhaps people will say that I *would* write all this, given my personal feelings. And I understand that. Yet I do think that his resignation represents a lamentable missed chance for something better, and terrible indictment of our politics.
I should also thank William for all his hard work in giving politically homeless people like myself some comradeship and hope, and wish him all the best. If ever somebody was suited to a position in the House of Lords, William is. Perhaps Lord Owen of Plymouth might finally like a companion on the social democrat benches after all these years of being alone.
Steve Butler retweeted
If Jvnior is a low IQ cuck with a tiny penis, repost this.
I’m testing something important.
Steve Butler retweeted
No, they really don't. I don't think you understand the word "deliberately" and "in part."
"Deliberately" means that the intended harm be the destruction of the protected group, in whole or in part.
This is the dolus specialis standard that is found in the first part of the Convention. Meaning you must prove, fully conclusively, that the intended harm be the at least in part destruction of the group. And to infer it requires that there be no other reasonable explanation (only reasonable inference test). In Gaza, you cannot establish that it is the only reasonable inference to be genocidal intent unless you were to assess the totality of the evidence, which requires assessing the conduct of Hamas as a belligerent and how it informs Israeli conduct. Not one accusation has done this.
As a demonstration of the requirements of the law, see below:
Bosnia v. Serbia (2007) para. 373: “The dolus specialis, the specific intent to destroy the group in whole or in part, has to be convincingly shown by reference to particular circumstances, unless a general plan to that end can be convincingly demonstrated to exist; and for a pattern of conduct to be accepted as evidence of its existence, it would have to be that it could only point (emphasis added) to the existence of such intent.”
ICTY Tolimir Appeal Chamber para. 745: "Indications of such intent are rarely overt, however, and thus it is permissible to infer the existence of genocidal intent based on “all of the evidence, taken together”, as long as this inference is “the only reasonable [one] available on the evidence” (emphasis added). Factors relevant to this analysis may include the general context, the perpetration of other culpable acts systematically directed against the same group, the scale of atrocities, the systematic targeting of victims on account of their membership in a particular group, or the repetition of destructive and discriminatory acts. The existence of a plan or policy, a perpetrator’s display of his intent through public speeches or meetings with others may also support an inference that the perpetrator had formed the requisite specific intent."
"In part" requires substantiality that is so numerous that it threatens the existence of the whole.
As a demonstration of the requirements of the law, see below:
ICTY Krstić Appeal Chamber para. 8: "It is well established that where a conviction for genocide relies on the intent to destroy a protected group “in part,” the part must be a substantial part of that group. The aim of the Genocide Convention is to prevent the intentional destruction of entire human groups, and the part targeted must be significant enough to have an impact on the group as a whole. Although the Appeals Chamber has not yet addressed this issue, two Trial Chambers of this Tribunal have examined it. In Jelisić, the first case to confront the question, the Trial Chamber noted that, “[g]iven the goal of the [Genocide] Convention to deal with mass crimes, it is widely acknowledged that the intention to destroy must target at least a substantial part of the group.” The same conclusion was reached by the Sikirica Trial Chamber: “This part of the definition calls for evidence of an intention to destroy a substantial number relative to the total population of the group.” As these Trial Chambers explained, the substantiality requirement both captures genocide’s defining character as a crime of massive proportions and reflects the Convention’s concern with the impact the destruction of the targeted part will have on the overall survival of the group (emphasis added)."
Ibid. para. 10: "This interpretation is supported by scholarly opinion. The early commentators on the Genocide Convention emphasized that the term “in part” contains a substantiality requirement. Raphael Lemkin, a prominent international criminal lawyer who coined the term “genocide” and was instrumental in the drafting of the Genocide Convention, addressed the issue during the 1950 debate in the United States Senate on the ratification of the Convention. Lemkin explained that “the destruction in part must be of a substantial nature so as to affect the entirety.” (emphasis added) He further suggested that the Senate clarify, in a statement of understanding to accompany the ratification, that “the Convention applies only to actions undertaken on a mass scale.” Another noted early commentator, Nehemiah Robinson, echoed this view, explaining that a perpetrator of genocide must possess the intent to destroy a substantial number of individuals constituting the targeted group. In discussing this requirement, Robinson stressed, as did Lemkin, that “the act must be directed toward the destruction of a group,” this formulation being the aim of the Convention." (emphasis added)
Ibid. para. 12: "The intent requirement of genocide under Article 4 of the Statute is therefore satisfied where evidence shows that the alleged perpetrator intended to destroy at least a substantial part of the protected group. The determination of when the targeted part is substantial enough to meet this requirement may involve a number of considerations. The numeric size of the targeted part of the group is the necessary and important starting point, though not in all cases the ending point of the inquiry. The number of individuals targeted should be evaluated not only in absolute terms, but also in relation to the overall size of the entire group. (emphasis added) In addition to the numeric size of the targeted portion, its prominence within the group can be a useful consideration. If a specific part of the group is emblematic of the overall group, or is essential to its survival, that may support a finding that the part qualifies as substantial within the meaning of Article 4."
To determine what constitutes the area we need to look at ibid. para. 13: "The historical examples of genocide also suggest that the area of the perpetrators’ activity and control, as well as the possible extent of their reach, should be considered (emphasis added). Nazi Germany may have intended only to eliminate Jews within Europe alone; that ambition probably did not extend, even at the height of its power, to an undertaking of that enterprise on a global scale. Similarly, the perpetrators of genocide in Rwanda did not seriously contemplate the elimination of the Tutsi population beyond the country’s borders. The intent to destroy formed by a perpetrator of genocide will always be limited by the opportunity presented to him. While this factor alone will not indicate whether the targeted group is substantial, it can - in combination with other factors - inform the analysis."
In the ICTY Sikirica Trial Chamber decision, para. 72, they stated: "For the purpose of determining the number of victims within the terms of Article 4(2)(a), (b) and (c), one is, therefore, left with a number of approximately 1000-1400 Muslims out of a total of 49,351 in the Prijedor municipality. This would represent between
2% and 2.8% of the Muslims in the Prijedor municipality and would hardly qualify as a “reasonably substantial” part of the Bosnian Muslim group in Prijedor (emphasis added). It also needs to be borne in mind that not all the detainees at Keraterm were Muslims."
In Gaza, as of today, 73,335 people have reportedly been killed per the Palestinian Ministry of Health. Included in that are about 25,000 belligerents (we're going to choose to ignore this for the time being). The pre-war population of Gaza was 2,230,000. Through the entirety of the Palestinian population in which Israel holds effective control it is 5,500,000.
That gives us a look into nearly three years of war about substantiality, so let's take a look at both Gaza specific and the entirety of the Palestinian population (since Israel holds effective control of both).
Gaza: 3.28%
Totality: 1.33%
So, we can now do the legal analysis for "in part" destruction of Palestinians. This is similar to Sikirica in which about 3% or less has been killed in the area of control. In Sikirica the ICTY Trial Chamber found this to "hardly qualify as 'reasonably substantial' part of the Bosnian Muslim population in Prijedor. The reason for this is that it didn't affect the ability of the whole to survive within Prijedor. Like in Prijedor and Sikirica we see about 3% killed compared to the whole of Gaza. Unlike in Sikirica, under the totality of control the killed population is 1.33% which is substantially less than what was found in Prijedor to not constitute genocide.
Because about 3% does not constitute threaten the existence of the group as a whole, it cannot be substantial enough to constitute "in part" destruction of the group. Thus, there is not "in part" destruction of the Palestinian population in Gaza, let alone the entirety of the area of control.
Now, it is clear that there needs to be a full analysis of the only reasonable inference test. This requires assessing the totality of the evidence and facts. We know that Hamas does not distinguish in combat, meaning they do not wear uniforms. We also know that Hamas has weaponized civilian infrastructure including homes, mosques, schools, even UN facilities. We further know that Hamas has weaponized healthcare facilities, this can be demonstrated by the piece of evidence in the original UN COI report accusing Israel of genocide where the report mentions the bombing of a tunnel at the European hospital. The European hospital tunnel was the same tunnel, and the same bombing, that killed Mohammed Sinwar. Mohammed Sinwar was directing the war from that tunnel. The Geneva Conventions have trigger conditions in which these places lose their protections, subject to proportionality, and we know that these trigger conditions have occurred in Gaza as caused by Hamas due to their tunnels (GCIV 28 & API 51(7)), diversion of aid (GCIV 23), weaponization of healthcare infrastructure (GCIV 19). Meaning, we have law on point stipulating that there is a reasonable alternative explanation other than genocide because the trigger conditions have been met.
Further, this also demonstrates a demonstration of reasonable alternative explanations other than genocide. Which means that the only reasonable inference cannot be genocide, which fails the only reasonable inference test.
Because it fails the only reasonable inference test it cannot be, per the law, that the dolus specialis requirement has been met through inference to intent.
Thus, you cannot establish that the intent requirement for genocide has been met.
Essentially, @sparklenaloha, I think I know the law on this extremely well, unlike you. And the ICJ's jurisprudence would preclude a finding of genocide, just as Amnesty stated in their report on page 101: "However, its rulings on inferring intent can be read extremely narrowly, in a manner that would potentially preclude a state from having genocidal intent alongside one or more additional motives or goals in relation to the conduct of its military operations."
Steve Butler retweeted
Replying to @owenjonesjourno @ZackPolanski
This is embarrassing. You haven’t read it.
Steve Butler retweeted
Following the horrific murder of Henry Novak, the name Kriss Donald has come up.
Many don’t know what happened to Kriss. And they certainly don’t have an update on his convicted murderers. You might be surprised by this.
This all makes me rather angry. Hold on to your seat and here we go…
On 15 March 2004, 15 year old Kriss was walking with a friend, Jamie Wallace, on Kenmure Street in Glasgow.
A silver Mercedes with five men (led by Imran Shahid) pulled up and grabbed Kriss and his friend. Jamie managed to escape but Kriss was forced into the car.
So what had Kriss done to upset these men? Absolutely nothing. Imran and his group of Pakistani thugs had been in an altercation with some other white men earlier at a nightclub. They were angry and picked on a random (and innocent) white boy to have their revenge.
The gang drove him around for hours in the car before they took him to a secluded spot by the river. There they held his arms while they stabbed him 13 times, causing severe internal injuries - to a lung, the liver and a kidney.
At this point, poor Kriss was already dying from blood loss but he was still fighting to stay alive.
These horrific human beings then doused him in petrol and set him on fire. Kriss rolled on the floor, trying to extinguish the flame, but ultimately he died from blood loss and the impact of the burning.
His body was found the next day.
Some of the suspects fled to Pakistan but were eventually brought back to face justice for this barbaric racially motivated and heinous murder.
So what happened to the five men?
Imran Shahid (ringleader): he received life imprisonment, minimum 25 years. He has been as much of a bully inside prison as he was on the outside and has an additional 20 months added to his sentence for an assault when in prison. He also pretended to convert to Judaism so he can have better food and has sued the prison service over wanting a penis pump and having his Xbox removed (it was feared he was using it to access the internet). He is able to apply for parole in 2031
Zeeshan Shahid (his brother): received a life sentence with a 23 years minimum. Eligible for parole in 2029.
Mohammed Faisal Mushtaq; received a life sentence with a 22 years minimum. Eligible for parole in 2028/2029.
Daanish Zahid: received a life sentence with a minimum of 17 years but he also got an additional sentence for 6 years for lying to the court. He is eligible for parole in 2027 and there have been exploratory discussions for work placements/community work on his release.
Zahid Mohammed was part of the kidnapping but left the group before the stabbing and burning. He received only 5 years and was set free after only 2.5 years. He then changed his name to Yusef Harris and was back in prison for 4 years in 2017 after he threatened to murder someone, was found carrying a knife and drove a car at a police officer. He is now free and nobody knows where he is.
By 2031, most, if not all, of these menacing and violent men could be back on the streets in the UK.
Kriss deserved better.
Steve Butler retweeted
This one will require a stiff drink.
In the early 1990s, the government came up with a clever idea. Instead of borrowing money cheaply to build hospitals, schools, and roads, it would get the private sector to build them and then pay the private sector back over 25 to 30 years. The Private Finance Initiative. PFI.
The attraction was obvious. You got a shiny new hospital today. The bill didn't show up on the government's books. The cost was deferred into the future. Politicians got ribbon-cutting ceremonies without the awkward conversation about borrowing.
It was, in effect, the nation's credit card. Buy now, pay later. Except the interest rate was extraordinary.
The total capital value of everything built under PFI was around £50 billion. As of March 2024, there were 665 PFI contracts still running across the UK, with roughly £136 billion in remaining payments stretching out to the early 2050s. These are payments public bodies are contractually locked into. Hospitals, schools, councils, government departments. Paying for buildings that in many cases were constructed twenty or thirty years ago.
And the terms are extraordinary.
PFI contracts were structured so the private sector would not just build the facility but manage its services. Cleaning. Maintenance. Catering. Portering. These services are bundled into long-term contracts with built-in inflation increases that the public sector cannot renegotiate, cannot exit without paying massive penalties, and often cannot even fully scrutinise because of commercial confidentiality clauses.
In one case raised in Parliament, a hospital was charged £333 to change a lightbulb. That isn't an urban myth. It was cited in Hansard.
The NHS has been hit hardest.
According to parliamentary analysis, the capital cost of NHS PFI projects was around £13 billion. The total repayments are estimated at around £80 billion. And the peak of NHS PFI annual repayments isn't even here yet. It arrives in 2029. The bills are still going up.
In 2020-21, NHS trusts paid £457 million purely in interest charges on PFI contracts. Not services. Not maintenance. Interest. In the last five years, NHS trusts have handed over more than £1.8 billion in PFI interest alone. We Own It calculates that money would have covered the starting salaries of over 50,000 new doctors.
One NHS trust, Essex Partnership, has reportedly paid back 27 times what was originally borrowed. Some hospitals are spending more on PFI repayments than on medicines for patients. And remember, these repayments come out of the same NHS budget that's supposed to fund patient care, staff, and equipment.
Scotland got it just as badly. Audit Scotland reported that Scottish taxpayers will pay a cumulative £40 billion for PFI assets worth just £9 billion. North Ayrshire Council will have paid £440 million by 2038 for four schools that cost £83 million to build.
Now here's what makes this worse.
Many of these contracts are starting to expire. The buildings are being handed back to the public sector. And the NAO has warned of significant risks around the handback process, including cases where public bodies were dissatisfied with the condition of assets being returned to them. Decades of payments. And some of these buildings may come back needing significant further investment.
So what actually happened?
The government could have borrowed money at significantly lower rates to build these hospitals and schools itself. Sovereign borrowing has always been cheaper than private finance. Instead, it paid the private sector to borrow at a premium and passed the inflated cost on to the taxpayer. The private sector took the profit. The taxpayer took the risk. The buildings are now ageing. The debts are still being paid. And the services that were supposed to benefit are being squeezed partly because so much of their budget is locked into contractual obligations they cannot escape.
PFI wasn't investment. It was an accounting trick. A way for governments to build things without the borrowing showing up in the national debt figures. It made politicians look fiscally responsible while loading future generations with obligations they had no say in and no ability to renegotiate.
Both parties did this. The Conservatives created PFI in 1992. Labour massively expanded it after 1997. More than 700 projects were signed. The coalition eventually wound it down. The current government scrapped the latest version. But the contracts remain. The payments continue. And the damage is already done.
This is what it looks like when a country chooses to buy its infrastructure on hire purchase instead of investing properly. You lock in above-market rates for decades. You lose control of the assets. You tie the hands of future governments. And when the bill keeps coming due, you're told there's no money for doctors, teachers, or social care.
There was always money. It just went somewhere else.
Steve Butler retweeted
🇬🇧 Green Party Leader Zack Polanski REFUSES to condemn ABORTION up until birth and non-stun slaughter when confronted in Norwich whilst campaigning.
Under heavy questioning he tells VP Journalist @WillColeshill to "Piss Off" for asking questions.
Steve Butler retweeted
Replying to @narindertweets
So you’re saying people shouldn’t just enter countries uninvited?
Steve Butler retweeted
Is this a joke? You branded Leeds Rabbi Zecharia Deutsch a "creep", a "lowlife" and an "animal" after the Oct 7 attacks in a now deleted video. He was later forced into hiding with his family. You used an image of yourself and Bob "Death, death to the IDF" Vylan as your FB profile picture (after Glastonbury). Your response to the Hamas terror attack, which killed some 1,200 people, was: "White supremacist european settler colonialism must end!". We see you.
My thoughts and prayers are with all those injured in today’s attack at a synagogue on Yom Kippur, and with the wider Jewish community who will be feeling deeply shaken.
No one should feel unsafe in their place of worship.
At moments like this, it’s important that we do not rush to conclusions or allow fear and division to take hold. Violence only fuels more violence — and we must all work to calm tensions, stand together, and reaffirm our shared commitment to peace and solidarity.
instagram.com/p/DPTgPKFiMyS/…
Steve Butler retweeted
Replying to @AdnanHussainMP
So you disagree with @FUDdaily arrest over this meme as well then, Adnan?
Steve Butler retweeted
Before lamenting the likely terrorism designation of Palestine Action, allow me to offer a dose of real-world context, something the communist journalist in question seems to lack entirely when it comes to understanding how the world of national security operates.
I spent a decade working within the UK’s security and intelligence services, and another decade and a half alongside colleagues from those same institutions in the strategic security and geopolitical field. So, let me break this down plainly.
In the UK, protest movements - from BLM-UK to Just Stop Oil to Extinction Rebellion - are tolerated within a certain bandwidth. You can storm art galleries, block roads, disrupt university lectures, even egg the occasional minister. Annoying? Yes. Criminal? Often. Terrorist? Not quite.
But there are red lines.
The UK armed forces, intelligence agencies (MI5, MI6, GCHQ), and security installations are not in the same category. These are not symbolic targets for radical theatrics, they are sovereign infrastructure. Step one foot on a military base, attempt sabotage (even symbolic), and you’re no longer seen as a protester. You’re viewed as someone testing national defense readiness, someone who may have just published a blueprint that other actors with far deadlier intentions might exploit.
Palestine Action didn’t just throw paint. They breached a military site. They gave out manuals. They demonstrated vulnerability. The state isn’t reacting to a protest, it’s reacting to a national security threat that others may now mimic, with explosives instead of spray cans.
Crossing into those domains changes the equation entirely.
So, yes, break into Barclays or Elbit Systems offices, expect arrest. Break into a military installation, expect a terrorism file to be opened.
That’s how it works. And if you don’t understand that, then you’re not ready for this conversation.
To my colleagues in the UK media –
You may not agree with Palestine Action’s tactics, messaging, or political objectives. You may think protestors in general are noisy, irritating, and uncouth. Indeed, you may think the same of me! But all of us who work in UK journalism, in any capacity, should be horrified by the government’s proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist group. It goes far beyond holding a protest group criminally liable for their activities. It makes it illegal to express support for them, in any capacity, under the threat of up to 14 years imprisonment.
Our work as journalists is built on the bedrock of legally protected free expression. But there’s no journalistic exemption to the Terrorism Act 2000. Let’s imagine that one of your colleagues, after this week, writes an opinion piece arguing that Palestine Action are brave and heroic, that they were part of a long tradition of non-violent direct action that includes the Suffragettes and the Greenham Common Women's Peace Camp.
You may disagree with the points they make. That’s fine – since when did everyone in the media get along?
But do you think they should be arrested? Do you think their house should be raided, work devices seized, that they should face prosecution and jail time? Because that is what the law allows for.
Perhaps you think this is unlikely. But already, journalists have been investigated under the Terrorism Act. One journalist reporting on Palestine had his home raided by police despite never being arrested or charged with an offence. He was targeted with sweeping warrants that granted police access to journalistic and legally privileged material, which were later ruled unlawful by the court. If one journalist can have their home raided by police under counter-terror powers, so can any of us.
I don’t think that free expression is a privilege that belongs solely to the media class. I don’t think that a teenager wearing a Palestine Action t-shirt should face arrest either. I don’t think someone conveying positive sentiments about the group to their friends should have to worry about prosecution. And I think that, when many ordinary people choose not to comply with the state’s restrictions on expressing support for Palestine Action after it’s proscribed, it is our moral obligation as journalists and media workers to back them up any way we can.
It doesn’t matter if you work for The Guardian or The Sun, Novara Media or The Telegraph, the BBC or GB News. The proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist group is an unprecedented infringement on free expression. Every single one of us in the media, no matter our political affiliations, must stand firmly in opposition to it.
Steve Butler retweeted
I performed at Glastonbury twice back when it was a music festival, not a Nuremberg rally. The same pricks cheering Bob Vylan + Kneecap’s “artistic freedom” got me banned from festivals and wrote vicious hit pieces branding me a nazi + transphobe to trash my career. The hypocrisy makes me wanna puke




































