First, they complain that Muslims send their kids to madrassas and not secular schools.
Then when you do send them to schools and they do particularly well, you complain that they are doing too well.
Maybe now they should gerrymander medical seats like how they gerrymandered legislative constituencies.
In recent years, Muslim kids in Assam have been doing exceptionally well in medical entrance examinations.
Himanta Biswa Sarma says that, as Chief Minister, what pains him the most is the day when the medical entrance examination results are placed before him.
Dear @himantabiswa , stop this imaginary “clash of civilisations” nonsense. Let the kids study and coexist peacefully.
You have already screwed up so many things. Please spare the children of this country!
1
4
729
subalterndesi retweeted
Intelligent commentary, IMHO.
Also, food for thought for some Pakistanis who think that their ability to have Indian-Congressi friends is a path to dialogue & normalization.
Urban mainstream in India is not interested, even if they swoon over Abu Bakar & Dar-e-Nizaat & so on.
I very much believe that IK is in abhorrent circumstances but it's not in his nature to beg for relief or exhibit weakness.
Even in death, he would be a martyr.
Replying to @BrSalmanSafdar
مجھے اس خط میں چار مسئلے لگ رہے ہیں۔ جس سے شک گزرتا ہے کہ کچھ خط سے نکالا گیا ہے یعنی omit کیا گیا ہے اور کچھ تبدیل کیا گیا ہے۔ جب تک خان صاحب بہنوں کے ساتھ ملاقات میں اس کے متن کی تائید نہ کر دیں ہمیں بہت احتیاط کرنی چاہیے۔ وجوہات آپ کو معلوم ہیں۔
1۔ خان صاحب نے فقط جیل حکام کی زیادتیوں کا تذکرہ کیا ہے۔ جبکہ بہنوں کے ساتھ ملاقات میں خان صاحب نام لیتے ہیں کہ کون ان زیادتیوں کا ذمہدار ہے۔
2۔ حالات جیسے بھی ہوں مجھے یہ بات ماننے میں تامل ہے کہ خان صاحب کہیں گے کہ مجھے نہيں لگتا میں جیل سے زندہ باہر آؤں گا۔ یہ بات خان صاحب کے ایمان کے خلاف ہے۔ وہ ہمیشہ چیزوں کا روشن پہلو دیکھتے ہیں۔ ہمیشہ فتح کی بات کرتے ہیں۔ ہار ان کی ڈکشنری میں نہيں ہے۔
3۔ خط میں بار بار وہ اپنی ذہنی صحت کا ذکر کرتے ہیں۔ لیکن خط کا متن ایک ذہنی طور پر مکمل صحتمند انسان کا ہے۔ خان صاحب اس طرح نہيں سوچتے۔ نہ کمزوری دکھاتے ہیں۔ یہ چیز قابل ہضم نہيں ہے۔
4۔ ایک عالی ظرف انسان اور ایک فداکار شوہر کے طور پر خان صاحب اپنی زوجہ کی صحت اور سلامتی کو اپنی صحت و سلامتی سے مقدم خیال کریں گے لیکن کبھی یہ نہيں کہیں گے کہ جج صاحب میں تو اب مایوس ہو چکا ہوں اس لئے میری زوجہ کو ریلیف مہیا کیجئے۔ مجھئ ریلیف کی یا انصاف کی ضرورت نہیں ہے۔ خان صاحب انصاف طلب کریں گے کیونکہ یہ ان کا حق ہے۔
1
5
1,132
This clearly does not communicate what I wanted to say.
Pakistani populace has no appetite for conflict with with a belligerent India. The Pakistan state too does not have the capacity or desire to engage in conflict on three fronts. So their positioning shall remain defensive. There is no room for protracted conflict b/w two nuclear powers.
However, the Pakistani state will not really back down from its position on Kashmir, which India keeps haughtily insisting is a unilateral matter.
As the May 2025 escalation show, you are surrounded by China and its allies on 3 fronts. If you want to reduce and eliminate the threat on your western border, you would have to come on the negotiating table and find a solution on Kashmir.
A prosperous South Asia is in the interests of all.
"No military conflicts with India for the next 20-30 years"
This is basically the fundamental ideology of Muslims. They dont war not because war is bad, but because they are weak right now in every parameter. They want to gain power first and then attack India with full might.
All those low IQs in India who wish normal relations with an economically stable Pak must understand this.
3
3
1,501
subalterndesi retweeted
Replying to @BrSalmanSafdar
مجھے اس خط میں چار مسئلے لگ رہے ہیں۔ جس سے شک گزرتا ہے کہ کچھ خط سے نکالا گیا ہے یعنی omit کیا گیا ہے اور کچھ تبدیل کیا گیا ہے۔ جب تک خان صاحب بہنوں کے ساتھ ملاقات میں اس کے متن کی تائید نہ کر دیں ہمیں بہت احتیاط کرنی چاہیے۔ وجوہات آپ کو معلوم ہیں۔
1۔ خان صاحب نے فقط جیل حکام کی زیادتیوں کا تذکرہ کیا ہے۔ جبکہ بہنوں کے ساتھ ملاقات میں خان صاحب نام لیتے ہیں کہ کون ان زیادتیوں کا ذمہدار ہے۔
2۔ حالات جیسے بھی ہوں مجھے یہ بات ماننے میں تامل ہے کہ خان صاحب کہیں گے کہ مجھے نہيں لگتا میں جیل سے زندہ باہر آؤں گا۔ یہ بات خان صاحب کے ایمان کے خلاف ہے۔ وہ ہمیشہ چیزوں کا روشن پہلو دیکھتے ہیں۔ ہمیشہ فتح کی بات کرتے ہیں۔ ہار ان کی ڈکشنری میں نہيں ہے۔
3۔ خط میں بار بار وہ اپنی ذہنی صحت کا ذکر کرتے ہیں۔ لیکن خط کا متن ایک ذہنی طور پر مکمل صحتمند انسان کا ہے۔ خان صاحب اس طرح نہيں سوچتے۔ نہ کمزوری دکھاتے ہیں۔ یہ چیز قابل ہضم نہيں ہے۔
4۔ ایک عالی ظرف انسان اور ایک فداکار شوہر کے طور پر خان صاحب اپنی زوجہ کی صحت اور سلامتی کو اپنی صحت و سلامتی سے مقدم خیال کریں گے لیکن کبھی یہ نہيں کہیں گے کہ جج صاحب میں تو اب مایوس ہو چکا ہوں اس لئے میری زوجہ کو ریلیف مہیا کیجئے۔ مجھئ ریلیف کی یا انصاف کی ضرورت نہیں ہے۔ خان صاحب انصاف طلب کریں گے کیونکہ یہ ان کا حق ہے۔
subalterndesi retweeted
Indian politicians control their people’s simple, unquestioning minds by painting a simplistic picture of all of Pakistan as “terrorists.” That view is rooted in tribalism.
subalterndesi retweeted
Indeed , they keep portraying Pakistan as a threat to keep People from questioning what china is doing , how china has left india way behind .
subalterndesi retweeted
The oath is fictional. The Janissaries never swore such an oath. This originates from an 1884 poem by Seyyid Mir Hamza Nigârî, an Azerbaijani Sufi sheikh, written nearly 60 years after the Janissary Corps was abolished. His views on Muawiyah also diverged from the traditional position of Ahl al-Sunnah wa’l-Jama‘ah.
In short, history is not learnt from a TV series which is 90% fictional, history is learnt from the works of historians and the sources.
Kerala seems like the only sane place in this hellhole of a subcontinent.
India is so unused to normal human beings as leaders that this goes viral.
Meanwhile Mallu Sanghis were mocking VDS for not being invited to some big elite wedding event, like other South CMs. (Which should be obvious, no normal Kerala CM would be, they are all middle class)
1
277
subalterndesi retweeted
İslam dünyası Güney ve Kuzey İslamı diye ikiye ayrılır aslında. Kuzey İslam anlayışı Balkanlardan başlar, Türkiye, İran üzerinden Orta Asya’ya kadar uzanır.
Hanefi-Maturidi çizgide Alici bir Sünnilik vardır. Tasavvuf, gelenek, görenek ve kültüre işlenmiştir. Muaviye sevilmez. Yezid’e lanet edilir. Hz.Ali cenknâmeleri okunur. Hasan ve Hüseyin için yas tutulur. Bunu güney islam anlayışı anlamaz.
Anadolu’da tamamen Alici bir sünnilik hakimdir.
subalterndesi retweeted
Pakistan and India pulling each other down serves neither. While China strategically avoids unnecessary military entanglements and focuses on consolidating its economic and geopolitical leverage, we keep falling for the egos of a few, perpetuating a cycle of jingoism and strategic miscalculation at the expense of regional stability and human well being.
subalterndesi retweeted
Alhamdulilah Panjabis have started answering the Lahori and Urdu speakers back!
Those days are gone when Lahoris and Karachi walas used to abuse Panjab - Now we respond back Brutally
subalterndesi retweeted
when pakistanis and indians talk about how different they are, unless they give real evidence i ignore them. religion aside, the south asian ppls have a lot of practices in common which are totally rare in places like the mid east. e.g., compare to iran below
subalterndesi retweeted
On why the "Lashkari Zaban" theory about #Urdu's linguistic origins is totally wrong, here's a brief, helpful piece by Dr Rauf Parekh:
dawn.com/news/681263
This erroneous theory relating to Urdu's linguistic history has been debunked a long time ago by scholars, but it is still peddled out to Pakistan's school children. Urdu schoolteachers need to correct this in their teaching.
Here's the full recording, with chapter edits:
youtube.com/watch?v=f4oTPt0p…
The international English press often struggles to understand the political and linguistic reasons behind #Urdu's prominence in #Pakistan, despite it not being the mother tongue of the vast majority of Pakistanis. My English-language podcast, with the Britain-based platform #TalkAway, seeks to address these questions and give international audiences and second- and third-generation Pakistanis in the diaspora direct access to the discussion.
"Is Urdu dying? Roman Urdu, English and Pakistan's other Languages"
Guest: Zahra Sabri, historian and Urdu scholar
Host: Fakhar Anwar Safeer (@ibneanwer)
Urdu is the mother tongue of fewer than one in ten Pakistanis, yet it is the link language for a huge number of people. Many young people type it in English letters, and many parents abroad hear their children answer back in English. So is Urdu fading, thriving, or pushing Pakistan's other languages aside, from #Punjabi and #Sindhi to the endangered languages of Gilgit-Baltistan?
Chapters:
00:00 Preview and Opening: Pakistan's national language, by the numbers
11:49 Is Urdu actually dying?
12:30 Should Punjabi be Pakistan's link language?
15:47 Is any language more elegant? Urdu and Punjabi
18:48 How the British made Urdu official
25:45 Why is this conversation in English?
27:41 Typing Urdu: from DOS to #ChatGPT
30:32 Is Roman Urdu killing the Urdu script?
35:35 Does Urdu survive only on WhatsApp?
40:53 Why do parents encourage English?
45:34 Kids in #Bradford answering in a Yorkshire accent
50:38 Can a child think in half a language?
53:26 #Lahore, #Islamabad and : who speaks what?
56:12 Why did Pakistan choose Urdu?
57:53 Do we need one national language? Switzerland
1:02:04 1948, #Jinnah and the #Bengali language
1:06:16 Will some of Pakistan's languages disappear? Gilgit-Baltistan
1:07:36 More Punjabi than Urdu in the UK
1:08:46 Mother-tongue education and Pakistan's school systems
1:23:57 Devil's Advocate: Does Pakistan need a national language?
1:29:51 Is Urdu more alive in #India than Pakistan?
1:32:14 Who owns Urdu? Hindi, Urdu and Hindustani
1:33:38 "A huge kick in the stomach. It's not dead."
1:34:48 #AmirKhusrau and why the poets wrote in Persian
1:37:46 Is Urdu a 'Lashkari zaban'? Why Sabri calls it a myth
1:39:35 What we lost when #Persian left, and what migrants lost
1:48:17 Keeping Urdu alive abroad: an online Urdu tutor
1:50:57 Teach Urdu at home: the Urdu-only family meal
1:53:38 What poetry should young Pakistanis read?
1:58:42 Rapid Fire
2:01:58 Closing: Language dies at the dinner table"
#LanguagePolitics #PakistaniLanguages #NationalLanguage #SouthAsia
subalterndesi retweeted
Young people in Pakistan are not less angry than their counterparts elsewhere in Southasia, but their response has not been to occupy public squares, build movements or attempt to transform the political system. Rather, as one student put it, “it is to acquire a passport, apply for a visa, sit an English-language test and leave as early as possible. When almost every door is shut on us, we must look for doors that are still open.”
Salman Rafi Sheikh (@Salman_Sh1987) writes that growing authoritarianism, the military’s expanding political influence and restrictions on political expression have made young people increasingly fearful and wanting to leave the country: himalmag.com/pakistan-youth-…
The day you remove this kind of political pressure and visa restrictions, you would see Indian and Pakistani public flow into each other's countries unrestricted.
The end to India-Pakistan hostilities, if it ever comes, would be more akin to the fall of the Berlin wall than anything else.


























