
Cabinetmaker, Health recovery đ #NoSugar How will we feed the UK+?
Catford, London, England
Joined March 2011
- Tweets3.4K
- Following554
- Followers285
- Likes10.9K
Lori Winters retweeted
If the standard American diet were a clinical trial, would it be considered ethical?
Lori Winters retweeted
Iâm often asked how we could feed the nation low carb ? Well we waste 99,000 hectares of land producing sugar ! âempty caloriesâ and addictive into the bargain!!
I see growing sugar as similar to being a tobacco farmer . Is that too harsh? @DoctorChrisVT @herdyshepherd1
Lori Winters retweeted
NEWSFLASH!! Our UK NHS low carb clinic is to get NATIONAL news coverage!! Friday Jan 3rd 7 pm @itvnews Thanks to @Oliviaguthrietv PLEASE RETWEET & TUNE IN TO FIND OUT WHY đđ
Lori Winters retweeted
I just nominated Public Health Collaboration movementforgood.com/index.ph⊠. Please join in nominating @PHCukorg and help us win £1000!
Lori Winters retweeted
Replying to @doctor_oxford
Imagine if the thought, energy, passion and scrutiny - in Parliament, in the media and in public - that is going into the assisted dying Bill went into improving palliative care for the âordinaryâ 500,000 people who die each yearâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
A tried and tested diet that can also sort: Weight, Blood pressure, Liver Function, Triglyceride levels and more! I have published on all these and made significant savings on our NHS drug budget. Imagine if we had a tablet that could do all of that!! nutrition.bmj.com/content/eaâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
Low carb diet for diabetes NOT a modern âfadâ! First published case of drug free T2D remission was 228 years ago in 1796 It still works today Just eat nutrient dense food that doesnât spike your blood sugar đđ
Lori Winters retweeted
Thanks Nick! We were going to do a video emphasizing how this study in no way accurately implicates red meat as a cause of type 2 DM. But Nick did a thorough analysis for us. It's worth a read. Our take: Following a low carb diet with plenty of red meat can treat diabetes, not cause it.
đ€ANOTHER ONE!? Study Claims Red Meat Linked to Diabetes. Letâs digest, againâŠ
This meta-analysis included 31 cohorts from regions across the globe and used individual participant level data to determine Hazards Ratios (HR) for the associations between unprocessed red meat, processed red meat, and poultry.
Here I will focus on the unprocessed red meat findings since I think theyâre of greatest physiological interest.
đšFindings
đUnprocessed red meat consumption was associated with a HR of 1.10 for T2D per 100g red meat intake.
Thatâs small.
đThere was a large degree of heterogeneity across studies.
đšVisualizing Heterogeneity
You donât need a professional degree to see this. If a given row has a horizontal black line that crosses the vertical black line perpendicular to 1.0, the results of that study were not significant.
So, for example, if you look at Europe as a region, there are 9 studies included. Only 1 of 9 found a significant association between unprocessed red meat and diabetes.
And, if a given black square is to the left of the vertical solid black line, it means there was a trend towards a negative association between meat intake and diabetes, e.g. the SUN in European group.
đšâBut itâs a Metaâ
Of course, the immediate counterpoint is âbut itâs a meta-analysis.â
Otherwise put, one could argue that, while there is heterogeneity and many studies might have negative findings, the aggregate of studies is more likely to reveal the truth.
However, mixing different studies on distinct populations also sacrifices specificity and has the potential to muddy the waters. This is an implicit limitation of meta-analyses. So, while itâs possible a meta can help provide clarity where there are conflicting data, it can also obscure âtruthâ by the process of lumping different studies with different methods and different confounders etc.
My opinion stated simply:
Metas donât necessarily represent a great truth⊠they can also be used to reinforce a deception⊠just with more perceived academic muscle
đšWhy I Remain Skeptical
The triad of
(i) a small effect size +
(ii) large heterogeneity +
(iii) clear confounders
Should already raise a red flag.
Of course, thereâs a potential contribution of healthy user bias, including BMI as one manifestion of healthy user bias, etc.
Importantly, the study does analysis with and without adjustments for BMI, with adjustment for BMI lowering the effect size. This consistent with the idea there is healthy user bias â not at all a surprise. And itâs important to acknowledge that these biasing factors can never by fully and confidently be accounted for, as the paper itself admitsâŠ
đŁïžâ[T]he observed associations could therefore reflect the bias away from the null owing to ⊠relatively unhealthy lifestyles associated with meat consumption.â
đšBY REGION
Compounding on this, itâs worth noting the effects were attenuated in regions one might expect to have relatively better overall metabolic health.
Specifically, the HR for the association between unprocessed red meat intake and T2D went from small to smaller, at a meager 1.07, when looking at European region vs America.
And, in Eastern Mediterranean, although only 2 studies were included, there was clearly no effect with one of the two studies trending to a negative association.
What I gather from this is further evidence that healthy user bias could be entirely to blame for the net effect seen in the meta. This is possible, when considering all the above factors further framed byâŠ
đšBIOLOGICAL PLAUSIBILITY
Furthermore, I again reinforce the important for scrutinizing biological plausibility.
The paper provides some attempt at presenting possible physiological explanations, e.g. the âhigh intake of animal proteinsâ may increase risk of T2D or gesturing at TMAO, but I didnât find it particularly compelling.
While honest (and I give points for that), repetition of statements like âno definitive effects have been reported,â and âthe exact mechanism is yet to be establish,â etc. reinforces the point that the mechanistic explanations remain extremely shaky, despite an abundance of interest and resources spent on studying this topic.
đšCONCLUSIONS
đ€Arguments that red meat causes diabetes stand on shaky data, at best.
đ€The observed associations may be driven by confounders. Statistical âadjustmentsâ cannot be assumed to fully account for these.
đ€Even if there is an effect, itâs tiny.
By comparison to the HR of 1.10 (with 1.0 representing no increased risk) reported in this study, the Relative Risk for diabetes according to BMI > 30 vs BMI <30 is ~4.44 (Fung TT JAMA IM)
All this is not to claim a causal relationship is "impossible," nor it is a commentary on other relationships re red meat consumption. This thread is specific to the claims at hand regarding Red Meat and Diabetes.
Bottom line, when it comes to diabetes prevention, red meat elimination is not the low hanging fruit
@SukhSandhu @EricTopol @guardian @itvnews @theproof @PlantChompers @KenDBerryMD @SBakerMD @MikhailaFuller
Also, I see a lot of people "jumping" on this one, and it's trending on @X. In choosing what source you want to listen to, consider who is evaluating the data and who is just amplifying the title and abstract and/or citing vanity metrics like the sample size because it might be consistent with their world view. Again, I'm open to the possibility there could be a relationship between red meat and diabetes... but this study and the recent Haem iron study seem to mostly hype feeding the incentive structure of the media and popular health narratives than compelling science.
That's my take, for now.
Lori Winters retweeted
New Scientist: Is it possible to be âaddictedâ to eating unhealthy food? Yes, say a group of doctors and scientists who hosted an ultra processed food addiction conference in central London yesterday including @DoctorChrisVT & @RobertLustigMD hosted by @drjenunwin newscientist.com/article/243âŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
Better Off Dead? review â Liz Carrâs blistering film may well change your mind about assisted dying theguardian.com/tv-and-radioâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
ATTENTION PLEASE!!!!!
Ticket sales closing at 11pm UK time today!!!
Donât miss out!!!
Please retweet đđ»
Everything you need to know about food addiction in one day!!!!
IMPORTANT NEWS!
International Food Addiction Consensus Conference IFACC24
Central London 17 May 2024
Amazing speakers presenting agreement about food addiction diagnosis
Confirmed @RobertLustigMD @MichaelMossC @addunplug @DrNicoleAvena @DrSPThompson @Drdavidwiss & moreâŹïž
1/3
Lori Winters retweeted
This is taking place this afternoon. Join us to ensure disabled people are not further dehumanised and devalued and that our lives count #NoToAS
For those opposed to legalised #assistedsuicide and #euthanasia and in the London area, please make your voices heard next Monday 3pm as MPs debate legalisation.
Lori Winters retweeted
Meat is the only whole food that contains every nutrient we need, in its proper form, without antinutrientsâand it's incapable of causing unhealthy blood sugar spikes.
Let's nourish our brains with the complete nutrition it needs to thrive. đ§
dailymail.co.uk/health/articâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
So many Real Food Runners out this weekend. Spreading the message of avoiding Ultra Processed Food. Are you a Real Food Runner yet?
So many great photos taken this weekend but weâre able to highlight 4 here of Lori Winters who completed her 1st parkrun, the Maidenhead Massive who continue to swell their numbers, @LHAbetteryou and @ascarbs. PBs for Alan Peters and Paul Newcombe đđđ
Lori Winters retweeted
The idea that diet can improve mental health is really grabbing attention How many of you know this is true? Certainly I see people with improved mood and less anxiety in every clinic I do â at North West, England
Thank you @WStoneReports & @NPR for calling the nation's attention to ketogenic diets for mental health.
"I realized it was actually the ketone level that was making this shift in my symptoms in a way that nothing else ever had." - @IainCampbellPhD npr.org/sections/health-shotâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
The Jersey proposal is not limited to terminally ill ("an incurable physical condition, causing unbearable suffering" - read "disabled people") and is for #euthanasia as well as #assistedsuicide. Please sign this petition to stop it. chng.it/TPLVYVZv8j
Lori Winters retweeted
Recent reports from UNEP and FAO have shared more or less radically different visions of food futures.
While some people call for a future without livestock, our research suggests a vital role for pastoral peoples in caring for the land and the rest of nature. #COP28
Climate change & pastoralism #COP28
Debates on the futures of food are hampered by generalised narratives with aggregated statistics that don't account for pastoral systems.
@IanScoones reviews our work from 2018-2023 on challenging these narratives:
pastres.org/2023/12/12/challâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
So these recent headlines about the UN/FAO urging the world to eat less meat for the climate were just a spin, & besides the *actual* message coming out of FAO, showing large mitigation potential from efficiency gains (& only to a very small degree from diets: all animal foods=4%, meat even less)?
Replying to @FAO
@FAO: base year and projected emissions (2050) from livestock systems + mitigation measures.
Reducing consumption of meat, dairy, eggs: 4%
The bulk of the gain is in improved efficiency and production. No surprises really.
fao.org/documents/card/en?deâŠ
Lori Winters retweeted
#Walking this #weekend - don't forget to write about it! Chance of #winning some lovely #prizes in our current walking #writing competition walklistencreate.org/competi⊠Please RT and share with fellow walkers and writers! #writerscommunity #amwriting
Lori Winters retweeted
I teared up watching this, and then got angry.
Put aside whatever you think of @RobertKennedyJr and watch it.
We are feeding our citizens poisoned food by design - itâs immediately fixable. There isnât a more important issue.
Why isnât every politician shouting this message?




































